Aston Villa Rumours Archive July 01 2013 to July 31 2013
Use our rumours form to send us aston villa transfer rumours.
31 Jul 2013 15:41:56
Sky reporting fulham as firm favourites and have put us as in the running for left back aly cissokho although I feel Luna will do well, I would rather use money towards wijnaldum
Josh
(posted about bannan deal braking down)
Believable11
Unbelievable1
*Fulham firm favorite for bent. oops
Josh
Agree9
Disagree1
Why are villa not taking caulker he would be perfect at the back as pre season has shown although very good going forward we still can't defend ticks all of lamberts criteria young and obviously hungry to play if he is going to sign for Cardiff I feel we have missed a trick here
Agree9
Disagree2
We aren't going to be in for cissokho because we have bennett and luna, also caulker is apparently going for around £8million which lambert won't spend on a player like him (btw I do rate caulker highly), the only player he'll spend that much on is our marquee signing e. g. Wijnaldum or Kiotake (forgive me, I forgot how to spell his name)
Agree5
Disagree0
Rumour has it that Wigan are interested in Stephan Ireland, part exchange with Villa to pay Cash as well for James McCarthy ed any truth in this
Agree5
Disagree9
Well seeing as wigan want 20mil for mccarthy we would have to pay 19mil plus ireland then because no way that lazy boy is worth more than a million. so this 'rumour' has clearly been made up
Agree3
Disagree0
31 Jul 2013 14:36:28
Rumoured even amongst the Aston Villa players and staff is that Geroginio Wijnaldum is Paul Lambert's/Fans preferred choice as our Attacking Midfielder.
Faulkner's & Lerner are understood to be undecided if to make their move now or wait until finalizing the Bent exit.
Personally I'd say just take a leaf outta Nike's book and JUST DO IT!
This a a top player in the making, exciting/skillful/technically gifted/unpredictable with loads of room for improvement.
I also believe we already have cover for him in the mould of Samir Carruthers
Believable11
Unbelievable1
Id like to see Carruthers have a run in the side from the beginning of the season. Throwing the lad in the deep end could be the making of him. The last thing we won't is him turning out like Bannan and never producing what was once promising.
Agree9
Disagree0
I would love this to be true but I can't see it. We have too many members if the Bomb Squad that we can't get rid of
Agree5
Disagree1
With the breakdown of moves for bannan and hutton over personal terms do we have a club of greedy *******s?
Agree9
Disagree0
Wijnaldum is more than a prospect he is a amazing talent he really does have everything he can go past people, score with either foot and is brilliant in the air he has been linked with us through both our scouts and vlaar I understand some talks have been held and he is keen but we are as said in previous posts waiting to free up the transfer funds
Agree7
Disagree0
Personally I think we will go back in with a final10m bid for kiyotake and see if the German outfit arms twisted. Kiyotake would be my preferred choice, proven in a better league, more of a consistent performer and a good player for marketing an PR.
Finch
Agree4
Disagree2
30 Jul 2013 23:41:16
Ex Arsenal man Havard Nordtveit is apparently a target for Paul Lambert according various reports, also we're apparently closing in on an unnamed player from FC Twente, guesses are it could be Tadic or Castaignos so far, both strikers mind - replacement for Bent?
Believable3
Unbelievable9
Helenius is bents replacement
Agree11
Disagree2
Tadic is more winger/attacking midfielder so he would be the more realistic target as I don't think another striker is needed. weimann, benteke, helenius with other players like gabby who can play up front if needed. tadic is strong and skllfull would be good for us but I must say i'm getting caught up in the Wijnaldum hype and hope we manage to sign him. as far as I know thers no definite proof we are even going to approch either player. this waiting to offload players is killing me. guess some of the players (bannan, hutton, ireland etc. ) are just upset to realise they aren't good enough for top flight football. bent is a great signing to any club for 6 million don't see how that still hasn't been done
kev
Agree4
Disagree3
Havard Nordtveit will NOT be sold, he is just establishing himself at Borussia Mönchengladbach, so there is no way he will leave.
Agree5
Disagree2
Tadic is a £10m - £12m player and we simply won't buy him, as good as he is and as outrageous as his left foot is, we can't afford his weaker right foot
Agree4
Disagree1
30 Jul 2013 21:53:11
According to a link at newsnow Fulham have increased their offer for Darren Bent to 6mil.
Hope its true, the bloke needs a new club so he can move on in his career.
Good for us as well?
villadave
Believable10
Unbelievable2
30 Jul 2013 19:27:46
from inside villa park rodwell done deal lone with view to buy for 10 million next summer. will be in general press by friday.
Kingvilla
Believable4
Unbelievable14
Can anyone else confirm/deny this rumour? I don't see why we need another CM, but don't get me wrong I like the guy, think he's got a lot to offer
Agree7
Disagree3
I'd be happy with this as long as he stays fit, but I'm already happy with our midfield, can't see 10 million being enough as city paid 15, and doubt lambert would take a risk on his fitness
Agree8
Disagree3
So no Steven Defour or Van De Vaart as you were equally confidently predicting a few days ago then?
I think you are having what you believe to be a laugh at real fans expense mate
Agree7
Disagree1
Kingvilla.
Not sure as I would go along with this one, after all he is not the AMF we need.
He is a strong powerful player, but does not score that often.
If it is true so be it, but would not be my choice.
villadave
Agree4
Disagree1
Sorry but just don't see the fuss about Rodwell when he is actually fit enough to play
Agree2
Disagree7
Yep me too mate rodwell is so NOT what we need.
Agree4
Disagree6
So its friday and?.
Agree1
Disagree0
30 Jul 2013 16:04:04
Bannan deal to Blackburn has broken down over personal terms
Believable12
Unbelievable1
The vile little scot thinks he is Messi.
Agree4
Disagree2
The boy still thinks his Dolce and Gabbana but you are becoming Desperate and Grabbing. Does he really think Real Madrid are going to turn to him if they don't get Bale? Your service has been appreciated but sign the Blackburn deal lad, otherwise you will be keeping the bench warm for the development squad.
Agree5
Disagree0
Do one bannan, your average at best and in my opinion Blackburn are too good for you so grab it with both hands or you could find yourself with given and bone idle Ireland on your way to Doncaster! Now off you pop!
Agree5
Disagree3
30 Jul 2013 02:09:43
Ed, any truth in Wijnaldum being aston villa final purchase, although a work in progress he apparently has outstanding ability branded the new ronaldinho at 17yrs old, yet to fulfill that promise maybe villa park is the place to do it, also fits PL age & wage criteria appox £6 - 7mill {Ed001's Note - I was told you were needing to sell before any more moves would be made, or at least get players like Ireland and Bent off the wage bill in some way. Wijnaldum is an option that was scouted throughout last season, to take the position N'Zogbia filled towards the end of the season behind the strikers. So it is certainly possible you could move for him, but I know of nothing being done yet, I will ask around though.}
Believable8
Unbelievable2
Wijnaldum is no Ronaldinho but he's already a very good player an will get better. He'll cost more than £6m-£7m, more like £10m-£12m
>Scg87
Agree14
Disagree3
I think we should get wijnaldum in asap because what I've seen of him he looks a really good player and got real potential
avfc 4 life
Agree13
Disagree1
Ed, I like your sources, at least there's a few of us who can really tell and know what's going on. I'm being informed that for now, noone is coming in imminently, however this will change if and when Bent leaves the club. In addition to Bent, Bannan, Ireland and Given will be leaving before the window is up, however certain snags and issues have arose. Given is wanting top flight football still if he can get it and I understand that - he's always been a true pro! But Bannan and Ireland are wanting far too much money and think they are better than they really are, no desire to want to go and play again and kick start their careers. Asking for far too much from both suitors and AV. Hutton is another one and it finally makes us realise how personic MON was with wages and player status's. Life under Lambert at Villa is sensational in respect to this and where we have come and I am aware that he has targets in mind and very much in position to act upon when the clearance begins. Bent will leave this week I think, seems to be going down the right track again. But Hutton and Ireland (Bannan not too fussed about - on 20k a week) are proving stubborn unprofessionals. We'll see. Again though, linked with Wijanldum and these are correct, something could very well happen here as scouts have been keeping a close eye on him all pre season.
Azza
Agree3
Disagree3
Villa keen on hi-jacking soloman kalou deal with west ham. could be a perfect number 10 for Under £3mil, wages £30k?
Agree1
Disagree11
If we can manage to get wijnaldum our sqaud will be complete and ready for the season. very impressed with lambert and all of aston villa for making great bargain signings. I've watched all preseason and although its little to go on each signing looks a great player. I don't think we will even be looking at the bottom of the table this season!
Agree2
Disagree3
Bad news as the little rat barry bannan fails to agree terms with blackburn. I am not surprised as I think all of our outcasts will be happy to never get a game again for us as long as they get their nice wage. w***ers the lot of them.
mallorca also halting their pursuit of alan hutton another greedy b***ard.
no more incoming transfer activity unless these money grabbers get shifted and its looking increasingly unlikely that we will.
and whoever is using my name please get a different one, thanks
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree2
Disagree1
Id take Kalou but I heard a rumour he wanted 80k a week to go the Albion, so couldn't see us getting him on 30k. tv are also reporting he has been backed into 1/4 to join Valencia (obvious choice with the weather and lure of European football)
Gilly
Agree0
Disagree5
Azza
I'd love to believe you that we are after Wijnaldum but my faith is a little shaken by the fact that MON signed none of the players you talk about in your post!
Agree4
Disagree1
I apologise mate for the misprint! I should have put McLeish in there alongside MON, specifying it was down to these two that we had very average players on massive status and wages! Accept my apology, its been a long day! Wijnaldum is not a definite future signing, but a promising link for sure! I know PL is keen, but like I have always said, we shall see! Apologise for the misunderstanding again, whoever you are.
Azza
Agree4
Disagree0
I cringe that people still slaughter MON. Yes he made some dud signings as most managers do but he made some great signings too! I doubt the same people questioned his signings when we were challenging for cups and qualifying for Europe. It was necessary at that time to pay decent wages for us to push on and improve from the DOL days
When will fans just talk about the present and the sterling job Lambert is doing.
It's the here and now that matters.
Agree3
Disagree4
Ultimately mate, MON never got us higher than 6th, a feat that the much maligned O'leary managed in his first full season after spending about £4 million
It could be argued, from that perspective, that MON spent a fortune to stand still and damaged the club for several subsequent years in the process
Oh yeah, and the football at home was bloody awful
I agree with you on one thing though, it's the here and now that matters most
Let's not rewrite history in the process though
Agree2
Disagree1
Mendax
I may be wrong but are you stating that the job done by MON was on a par with O'Leary on the basis that the best finish either manager achieved was 6th? If this is the case I strongly disagree.
Great European nights, Wembley appearances, beating Manchester United at Old Trafford, destroying the Blues, 7 away victoties on the bounce, figthing in the top four for the majority of the season and recruiting players such as Young, Milner, Carew and Friedel. For me these are just a few things why MON more then outweighs O'Leary in the jobs they did for us.
And to suggest we stood still from O'Leary to MON is again ridiculous as highlighted above.
I could argue all day about this as I truely believe MON did a fantastic job for us and fervently believe Lambert, who has a lot of similar traits to MON is a star manager in the making.
Agree0
Disagree4
MON done a good job at villa spending a hell of a lot of money, so we achieved the minimum of what was expected, I wouldn't be overly critical but I do think with the money he spent we should have got top 4 atleast once. An I do wonder why he gave huge wages to players who were old enough to be grandads lol eg Beye an Heskey
>Scg87
Agree6
Disagree0
29 Jul 2013 11:29:38
Paul lambert wants 3 more players in by the end of the window. A defender that can play at centre back and right back to cover both positions with christian zapata his no 1 target. a ball winning solid midfielder who is strong defence wish but has an eye for a pass with his top target being steven defour. And a attacking play maker num 10 type. with 2 players in mind and will depend how quick and how many of our not needed players can be got off the wage bill. If we csn shift bent given ireland bannan lambert wants to bring in rafa van der varrt as he sees his prem experience as a plus and would help the clubs young lions. The other option on a less wage fitting with our new pay stuc is a young Brazil player dudo.
Kingvilla
Believable3
Unbelievable13
Wow van der vaart now there's a name!
Agree7
Disagree4
Zapata has signed for Milan in May
Agree6
Disagree3
You're stuck in 2008 mate
Agree12
Disagree2
That is absolute tosh- VDV would want at least 60k per week. we should be looking at the likes of A mvuemba from Lyon
Agree8
Disagree1
James McCarthy fits the mold young enthusiastic hard worker get him in lam
Agree4
Disagree6
Dimitri Payet would be a good shout- available for around 8-9mil, quick and young (ish)
Agree2
Disagree2
James McCarthy would cost somewhere in between £12million-£15million at least. definatly not worth that much, not yet anyway.
Agree8
Disagree2
I have to dismiss this as total garbage.
zapata only just signed (permanently) for AC and as for van der vaart we will never pay 60ish grand a week to someone whos over 30 and way past his peak.
get real dude.
the james mccarthy shout above is a no-goer too as wigan want 20mil. he isn't even worth half that in my eyes.
any REAL rumours with proper foundations guys?
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree6
Disagree2
James McCarty would be ideal. He is a class young player with real potential. He a good season.
Agree3
Disagree4
James McCarthy would be great, however he would be fairly expensive. our future and prospective marque signing?! Who knows! But from my contacts I have nit heard his name being mentioned at all, as yet.
Azza
Agree3
Disagree2
Dimitri Payet has just joined Marseille
Agree2
Disagree1
Are people forgetting we have bought 6 players?
I don't think we will sign any more. Lambert has got all his business in early so the team have time to gel. Maybe we may get an AM if we offload the likes of Bent Ireland Given etc but that will surely be it
Agree1
Disagree3
Surely we want someone like Bridcutt from Brighton in DM?
Agree3
Disagree6
The fact you said PL is targeting Defour as the man to fil the DM role makes me think your talking absolute nonsense, Defour is not a DM, I'd hope PL knows that.
>Scg87
Agree10
Disagree2
Sorry to say it, but I don't know who this Kingsvilla is but your information is appalling. Do you even work in football? I'm one amongst many trying to offer fellow avfc fans an insight and your throwing names like Zapata, Defour and Dudo out there?! let's get serious now! Man alive.
Azza
Agree5
Disagree2
Yes I work in football very close to aston villa. Closer than most anyway and just share my rumors I here. It is after all a rumor site. Somr come off some dont. Rodwell will sign on lone as I stated other day. Be done by end oof next week.
Kingvilla
Agree0
Disagree6
How can you share rumours when Zapata signed for AC Milan in May? how can that be a rumour by you when it is a fact
Agree6
Disagree1
29 Jul 2013 09:14:41
Fulham are back in for Darren Bent. Newcastle are still pondering a confirmed move for him as they are believed to be favoring Gomis and Remy. However, Fulham have struggled to sign Osvaldo of Roma, and so switching attentions back to Bent. Expect an offer of around £6m to come in very soon for Bent with a positive outcome this time round. Darren is 'frustrated' and he wishes something to be sorted asap. Fair play to the lad and good luck I say. On other issues, PL has identified an AM as his main transfer target now, with Wijnaldum and Will Hughes his two top ideals. We shall see. I think we can expect to see a new RB and another CB also to arrive. RB, as I've been saying for a long time now (Kingsvilla?!) I think will be Serge Aurier (not Aurtor Kingsvilla!). Exciting times at avfc!
Azza
Believable3
Unbelievable4
I thought aurier was going to spurs
Agree1
Disagree7
28 Jul 2013 09:06:46
Leaked news from villa scouting team.
No1 priority from Paul Lambert is to get a Quality Attacking Midfielder.
Nobody really knows who is on the shortlist.
This is not a rumour but fact, HoweverGeorginio Wijnaldum seen talking to our scout as recommended by Bacuna
Believable6
Unbelievable7
Wijnaldum is a terrific PROSPECT he is no where near developed enough to be expected to take on a huge role in my opinion.
I have mentioned it before, he has a very high ceiling and has oodles of ability.
Polar opposite to someone like Dempsey for example (who has also been mentioned in another rumour below).
I have to make myself clear, I am a big fan of the lad, but it would worry me slightly that he might be thrust into what I would consider "the missing link" role for us.
Massive upside might be enough to sway Lambert and I wouldn't be over critical if we went through with it as I trust Lambert.
Leroy
Agree4
Disagree5
Wijnaldum would be the perfect signing I think, paul lamberts type of player too.
does anyone know if the newport county game is on avtv or if there is anywhere to watch it?
Agree3
Disagree3
To Leroy. I agree with most of your posts especially when things are eloquently put with intelligence rather than a follow on diplomacy of already existing media waffle.
But the question is who would you recommend if given the chance a marquee signing of high ability/prospect AM under 24yrs
Agree6
Disagree2
I seriously believe grealish will be a superstar and save the club a potential 20 million purchase the boy is that good I went down and watched him yesterday against newport and the boy was on another planet to everybody else newport resorted to just kicking him and he still wanted the ball all the time I can't wait to see him break through to the 1st team
Agree5
Disagree1
I have commented in the past about how good Grealish will be, the kid has a huge amout of talent. I regret to say I haven't watched him so much recently, would you now say he is ready to step into the first team this season?
Agree2
Disagree2
I think he should definitely be dipped in and out of the 1st team this season he took a few whacks yesterday and was more than up to the physical battle I was very impressed
Agree1
Disagree2
Hello to the above commenter. and thanks (i think :)) for the feedback.
If I was given between 10-15mil (as that is what I consider the minimum amount it would take to obtain a marquee signing in today´s market), I would attempt to bring in one of the following -
Son Heung Min (Hamburg)
Totally two footed, ridiculously high work rate, great motor and already 13 caps for South Korea. Recently was purchased however and signed a 4 year deal.
Regardless, he is amazingly skilled and lethal in front of goal and very versatile. Will be a star.
Florian Thauvin (Lille)
10 goals from midfield in Ligue 1 (probably the most obtainable and cheapest option listed here - Arsenal sniffing around).
Adem Ljajic (Fiorentina)
Some may remember him from a bungled transfer that never went through with Man U as the terms were being investigated by FIFA.
8 goals 8 assists this season past and is a real playmaker with excellent passing range. Potentially a trouble maker though as he has been involved in a few controversies including refusing to sing the Serbian national anthem before one game and abusing his then coach.
Skill is certainly there to be seen.
Erik Lamela (Roma)
15 goals from the attacking midfield position and has great tenacity ala Suarez. deadly in front of goal and excellent dribbling skills which allows him to take on almost any defender one on one.
These guys I think can be difference makers and I would probably add Wijnaldum to the list as I really do rate him.
Soon is the best player of this bunch, but it is higher unlikely/near impossible to obtain him I think.
For some reason I watch a bit of La Serie A despite the style, I have actually grown quite fond of it as there is a lot of drama and is pretty entertaining. I will expect many to give me stick about it, but I stand by it :)
Leroy
Agree4
Disagree11
Cheers Leroy, as ever very astute/informed and summarized. Much obliged.
Every player named would definitely add some positive attacking influence. Villa are now a team waiting for a catalyst an enigma of a number 10 AM diverse two footed with the ability to make things happen let's hope we get it.
Agree7
Disagree1
Everybody knows its the one thing we are missing, from paul lambert, to the clueless daily fail. I just hope we can get somebody in at least by the liverpool game if not before. I have a lot of trust in lambert but I really hope he doesn't go too risky, we don't need a huge name, but somebody that will clearly make a difference and add a completely new dimension to our game. I also hope the guy we bring in can strike a decent free kick as well, as I can't rememer us scoring directly from a free kick since ashley young played for us (please remind if we have)
Agree1
Disagree1
Hi Leroy
I am not trying to be a smartarse here I promise you, just genuinely interested
How do you know so much about these players?
Do you really watch all these leagues?
I think if we are to get players like this we need to get in early, as we did with Benteke
Agree0
Disagree0
Last time we scored from a free kick I believe was Charles nzogbia
Agree2
Disagree1
Son and Lamela aren't realistic targets, especially not at that price.
Agree5
Disagree2
Westwood scored a freekick a week ago. friendly but still. we need a david silva type player obviously not silva. I like Jano Ananidze but he recently went out on loan I think. someone who thrives on assists is needed
kev
Agree2
Disagree1
Yep n'zogbia v west ham such a crucial goal at villa park in a 2-1 win
Agree3
Disagree1
Oh yes I totally forgot! Thanks for refreshing my memory, but you know somethings wrong when you have to strain to remember one.
Agree2
Disagree1
Mendax, its the culmination of having a real interest in football (and indeed just about all sports) and having a very understanding missus :)
I just stream all kinds of matches over a weekend, watch highlights etc. i'm pissed that tv has had an injunction set in place to see that streaming site "firstrowsports" will be prosecuted if they stream the premier league.
Might have to turn to the dark side and subscribe to AVTV : (
Leroy
Agree1
Disagree1
PS I would love to ask for the person or persons that disagree with my opinion of who I would try and spend 15mil on for an attacking midfielder, to state their opinion or perhaps even give some constructive criticism.
Perhaps even offer up some names of his own?
Leroy
Agree0
Disagree0
Leroy, the players you mentioned would be welcome at villa and you defo gave a great scouting report on them but Lamela and Min are completely unrealistic. Lamela will probably cost £20m and ask yourself if he'd come to us, when most think will be still fighting relegation and Roma will be competing for Serie A.
The others you talked of would be more of a gamble an are more about potential than current ability.
I'd take Wijnaldum over all of the players you named, purely because I think he'd give us more flair and unpredictability than the others
in saying all that, I find it hard to believe we'll sign any player for more than £8m which would rule out wijnaldum and others named. Capoue who isn't a flamboyant AM but is a fantastic all round CM and is available for £9m apparently who I think would make all the difference for us, yet we're not interested.
>Scg87
Agree6
Disagree1
Scg87 - really cool to hear you opinions and I agree entirely actually. I was asked (by someone without a name) who I would purchase as a marquee signing under the age of 24.
I gave my answers based on that and clearly Lamela and Min may require more money than 15mil.
Im not at all interested in this "agree"/"disagree" aspect of this site, ala "liking" something on . to me its meaningless, I am here for the banter and opinion from fellow Villa fans.
So thanks for sharing, you made excellent points of which I am in agreement with each of them.
I would also add, that just about any player at 21 years of age is a gamble. I mean, we were told not so long ago that Barry Bannan was the next coming of Xavi/Iniesta, now we can't even get rid for 750k! :)
Same as Benteke could falter (although it doesn't look as though it will happen) and go through a "sophomore slump" as they call it.
Leroy
Agree3
Disagree0
28 Jul 2013 09:02:28
Some rumours are suggesting Dempsey might be coming to AVFC in an 8m deal
Believable2
Unbelievable11
So by Levy´s rules we should expect to pay 5/6mil max then ;)
Leroy
Agree2
Disagree1
8 million for that clown Dempsey?
Someone has been drinking the meths again.
Clarrie Blue.
Agree5
Disagree2
Great results again boys against new football league members newport county 5-2 defeat. ridiculous
Agree3
Disagree9
It was an under 21 game, hardly anything to get worked up about. No 1st teamers played
Agree8
Disagree1
So plenty of promise coming through the ranks then (not)
Agree1
Disagree6
Some Villa fans are as bad as tv FFS! It was an academy development squad game and the highest named player was Jack Grealish. Petrov managed the team and no first team players went! It was on the avfc website as a development game for months. Just stop with the negative and false comments. Clearly no faith in the avfc system. It was boys versus men at Newport and if you actually watched the game anyway, despite a crazy 15 minutes in the second half, Our young lions were actually very good! Very good. Promising for the future that's for sure!
Azza
Agree4
Disagree2
I don't care what anyone says, if our best youth players are getting caned by awful, part time opposition, then there's not a lot to look forward to is there?
how is stating that we lost 5-2 to newport 'false'? its exactly what happened and as I said in 1st post its ridiculous we should be killin such rubbish teams, even with our u21s.
Agree1
Disagree6
Most of the players on the pitch have never played a competitive professional game in their life, seriously you need to give your head a wobble and learn about football! I bet you weren't complaining when they became the champions of europe a few months ago!
Agree2
Disagree0
Totally agree ethAVFC. the above you comment needs to watch football and learn the game properly!
Azza
Agree3
Disagree0
To condemn a whole generation of players off the back of one result is absolutely ridiculous
Clearly you have not been watching football long enough. If you had, you would know that players, Eevn Messi and Ronaldo, can be inconsistent and young players particularly so
Agree2
Disagree0
27 Jul 2013 20:12:45
just been told very interesting little rumour. Villa have asked about the availability of jack rodwell and want to take him on a season long lone due to fitness worrys with view to a 10 million deal next summer. Rodwell would do well for the villa sitting deep and his passing ability if we can keep him fit. I hope this one happens tbh.
Kingvilla
Believable7
Unbelievable10
If it's true and he can stay fit, that would be a really great bit of business
Perfect for us
Agree7
Disagree4
Interesting, i'm doubting the likeliness though
Agree6
Disagree2
Jack rodwell would be a perfectmove he's young talented and would add a bit of creativity to the cm position him and Sylla would be a perfect combination
Agree4
Disagree2
Would prefer other targets due to the fact you can't get more than 10 games out of him in a season.
Agree2
Disagree2
To be honest, I think we need someone with a bit better health record than Rodwell.
Whilst his talent is unquestioned he is injured time and time again.
Its a disaster waiting to happen I feel.
I don't mind the Wijnaldum shout, as he has bundles of potential, but he is not the finished article by any stretch of the imagination.
Leroy
Agree3
Disagree1
The Rodwell rumour and the Dempsey rumour are absolutely false. No interest from avfc or PL in either of them!
Azza
Agree3
Disagree0
27 Jul 2013 07:00:50
Paul lambert to look into signing defensive midfield players steven defour or miguel veloso to add a bit of steel and experience to a young villa side. Veloso is thought to be the more realistic target and would cost the villa around 12-15 mil mark. I've also herd a little rumor that we after serge aurtor a young ivory cost right back who is highly rated and would come as direct competition to matty lowton.
Kingvilla
Believable4
Unbelievable8
Both these people wer targets for villa a few years ago. hope its true!
kev
Agree3
Disagree5
Both players respectively are champions league level players and would he a massive coup if we were able to obtain one of there services, as for the youngster, if PL thinks he's got potential, then the kid has got what it takes. In Lambert we trust.
Agree6
Disagree2
Days are gone when we spend 12-15m on one player so can't see much in this tbh and with ireland nzog bent bannan stil on the books I think pl will maybe be allowed to get one more lad in but can't see him paying more than 3-4m
Agree8
Disagree3
Why do we need another defensive mid? We have westwood, Delph, Sylla, gardner, herd and el ahmadi, who are all are capable of playing well at defensive mid. If anything we need an attacking mid to link up the play.
Agree5
Disagree3
It seems that we'll be stuck with bent after Newcastle tabled bids for gomis and remy in the last 6 hours! Along with Fulham out it's going to be difficult to get shot of him now!
Agree7
Disagree1
Both good players.
Defour is not a DM
Veloso can play as a DM, CB an fullback so would come in handy
Agree5
Disagree1
Personally I'd rather we sign a proper DM. Delph is never a DM. Westwood might be a deep lying CM but he doesn't have the qualities to do a DM job. Gardner is better going forward. Herd an Karim are just not good enough to play as our DM.
We need a DM who's a physical presence, aggressive, wins tackles, reads danger, can play a pass an who leads by example, sylla may well do that in the future but I don't think he can do that consistently this season.
Almost every game last season the opposition had to much space an time on the ball to do what ever they wanted to do, unless we solve that problem then the same thing will happen this season.
>Scg87
Agree6
Disagree2
Since whens defour been a defensive midfielder?!
Both unrealistic targets regardless.
Finch
Agree7
Disagree1
Not the best info I've heard as they would be way too much in terms of price so no go their. and the ivory coast you mean is serge aurier of toulouse he would cost at least £8m, c'mon be serious dude.
Agree1
Disagree1
Westwood &, Delph I tend to think of as all round midfielder players who are not awful midfield players but not great either. Sylla is raw and seems to be improving and yes I would agree, he is a defensive player. Gardner has been injured for a year, has little experience and is an attacking midfield player. We should use him sparingly this year to make sure he can become the player we believe he can be. Herd and El Ahmadi are just not good enough. Herd is too reckless and El Ahmadi looks like he has been on the crack pipe 10 minutes before he comes on the pitch
In an ideal world I would get rid of those 2, plus Bannan and Nzog and buy a top class defensive player and a goal scoring creative player
We have quantity of midfield players, what we lack is quality
Agree3
Disagree6
Sorry Mendax I disagree with your opinions on Westwood and Delph. For me both are quality and are justifiably our first choice pairing.
I do believe that a No 10 player though is required
Agree4
Disagree3
Hi Mendax.
I have to agree with most of what you say.
But I have to disagree somewhat concerning Westwood, I think Westwood is a very good player and getting better all the time.
Now he has found his feet in the prem I believe he will go on to be a very important piece in PL team.
He is important now, and I think he will become part of the England set up within 18 months, if injury free.
villadave
Agree4
Disagree1
Celtic have reportedly registered an interest in Darren Bent
Agree1
Disagree3
Blimey, this is a turn up for the book, Scg87, Finch & Mendax posting together, brings me back to a few months ago when all we seemed to discuss was the xmas period, PL's ability, relegation and the best midfield options and we still don't know the best options? but as then, for what it's worth, I think Gardner deserves a crack at it. Hopefully this term, less counter attack and more possession. P. S> keep up the positive posting guys.
Agree3
Disagree1
We are the best counter attacking team in the league so if we sacrifice a bit of posession then so be it but I agree we need to bring in a number 10 type player who can offer something a bit different
Agree3
Disagree2
I disagree with myself as well actually!
What I meant to say was that neither Westwood nor Delph were not awful "defensive" midfield players
I actually like both of them, I just don't I wouldn't want either of them playing a purely defensive role
Agree2
Disagree0
Mendax I understand what you mean, I don't really like it that westwood sits in front of the defence, because let's face it he's not exactly going to provide any extra coverage for the back four. i'd prefer sylla to sit in front of the back four, and for westwood to go forward 15/20 yards. It would mean westwood has less room to play a massive variety of passes but at the same time he will be able to play his passes straight into the forwards and in all honesty, he could link the midfield to the strikforce very well. Perhaps providing the missing link that would come with the all important attacking mid we all desperately want.
Agree2
Disagree2
Mendax.
Not to worry mate, I disagree with myself every day.
What you have followed up with sounds better.
But we still need that AMF like Dempsey used to do for Fulham.
villadave
Agree2
Disagree1
Totally agree with Scg87, Our frailties for much of last season lay inbetween the defence and midfield. Sylla who is on the back of my villa shirt this season changed that for us, I believe he can go on to be a top player in the prem but would like to see some competition for his place and unsure that johnson/clark (who I see as our only other options) will be able to step up to fill the void.
One thing that's really bugged me in preseason is that we'r still conceeding from corners. Preseason or not that's not a good sign considering the quality of delivery from a prem team is far greater than the likes of wycombe or luton respectively.
I actually think KEA has something to offer and hasn't shown his full potential as yet.
Westy could go on to show how good a player he is in an england shirt and delph IS improving.
Gardner and Albrighton need to get 100% fit.
Bannan and Ireland need to get the lamb chop out of the club, I think i'd keep the zog as a game changing sub.
And with the additions of Bacuna as I see as perfect competition for delph and Tonev for when the formation needs width we have a solid midfield but not a great one.
Finch
Agree1
Disagree2
26 Jul 2013 07:21:09
hull, palace mulling over nzogbia
Believable5
Unbelievable8
Absolutely nothing will come of this. They won't sign him before the transfer window closes as he is injured long term. It's only us that sign crocked players e. g. Downing.
Agree6
Disagree5
N'Zogbia will be in the Villa team next season - Bent got number 39 when he first joined Villa - team numbers mean nothing!
Agree6
Disagree7
Bent joined in january squad numbers were already set, he got what was left
Agree8
Disagree3
Bent joined in January! They are not just going to change the player numbers half way through a season. Even if he wanted the no. 9 he had to wait until the new season. Player numbers only change at the start of the season!
Agree10
Disagree1
The #9 shirt at the time was just vacated by John Carew. So it was open mate if Bent wanted it!
Agree2
Disagree5
John Carew had the number 10 when he was at villa
Agree7
Disagree1
Stevie Ireland was no 9 that season else Benty would have snapped it up. N'Zogbia is a goner once he's fit in January if not before. I agree squad numbers aren't the b all and end all but I think they give u a very good idea
Agree4
Disagree1
Carew was never No 9. that was Harewood
Agree5
Disagree0
Before bent joined it was stephen ireland who had the no. 9 shirt. and, as correctly stated above, carew was 10
Agree4
Disagree0
I think you will find Stephen Ireland had the no. 9 shirt when Bent arrived
Agree4
Disagree1
25 Jul 2013 17:46:44
Lyon have confirmed they have received 3 bids for Gomis, are we one of them? Would be an amazing signing, just image benteke and gomis-scare all the defences
Believable4
Unbelievable10
We are intrested but have yet to place a bid
Agree5
Disagree8
Gomis, Weimann, Gabby, Tekkers, Helenius - as amazing as that would be, doubt Gomis would want to be a bench boy a bit.
Agree9
Disagree4
Villa should try and hijack cardiffs bid for etienne capoue, he would be a gem in the villa team
Agree8
Disagree3
Would hate to see us waste money on another striker we need to think defensive or creative not another big centre forward
Agree5
Disagree0
Sylla or Capoue it would end up on a match day & I think Sylla would play in all honesty infront of him!
Agree4
Disagree4
Hopefully its not Lyons Gomis we'r looking at but their dmc fofana who would cost around 5m.
Finch
Agree4
Disagree3
Finch,
I agree with you here, Fofana is class! Would fit into the PL system too! Hopefully PL notices this and makes a move. for £5m it's a snippet as well.
Azza
Agree5
Disagree4
Azza glad you agree! My estimation of the player might be off 1 or 2 mill but he's an absolute beast of a player, can tackle, pass, high stamina and is young too. Reminds me of viera.
Finch
Agree4
Disagree1
Remember Fofana had a good game against spurs but forgot about him, if we pick him up that would be some good business
Agree2
Disagree3
We nearly had him in 2011 under houiller but the deal fell through medical reasons I think
Agree2
Disagree2
I was going to say that, I remember we didn't move for him because he wanted money and we already had a host of lads, Hogg, herd, bannan, Delph, gards, johnson, who were breaking through and needed games. I always thought we didn't go for him because we already had players who were his age in his position. Still I'd take him now because Hogg went and bannan will hopefully find a new job. Good link
Agree2
Disagree1
We failed to get him 1st time so we got makoun instead I remember now
Agree1
Disagree0
25 Jul 2013 16:24:17
Villa making enquires about Marco Capuano a CB from Pescara.
Believable6
Unbelievable2
Hope so!
Agree6
Disagree2
Would be an amazing signing would love to see this. there's a few premier league clubs looking him though so wouldn't get my hopes up. on the subject of defenders I think vlarrs goal for wigan last year on the final day should get more recognition it was world class!
kev
Agree7
Disagree1
Caupoe going to Cardiff
Agree3
Disagree2
Sure this guy means capoue NOT capuano the brescia defender who'd be an awesome addition and would replace vlaar in starting 11 slipping in alongside beastly baker
Agree3
Disagree5
Baker and capouno. no confidence in Vlaar and Okore then?
Agree3
Disagree2
No confidence in vlaar and from what I have seen capuano would slip easier into the side straight away and baker would have to be his partner as he putts his boll*cks on line game after game for AVFC. obviously okore is a gem but may take a bit more time in adapting to the prem. 1 for the future definitely. so yeah capuano and baker for me mate.
JUST AN OPINION
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree3
Disagree4
25 Jul 2013 09:09:30
Steven irelands bentley about to grace Doncaster thank f--k for that
Believable11
Unbelievable3
They won't be paying for 100% of his wages so not really any different for us
Agree10
Disagree6
Aston Villa look set to actually terminate Stephen Ireland's contract with a £1 million pay off to please all concerned
Agree9
Disagree2
Also still failing to get hutton out on loan. couldn't get a deal done with almeria in spain. they probably didn't fancy payin his unjustifiable wage. when ARE we going to get these wasters (ireland, bannan, hutton, etc. ) OUT of VP? needs to be soon or we can kiss goodbye to anymore potential incoming players.
Agree7
Disagree2
Come on PL time to get rid of all these hasbeens and bring in some expensive players 8-12m like Cardiff City or we are definitely going down
Agree4
Disagree12
Blackburn are interested in Bannan but need to ship out Dunn and Givet before they make a bid
Agree6
Disagree1
More misery!
Who cares what Cardiff are doing?! Get a grip!
Agree13
Disagree0
Bannan just not good nothing against the kid but the others are just money grabbing mercanaries who would rather stay and collect their wages
Agree9
Disagree1
To the guy on about cardiff, what do you want us to do? Buy expensive players on high wages like QPR, because that clearly works so well. What we're doing is in my eyes so much better than paying £15m for average players. Take bent for example, we got 5/6 very good players last summer for the same amount of money we spent on bent? Who you rather have in your team, lowton, westwood, benteke and sylla or darren bent? If you're unwilling to wait a few years for success then find another team to support!
Agree11
Disagree1
Well said ethavfc!
Regarding, Hutton I know a deal has been agreed with mallorca but its his agent making the deal stall and making a better pay out for them both. Either way he's definetly on his bike
Finch
Agree6
Disagree2
Baggies, Hull & Cardiff to go down!
Cardiff's squad is still made up of Championship at best players!
Ooo Christian Benteke!
Agree3
Disagree3
Baggies won't go down, I hate to admit it but I think they'll have a good season! Sunderland to go down for me f**k paolo di caniooo!
Agree4
Disagree2
I think stoke will go down they have been awful for a long long time now hate watching them play and if it wasnt for begovic huth and shawcross they woulda gone down a couple of seasons back because the rest of their team is terrible. palace, stoke and either hull or sunderland will be relegated I think
Villa should finish between 8th-12th
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree4
Disagree1
24 Jul 2013 09:00:52
Expect some incomings at VP when Bent and Hutton are shifted out. An AM and a CM are essential, with Kiyotake and Wijnaldum the favourites at present, cover at RB also needed, with Aurier PL's favourite choice. Hopefully following this some good luck with injuries and recoveries, with Bannan and Ireland leaving too!
Azza
Believable11
Unbelievable6
Donacien & Herd can play RB as well as Okore technically.
Love Donacien - really one to watch, massive potential & is a fantastic sprinter! such amazing speed!
Agree11
Disagree3
Not so sure another CM is necessary?
Westwood, Delph, Bacuna, Sylla, Gardner, Carruthers, KEA
Personally can't see PL adding to that.
I think an attacking midfielder is required but suspect this may in the form of another 'unknown' who will not be first choice and will be used as a Plan B.
Agree10
Disagree2
Him being unknown won't make him second choice mate, benteke wasn't exactly a name on everybody's lips and he turned out great. Unknown or not, paul lambert will get a very good player, he has only made one bad signing in joe bennett and I even believe that if somebody tells him he's actually a winger, and motivates him, he can also be a very good player! Lambert is very good at getting players cheap with as much quality as some worth 3/4 times the price. Appointing lambert was the best thing the villa board have done for a long time.
Agree11
Disagree3
I would like either of Kiyotake or Wijnaldum. I think Kiyotake is more proven, yet Wijnaldum has a huge ceiling.
I might be wrong, but I think Bacunda, Sylla and Delph might very well have it covered for us in the middle, in terms of DM.
Bacunda is not as strong winning the ball as Delph or Sylla, but offers much more in attack, showing quite a nice passing game so far.
Delph has come on strong late last season, but I still get the jitters when he lounges in on tackles. Still think he will end someones career sooner or later with his brash tackling style.
Sylla has surprised in the last couple of outings, as he has shown some shooting ability.
I think an attacking player and we are ok. If anything, a towering CB could be brought in, someone in the mould of Samba. i'm extremely nervous about the back four. even without the injuries
Leroy
Agree8
Disagree2
EthAVFC - I didn't mean he would be second choice just because he was an unknown. More that I expect us to play this season as we finished last with the three midfielders all being pretty central and neither sitting or pushing on so on that basis any attacking midfielder would be second choice as not your standard midfielder in the way I see us playing.
By unknown I pretty much mean someone who won't expect to come in and play every game which a 'name' probably would (in the system mentioned above)
I fully support Lambert and his transfer strategy and hope he continues along this route to ensure the future of Villa is bright.
Hope this clarifies.
Agree3
Disagree1
Okay i'm with you now. My apologies, my only worry is that to some extent playing the 3 in midfield like last season doesn't really give us the link between the midfield and the attack, i'm thinking if an attacking mid does come in he will make the team (if he plays well enough) ahead of one of the 3 to provide that link, and also hopefully get a few goals from the midfield, which is something we lack.
Agree3
Disagree0
Lambert will add a few more new faces, especially now Hutton is gone on another season-long loan back to Mallorca with them paying all his wages. It wouldn't surprise me to see Bent go out on loan & hope we can command a better fee next summer if he has a good season at somewhere like Newcastle or Spurs perhaps?
Agree3
Disagree3
Totally agree leroy our defence does look like its going to be leaky again unless Okore really steps up to the plate. Personally i'd like to see another CB signed and Clark to spend a season out on loan.
Finch
Agree6
Disagree3
Agree 100% finch.
Clark is very much a confidence player as he has shown ability before and even nicked a few goals for us. Maybe a loan would allow him to regain that confidence again.
How do you feel about Baker? I'm still unsure about him. He had some catastrophic moments last season that's for sure.
Leroy
Agree5
Disagree1
Baker will fly higher than them all, for me he's our best youth product since gabby, the man has bags of strength, and like all good defenders he will do everything he possibly can to stop the ball going towards the goal, shown with the KO he took when he blocked a shot with his face last season, he's great in the air (6th highest percentage of ariel battles won last season) and can tackle very hard and very well. At the start of last season he did look a little rash going in but he soon sorted it out and in my eyes made himself a serious contender for a few MOTM awards. Clark is a good player but he's no defender if somebody goes up for a header against him he'll lose out every time. And if you look at all the goals conceded from corners it was because clark was stood 4 yards away from HIS man then telling benteke he should have marked him. When baker replaced clark in the team our average points went from 1. 1 to 1. 5, and we conceded a lot less corners. The own goals where bad and a few mistakes where made but every defender with a villa contract made some shocking mistakes last season. I see a lot with baker, and I honestly totally believe he will be an england international, he's going on the back of my shirts this season that's for sure!
Agree10
Disagree3
Baker put his body on the line & stopped anything he could - something called commitment by the lad!
Agree9
Disagree1
Think baker could be top notch given a good run in the team, rate him more than Clark that's for sure!
Agree9
Disagree1
For me baker is our best defender, has a magnet of a head for ariel duels, strong tackler and has decent pace. His passing needs improvement though. In comparison vlaars average, Clark's not a center half and maybe never will be. As for okore I'd give him a go to partner baker at the back but not seen enough of him to have a strong opinion.
Right back is matty lowtons for as long as he wants it, really think he should be pushing for a world cup spot, certainly wouldn't swap him for Glenn johnston. The left back spot is an interesting one as iv seen a lot of Luna and don't rate him, him an bennett will fight all season for that place but I doubt either will hold down the place.
Either way I don't hold much confidence in our defence this season. however the attacking options look frightening and don't really mind watching an attacking team that score goals with a leaky defence as opposed to a team that can keep a clean sheet but can't hit a barn door!
Finch
Agree6
Disagree2
Didnt sign in for the massive comment I put about baker so if any of you care that was me!
Agree2
Disagree2
While I'm not one of Villa's famous doommongers who thinks everything is permanently black, I have to say that NINE injuries after only five low key friendlies against poor opposition is a bit much and doesn't bode well.
No one else seems to get all these never ending injuries and it makes me wonder if our training is in some way responsible. We shall be lucky to have eleven fit players on the pitch at this rate for the Arsenal game.
Agree3
Disagree2
Are we ever going to get rid of our unwanted dead wood?
We currently have no less than SEVEN players we are trying to shift out and there is not one sniff of interest for any of them.
I tell a lie - so far we have had 3 weeks of rumours that Newcastle want to sign Bent but has he gone or is he ever going?
No he isn't. He's STILL here.
Agree2
Disagree1
All valid and well made points in regards to Baker. Again, might just be a confidence thing. I think Baker was even responsible for a couple of own goals also.
T be honest though, as the season wore on, we didn't leak so many goals and we sort of held firm. I will never say a bad word about Bakers commitment, his work rate is exceptional also.
I hope they provide healthy competition for Okore and Vlaar. I think Sylla can be key here also. If he is winning the ball with great gusto, we may not have as much pressure at the very back.
I hope Sylla can crank it up another notch, all signs are there to suggest he can do just that.
Leroy
Agree7
Disagree0
Godsylla was our unsung hero last season.
Finch
Agree6
Disagree1
None of them are serious injuries mate, PL would have just taken them off at the first sign of there being any slight injury to prevent it from getting worse and then missing the start off the season. Calm down, we'd much rather keep slightly injured players from playong at all rather than risk it in a friendly. Jeez
Agree3
Disagree0
Reading that Ireland could go Doncaster with given but we'll have to part fund both wages!
Agree1
Disagree1
I have reservations about Baker and still not sure we can rely on him 100% at this stage.
I think part of that is down to the way he plays, putting his head in where it hurts and prepared to make a tough challenge (ala Carragher amd Terry). That style of play will invariably lead to mistakes although he improved as the season went on. I would put Baker and Clark on a par in that Clark is a better footballer (although not great) and Baker is better at defending.
Personally I think our defence improved towards the end of the season when Vlaar returned and I think we will start the season with Vlaar and Okore. That will hopefully give Baker and Clark the impetus to work hard and take their chance when it arises.
Agree1
Disagree0
Honest opinion lads, I can see this defence starting at Arsenal:
Lowton - Vlaar - Okore - Baker
Purely because Luna is untried in Premier League to date, and Bennett should be a winger, not a defender (I think he'll be a top player if he moves forward permanently). I can see then this midfield starting:
Westwood - Sylla - Delph
With the following winger/CF combination:
Weimann - Benteke - Bacuna/Gabby/Tonev
Either way, I'm buzzing and we have every reason to be excited and thrilled with current situations at AVFC (obviously the deadwood needs shifting too but we can't do anything about that).
Talk coming from colleagues I work with at the FA and Premier League clubs around the country, I wouldn't be surprised to see a few additions onboard before the end of August also, just be patient, PL knows what he is doing!
Azza
Agree4
Disagree2
Azza totally agree about bennett, whoever told him he was a defender needs to get away from football as soon as possible. Still unsure about luna, hasn't looked bad in pre-season but doesn't have the best positional discipline, the back four you have mentioned looks like the strongest to me too. At least this year we have a few more options, last season we played 5 at the back a few times and only had one defender on the bench in lichaj, at least this year we have 2 left backs and we can make 7/8 different centre back partneships if we need to.
Agree2
Disagree0
At the moment are starting defence will be
Lowton Vlaar Okore Baker
This is because it contains experience and luna and ennett are untested and crap respectively
Sylla Westwood
Weimann Tonev Agbonlahor
Benteke
Thats without some promised big named signings
Agree2
Disagree2
Sorry but Delph has to start. He and Westwood had a great understanding towards the end of last season and for continuity and long term plans we need to keep going with that.
Agree5
Disagree0
Agree, Delph needs to play! Its very obvious to the continuation of our good form from last season, he was epic!
Agree4
Disagree2
In my opinion sylla is a lot better than delph, he was half of the reason we went on such a good run at the end of the season, I can only think of 2/3 games that delph played better than him
Agree4
Disagree2
I have to disagree that sylla is better than delph
Agree2
Disagree1
I've noticed opinions are massively divided on this one, and i'll try and settle it by saying actually, its hard to compare the two, because while the play similar roles they are actually different players, delph is somewhat flamboant, twists and turns, flying lunges and spontaneous runs, where as sylla will just look for a pass and move the ball, then press any player with the ball when defending.
Agree4
Disagree0
Got to say Villa played much better with Sylla in the team. Delph benefitted most from this as it allowed him freedom to play and he started to look like the player with all of the potential that we paid so much for. I would definitely start with these 2 and Westwood and then shape the team around them depending on opposition and tactics for individual games. Weimann & Gabby added the width with this formation but they can interchange with the new guys to change the whole shape of the team.
Agree0
Disagree0
Totally agree, I think the formation will have to be a 4-5-1 but you have to wonder that if we only play one striker, weimann gabby and helenius won't get a load of games. Tonev and bacuna should be the wingers in my opinion. I guess we'll just have to see who performs this season, it will be good to have better options than barry bannan and stephen ireland on the bench that's for sure. Paul lambert knows what he's doing, and i'm sure if any player doesn't play well he'll drop him straight away, he proved that with the 'bomb squad'. Competition for places will make all the difference for us.
Agree1
Disagree1
Well written pieces regarding baker my only eservation about the lad is that when play is open he'too brittle strength wise not a rough centre back in way what WEDOneed is to stop crosses at sourcetoprevent losing so many goals if you are able to review the goals we let in almost50% were from unchallenged crosses which is where width in the sidewould be best employed
ANDY2055
Agree1
Disagree0
Whats the verdict on luna?
Agree1
Disagree1
21 Jul 2013 19:56:00
My mate lives in France an is convinced villa made an enquiry with regards too Gregory sertic two weeks ago.
Finch
Believable5
Unbelievable14
Looks like a pretty solid player, but how attacking is he?
Agree3
Disagree4
Paul Lambert went after him when he was at Norwich so there could be truth to that. would rather a real attacking midfielder or defensive this guy seems another winger
Kev
Agree7
Disagree4
You're right kev mate he is a winger that would add nothing at all to our squad. agree we need a real att mid and a big strong commanding def mid.
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree7
Disagree3
Put it this way:
Against Luton, only strikers we have fit & available are Drennan & Burke basically. we need another striker!
Agree4
Disagree8
He often plays in the middle of the park for Bordeaux. Like I said I'm putting up a genuine rumour and putting my name to it.
Finch
Agree7
Disagree3
Respect Finch.
Not my first choice, so hope this is not likely.
Leroy
Agree5
Disagree4
I think he should really concentrate on a defensive midfielder to help out the defenders and control the midfield. unless sylla becomes a much better player as pre season looks to be showing. can't figure out the formation for the game against arsenal should be interesting to see our new starting 11
kev
Agree7
Disagree5
Sylla looked fab against Wycombe! Absolute beast of a player!
Agree11
Disagree0
Well it looks like Clark or Johnson will be cover for this season unless we sign a dmc. Sylla for me was a big influence on the team last season so ideally would like to see another guy signed up.
As for the arsenal match iv a sneeky suspicion we may play 4-5-1 and flood the midfield. plus wev no fit strikers either!
Agree6
Disagree5
We have Burke. All our players par N'Zog will be fit for Arsenal.
Agree10
Disagree2
Benteke is not injured and will be match fir for Arsenal. There is no point signing a new striker just because we have a few minor injuries.
As for starting line up
Guzan
Lawton
Vlaar
Okore
Luna
Bacuna
Westwood
Delph
Weimann
Benteke
Gabby
433
Agree7
Disagree5
Gabby will be fit, helenius will be fit, bowery will be fit, benteke will be fit, and weimann will probably be fit, so yes we will have strikers. I think all the pre-season injuries are just precautions, better to take them off when they sprain a little finger than to make them play on and risk breaking a wrist. However I still think we should be packing the midfield to some extent, the last time we did that at the emirates we won 2-0!
Agree6
Disagree3
I think that gardner has to feature in tht midfield. I like westwood but gardner could be the new steven gerrard from what I've seen
kev
Agree7
Disagree3
We need a new striker because think last year how many injuries Benteke had? None! With Bent also leaving soon enough - I also agree, we need 1 more striker
Agree3
Disagree4
I'd play gardner more attacking if i'm honest, played cdm, cam and strike for the u21's and look very good going forward. He'll be 3 times better than his brother.
Agree8
Disagree1
If Benteke is injured we have Helenius and Bowery to come in and if by any chance the three of them are all missing both Gabby and Weimann can fill in the centre forward role with Tonev, Albrighton or N'Zog (presumably still here) coming onto the wing.
We don't need another striker!
Agree11
Disagree2
We do not need a striker, helenius has replaced bent, gabby and weimann can now play as strikers as we have signed at least one actual winger and bacuna can play there as well. We have 5 first team strikers (if bent leaves) so if we play 4-4-2, only when 4 strikers get injured/suspended at once (highly unlikely) we will have to call upon the u21's. but that's like saying 'lets buy a mansion just in case we win the lottery'. We have less central defenders than we do strikers, why does nobody care about that?
Agree9
Disagree1
We've got 4 central defenders, how many do you want? With regard to strikers, I would argue we only have 2 viable options (assuming Bent leaves), and one of those, Helenius, is completely unproven. Gabby has proven year after year he is not good enough upfront, wiemann can't play with his back to goal (if lambert wanted strikers who play on the shoulder, he would keep Bent), and Bowery is nowhere near Premier standard yet.
Agree0
Disagree6
Guzan
Lowton vlaar clarke luna
Sylla westwood
Weimann gardner agbonlahor
Benteke
Steer okere baker herd tonev baccuna helinus
Agree2
Disagree6
You've lost the plot haven't you? Gabby is a much better player through the middle, he's never a winger. And as for the 'helenius is unproven comment' what would your suggestion be, buy another bent, ireland or given on silly for poor ethic or buy players like benteke, lowton, westwood and sylla who are as you would say 'unproven'. Weimann doesn't need to play with his back to goal if he is next to benteke, we all know benteke would be a target man and is very capable of bringing the hall down an laying it off to players with their fronts to goal and finally as for the bowery remark how do you suggest we get him to prem standard? keep him 5th in the pecking order or sign another striker and make him 6th reducing the chance of playing time. Also my point still stands, we have 4 defenders for at least 2 starting 11 positions, and 5 strikers for a position that might only be available for one player in the starting 11.
Agree3
Disagree2
Good result boys 2-0 defeat to non-league luton not a single pre-season victory against sides at least 2 divisions below.
Agree4
Disagree5
Get a grip the side put out in the first 60 minutes was more like the reserves and don't forget all the players rested with knocks are still to come back. Unless you have something constructive to say then shut it.
Agree5
Disagree1
Yes and who was playing? Donacien, webb, carruthers, burke, johnson, robinson. Why don't you wait until we have played a full strength team and kicked a ball in anger before you judge us. All the young lads where trying to impress and were dancing with it in the box instead of passing as they wanted a goal for themselves, we were just moving the ball round the pitch, getting the running done and learning how to talk to each other. I for one would prefer to lose to lower league teams like luton in pre-season than man united in the premier league. Are you seriously suggesting last nights result had any reflection on the game against arsenal? Will we be starting a nearly conplete second string team? Will we be running at about 25%? Tell me, why would we be rotating the squad, giving everybody time on the pitch, and letting 6/7 of our under 21's play if it meant anything? Seriously you're better off locking yourself in a room until pre-season is over as you're worrying too much. Man city and Manchester United have lost in pre-season too, will they have awful seasons. Honestly mate I don't mean to be rude but you seriously need to relax and wait until we are playing for something important.
Agree4
Disagree2
I really can't believe we are judging the team on a few pre season games. Did you not see the back four last night? No Vlaar, No Lowton, no Okore. We have a squad currently impacted by 8 niggling injuries.
Lets judge the team shall we are playing meaningful games and when we have a strong first 15/16 available
Agree5
Disagree2
Stop moaning. No one who contributes to these pages want to see out beloved Villa lose. It was only a pre season friendly. We have a number of significant injuries and six players to blend into a new squad and our star player who hasn't played much since the end of the season. Prer season is about just getting fitness levels up and getting the team to blend. Manchester United have lost two games ore season-does that mean they are falling to bits and will be struggling all year. no it doesnt. Judge us after half a dozen games of the new season and not before. fed up doom mongers on this site. get behind us for once.
Agree3
Disagree2
I really couldn't care less what are results are in pre-season. as long as the players are training well and getting fit for the arsenal game, the results we get with a weak, rotated team won't have any impact on the season
Agree3
Disagree2
Seems everybody in this page has the same view on pre-season except this guy that has moaned after every single pre-season game (i pressume its the same person as nobody else can be that negative). Shall we all give him a big group hug for his troubles?
Agree4
Disagree4
EthAVFC, I agree agbonlahor is no winger, but that doesn't make him a good centre forward (1 goal every 5 games - not good enough). How do I suggest we get Bowery upto to PL standard? He is so far away from PL standard, he shouldn't be learning his trade in our first team! Loan him out seems fairily obvious to me, he ain't going to learn anything being 4, 5 or 6 choice striker in a 1 striker system. This leads me on to my point about Wiemann. I agree entirely that he could play alongside Benteke, but as you say later we are talking about a system that only employs one striker! I don't advocate buying another expensive player, all I am saying is, that if Benteke goes down in the first game, in my view Wiemann, Bowery and Gabby can't cut it up front on their own, so that just leaves us with Helenius, who is unproven. Big risk going into a season on that basis. With regard to CD's, how many other teams have more than 4?
Agree2
Disagree2
I can assure you if benteke was injured there's a very good chance we'd play two up front, but let's not forget gabby had his best season playing as the striker in a 4-5-1 formation. Forgive me if i'm wrong but you also appear to be saying our all time leading goal scorer doesn't score enough goals? And with regards to CD's I guarentee 15/16 teams in the premier league have more central defenders then they do stikers!
Agree3
Disagree1
The 12th man and Kentish Villan are the only ones talking semse about the "injury" situation. They were taken off as a precaution, much better to rest first team strikers for friendlies when they have a knock than play them and risk making the injury worse, have some common sense!
Agree5
Disagree2
Agbonlahor had to play as a winger under Houllier & Lambert has sorted him out by giving him extra room on the flanks to run in. Correct he is no winger, but he is now a lot stronger so can play the #9 sort of role.
Agree3
Disagree1
Agree with both the above comments. As regards gabby, would we all agree his best game was against norwich last season? The game where benteke went missing and gabby played through the middle for 60 mins. Trust me, gabby would rather be running straight at goal between the two 6ft3 usually really slow centre backs than running towards the corner flags and looking for somebody in the box.
Agree3
Disagree0
21 Jul 2013 12:35:53
Hi
I was at my son under 7's tournament this morning and was talking to a villa scout, and I said that benteke signing was great news, which he agreed and he said that the rumours are that it wasn't his agent pushing for a move it was someone in the Belgium set up that had spoke to benteke saying you'll never get in the World Cup squad if your at villa. Which is why he put a transfer request in, but apparently it was the Belgium manager who told benteke to stay at villa because he needs him to play every game which he told him wouldn't happen at spurs or Chelsea, like I said its just a rumour that he had heard. UTV
Believable9
Unbelievable9
Probably lukaku again, he said back in march that benteke should leave villa. Maybe spending a year in west brom went to his head, he must have picked up their unreal assessment of both west brom and villa. Then again a few belgian lads play for chelsea and spurs so they may have had a couple of bits to say. Especially the spurs ones as they need somebody who can put the ball in the net from inside the box.
Agree5
Disagree2
No he has been advised to stay for one more season just to prove himself and the contract is a smoke screen
Agree5
Disagree5
Crazy if someone did tell him that on the basis that Benteke is currently first choice for Belgium and that would only change if he wasn't scorin or playin regularly which he would be at Villa.
Again clearly someone with a financial interest in him moving on.
Agree2
Disagree1
Randy will say enough wih the new guys get on with it we need more meaningul pre season games instead of nothing games against the likes of wycombe, gabby played hi s best as a lone striker undersome irish geezer wo buggered off when he ran out of ideasandy2055
Agree2
Disagree0
21 Jul 2013 01:19:30
Zdravko Kuzmanovic now being linked, also Fulham are looking at Bent apparently.
Believable7
Unbelievable4
Highly doubtful due to high wages and he's getting on a bit now. would probably want european football too which we can't offer, until next season anyway.
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree5
Disagree3
Before every1 says 25 isn't old, I know that, jus comparing him to the other signings we've made lol. up the villa boys, europe next season
Agree4
Disagree4
I don't think this will happen but the obsession with age that many of our fans have now developed is just getting silly
I am sure that Lambert is not stupid enough to discount a player because he is the wrong side of 25!
The modern footballer, with good diet and training regime is going to be able to play at the top level until 35, no problem
Lambert will know that better than anyone
Agree7
Disagree2
Agree mendax, I rubbish it when people talk about lescott and huddlestone because they're just has beens and rejects but we got vlaar when he was 26, and el ahmadi and guzan too. His criteria isn't 'has to be below 23' its actually just 'has to be very hungry with plenty of room for improvement' if there was a 30 year old that suited us and was hungry with room to improve then he wouldn't hesitate to sign him!
Agree4
Disagree2
20 Jul 2013 21:58:14
Kiyotake spotted at bhx late this afternoon keep your fingers crossed
Believable5
Unbelievable6
If your so sure of it, reference your name to it.
Finch
Agree8
Disagree2
18 Jul 2013 19:27:49
Benteke told fans today when asked if he was going to stay now, he said "It is a strong chance I will be staying at villa"
Believable29
Unbelievable9
Dream on
Agree5
Disagree20
How do you know this? Pray tell
Agree11
Disagree6
Well if my wife asked me if I was having an affair I would say NO,
Even if I was.
True
villadave
Agree10
Disagree8
Yes and he's gona be playing upfront with pele hahaa. got to love some of the bs people write on here
Agree3
Disagree9
We will see. he may stay but a massive apology followed by a great energetic and commited start to the season would be needed if he wants to be accepted by the fans, management or executive of the club.
I hope you have puckered your lips Chris.
Agree9
Disagree1
Absolute rubbish!
I watched a video from smart phone online when benteke left bodymore Heath and he did not say a word to fans. He signed autographs when driving away and had a very big smile when one fan mentioned Tottenham!
Agree4
Disagree9
I've also seen the video, he mutters one word hen a fan asks for a photo and then just keeps smiling like he was actually listening to them. They sounded a bit desperate though!
Agree6
Disagree1
Had to laugh villadave. thanks for making the mood a little lighter :)
Agree3
Disagree3
"Christian Benteke has pledged to train hard and give his all for Aston Villa despite the uncertainty surrounding his future with the club. "
Agree9
Disagree2
"When we first approached I asked the question 'will you be staying?'
"He looked at Sylla, had a very big smile then said 'I will'. I'm unsure if the smile was that Sylla knows he's leaving or that he convinced Benteke to stay. "
So - he did say a word to the fans!
Agree8
Disagree3
If he stays it won't be because of sylla or villa it will be because spuds won't pay and that will be the only reason
Agree4
Disagree6
Spuds lookin at soldado too now. surely they won't get both and seems as if they are more interested in the valencia star than benteke. we are miles off sorting any kind of deal yet whether we keep him or get rid. who knows?
Agree1
Disagree3
IF you want to know what negotiations are like - look at our sightings page!
Agree1
Disagree3
Credit has to go where credits due. A lot of people didn believe this chap but he was right. Jog on spurs! Up the villa
Agree10
Disagree0
Well well benteke signs new deal. I literally cannot believe it. F U Spuds ha
Agree7
Disagree0
There you go then lads! told you it was happening & it has - Benteke new deal until 2017, he just wanted to push for more money I guess!
Agree8
Disagree1
Benteke signs a new contract, gutted tbh not because I wanted him at spurs but because it was nice having banter with another club for once. Couldn't he have waited another week or 2?
Best of luck next season to all Villa fans loved all the abuse and positive comments from you guys. PL is doing a great job and in a couple of seasons we may be fighting it out for a top 4 spot.
Much love Villa fans
P. s you might want to apologise to OP as apparently he was spot on.
Agree5
Disagree2
Thank you! it was via an old friend of a source I heard a new deal might be on the cards & he was staying. I should probably get a sign off name now, I got Steer right too - i'm on a roll!
Agree7
Disagree1
Looks like Dave's cheating on his missus then.
With bentekkers back on side I feel we just need one more signing (attacking mid) and we could be a top 10 team next season.
Utv, lambo is a legend.
Finch
Agree10
Disagree2
With benteke staying, and bale wanting out -the spuds will be ordinary
Agree11
Disagree2
Villadave we've all told your wife were not having affairs behind her back.
Agree8
Disagree2
And this is my new name on this forum (I was the one whom said benteke was staying & about steer in the first place!)
Lambert is apparently set for a little bit of a pay bonus for securing Christian Benteke according to what I am hearing!
Agree7
Disagree3
I think Lambert has promised some big name transfers in order for benteke to stay. More to come in the next few days
Agree2
Disagree5
Erickson. ?
Agree1
Disagree5
Now that all is sorted who do you think should be this all important attacking midfielder? kiyotake rumours went dead. I like hiroki yamada young and cheap
Agree0
Disagree2
He deserves it, if he can get him to stay next season, and then some too, i'll give him my family to work as his personal slaves.
Agree2
Disagree2
I really doubt whether Lambert needs to add some more big names to the squad because that isn't our style anymore! What I am hearing is a few more potential gem's from Europe, reportedly a striker & a playmaker.
Agree4
Disagree3
The eriksen that jus moved to milan? don't think he woulda come here regardless
Agree1
Disagree1
Lambert is a legend, he could talk your wife into bed. Good work Paul. {Ed001's Note - I heard he is that good a talker, he could convince you to bring him brekkie in bed the morning after he slept with your wife.}
Agree2
Disagree1
Can u give any names of those 'gems' u mentioned please dutchvillan?
Agree3
Disagree1
Nothing solid right now sorry mate, he is looking even further into the Eredivisie & possible recruitments there but no solid evidence on names right now mate - i'll keep you updated with what I hear!
Agree14
Disagree1
Appreciate the reply dutchvillan. shame no names in the offing but i'm sure we will hear something soon. cheers mate
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree2
Disagree2
All though he has signed a new contract means nothing come January, Spurs will be back when Bale goes to Madrid, And Villa will get around £35mil for him, the club are happy to let this happen.
Agree4
Disagree2
If levy refused to pay £25m, what makes you think he'll then pay £35m!
Agree4
Disagree2
Now he has signed a contract he will have 3 years left, and he will have played 2 seasons in the prem. £25m is a risk after a year as he could be a one season wonder, but if he has another good season in the prem and doesn't get second season syndrome he has to be worth £30m.
Agree3
Disagree2
My point exactly
Agree2
Disagree2
18 Jul 2013 17:30:44
lee Wallace and lewis mcloud from rangers both for 4 mill. lewis mcloud looks a very good player he only 19 plays midfield and has scored 3 during pre season
Believable6
Unbelievable18
Such a shame spuds fans have a taste of what damage poaching can do to a club mediocrity I think
ANDY2055
Agree1
Disagree0
18 Jul 2013 10:36:20
Barry Bannan seems to be closer to the exit door with noises coming out that Leeds are preparing to sign the young Scotsman for £1.5m with the option of Villa to have first refusal on the player in the future.
Enda Stevens looks set for a loan move to the Championship in an effort to give Stevens some game time.
Darren Bent is expected to complete a £6m move to the Toon come next week.
Believable24
Unbelievable4
Clap clap
Agree10
Disagree2
He's got what?
Agree5
Disagree5
A midget in a suit case called Bridget
Agree5
Disagree1
18 Jul 2013 10:25:16
Despite enquiries by Spurs - no bids have gone in for the young Belgian, Benteke is in Birmingham today & has started re-training with the Villa lads. Its expected he will have a meeting with Paul Lambert to thrash out his future, where it is expected Lambert will try to get Benteke to stay at Villa for the coming season.
Believable13
Unbelievable3
I hope your right, if we can keep him for another 12 months or give him a new contract then he can get his wish and leave after the world cup
Agree12
Disagree2
18 Jul 2013 09:01:55
Paul Lambert is said to have checked in with Lyon about the availability of not only striker Bafetimbi Gomis, but also French international forward Jimmy Briand.
It is said that Hull and West Brom have already taken exploratory calls about Briand, but the player has insisted that he is not looking for a move away from the French giants.
Gomis has his own admirers also, with Premier League outfit, Newcastle inquiring on the French international recently.
Newcastle are still keen on a move for Aston Villa hit man, Darren Bent, yet have so far baulked at the Birmingham clubs� valuation of the player, despite that valuation having decreased from a said 8 million, down to 6 million in an effort to help find a home for the embattled player.
It seems increasingly likely, that the striker merry-go-round may kick off when and if, Villa star striker Christian Benteke gets his way and Aston Villa grant him his big money move out of the midlands.
Tottenham are seemingly at the front of the queue but have yet to officially test Villa owner Randy Lerner�s resolve on his 25 million valuation of the player.
Multiple reports have come to surface, that a behind the scenes deal is being worked on that would see the Belgian player handed a 5 year deal at Spurs with a whopping 85k weekly earning packet, more than trebling his current 20k per week deal at Villa.
According to those reports, the additional fees are a stumbling block as Aston Villa are playing hardball, insisting that a sell on clause be included in the deal that would see them take a 25% stake of his next transfer fee.
Its not difficult to see the reasoning as to why Aston Villa value this sell on clause, as they are not the only club to fall victim to the player and more so, his agent Eris Kismet�s forceful tactics and may believe that even if a contract is agreed with a new club such as Spurs, he may soon have his eye on yet another move in the not too distant future.
Believable5
Unbelievable3
Fed up with all this Benteke talk!
The papers want to sell papers so they add in any "information" from "unknown sources" (aka. B. S) they can think of!
Ed, can we ban all Benteke talk here please!
Agree3
Disagree1
I understand a deal has been struck with spurs, fee agreed, wages agreed, sell on's not what randy wanted but they are ok? Just the niglie things to sort out at the moment! rather like two dogs have a sniff going away then coming back! About 10 days I think?
Agree3
Disagree5
This very detailed report seems to be a compilation of the last 4 days press and nothing more.
Sorry but we are all waiting for something new.
villadave
Agree6
Disagree0
Yet another re hash of tedious nonsense dished out by Spud ITK's. No one knows what is going on other than RL, PF, PL and the Judas himself.
Agree3
Disagree2
Genk have a 15% sell on clause already on Benteke.
Agree4
Disagree7
Lol
So apparently noone knows what's going on and all rumours and b. s and yet people keep flocking back to a RUMOUR site.
Fairly daft really.
Agree6
Disagree0
Id just like to know what people think are untrue about this rather detailed compilation above?
- Lambert has been reported by a couple of sources, as checking in on Gomis and Briand
- Bent has been discussed as heading off Newcastle way - with the price seemingly the sticking point
- There have been a stream of apparent in the knows that have also confirmed that an agreement has been struck for Benteke with prices ranging from an initial 18mil (with a copious amount of add ons) to 23mil straight with a sell on clause.
This Benteke saga seems to be bringing out the nastiness in Villa fans, snapping away at one another.
I think they should get rid of the guy. he has talent, but Lambert has spent time and effort crafting together a solid unit of players.
It seems that each young player has nothing but positive things to say about the club with words like "honour", "unity" and "pride" being mentioned by Villa players.
As for the so called fans whinging away here, might be good practice to do a little more as the players do and say.
Agree7
Disagree1
Now, now, let's not get chippy.
I took a few hits yesterday as I reported something from the apparent Spurs ITK people.
It is a rumour site and naturally, not all rumours are going to be accurate nor what we are looking for as Villa fans.
The Benteke saga is proof of this. If we are getting riled up by this subject as fans here on a somewhat anonymous website, maybe it is better to just rid ourselves of him.
Can only imagine what the other players are thinking.
Leroy
Agree2
Disagree0
I think if you read the remarks about your post, nobody is saying that your comments are untrue, they are simply saying that its what we have heard before, we all know about your remarks having read about them in the papers, and the papers write things that they think will sell their publication.
I am like all Villa fans, we are looking forward to something new and exiting to talk about.
villadave
Agree1
Disagree0
Everything being written about Bentakee is pure fantasy and the only point that is real is that he has pushed in a transfer request. Spuds have not put in a bid, indeed, according to most press reports, no bids have been received to date.
Most of the stuff isn't rumour, its people putting their own spin on events. Let us hope that the silver tongue of PL convinces Bentakee that he will be better served by staying at VP for the coming season and then he can see for himself if AV are heading in the right direction. With Bale bailing out of WHL, Spuds may find that they are not in the top 6 this season.
I believe that Bentakee is feeling a bit silly at the moment as there are no bids placed and it appears no questions have been asked. So where is he going?
Agree2
Disagree2
As they always say. its not over till the fat lady sings ie until he signs. he is still a VILLA player. not a spuds player.
Agree7
Disagree1
Gary gardner from40 yards what say you obsessionalist with unknown and untested names nobody has heard of?
ANDY2055
Agree1
Disagree1
17 Jul 2013 21:04:07
Another striker linked as bentekes replacement hosinier Austrian striker who scored 32 goals last season
Believable6
Unbelievable5
Ed, is there any legs on this gomis talk as a replacement for benteke? {Ed001's Note - I am pretty sure, having checked up, that he made it known he wasn't interested in a move to Villa around the time Swansea first bid for him. He also rejected them too. Seems he wants Champions League football. You never know how he will feel later in the window if they sign replacements though!}
Agree3
Disagree4
17 Jul 2013 20:19:24
Lambert is considering keeping Benteke on £20,000. A week for the remainder of his contract. Lerner is happy with this as replacements are asking three times as much in wages.
Dortmunds policy if you ask me. Benteke will be a free agent in three years time in which he has the option to sign a new deal to double his wages at any point but will mean a longer contract. Kismet's was happy for his client to sign a four year contract last summer so he has no input for the next three years.
Believable10
Unbelievable6
If this is true, I say let it happen. AVFC TILL I DIE
Agree7
Disagree3
In do think we should threaten this stance. 25m not a penny less or you return and train with the reserves until you kiss the pinky ring (ALOT) and play again, sign a new contract and get on with it.
Sure, we risk losing money and as a privately owned business this ain't going to happen. But to prove to a player that we won't stand for this should be applauded by all in football. Shame is other clubs like you to make a stance but act in their own interest and have no honour when it comes to these matters (ie they are private businesses)
Would be funny to see what happens if he does not get his move, missees out on the world cup and messes his career up. F U 'famous belgian'!
Agree6
Disagree4
17 Jul 2013 19:16:54
Villa supposedly looking at bringing in finnobogson or Gomez (baby drogba) as bentekers replacement
Believable5
Unbelievable6
I would love this! Rumours have it, that Gomis is Bent's replacement, where Finnabogasson is Benteke replacement, if he goes. Fans still stating they think Benteke will stay!
Agree4
Disagree6
Firstly are we forgetting helenius was bents replacement and we have another striker linked phillipe hosinier who is Austrian and scored 32 goals last season
Agree7
Disagree3
No truth in this but what would we think of a swap deal involving bent and cisse? (the wonga.com rebel)
Agree3
Disagree6
Whatever happens there, great to see Cisse standing up, i'm not a religious man, but Wonga operate plantation economics, modern day slavery with their disgusting APR. Newcastle should be ashamed, such a company has no place on our TV screens.
Agree4
Disagree4
Why would want a player who was happy to wear a shirt with two other companies who make money and charge interest (northern Rock and Virgin Money)but now as he fancies a move starts to bring religion into it and holding the club to ransom. I say stone him not buy him. {Ed001's Note - he also frequents the local casino and has recently split up with a non-Muslim porn star to date another non-Muslim. All those things a devout Muslim would not do.}
Agree5
Disagree3
17 Jul 2013 11:17:54
Further reports are coming to surface in regards to Christian Benteke, this time from an ex AVFC board member who has said that the terms of his transfer to Tottenham have been agreed.
What will come as a surprise/disappointment to Villa fans is the apparent fee agreed - atleast the initial upfront payment.
17mil upfront and then add ons that could total up to 25% (additional 6mil) of the fee. What remains unclear here, is if Villa have snuck in a "sell on clause" that had been spoken of previously (10%).
So it seems Villa will get their 25mil, but it seems it will trickle in long after the move has been completed.
Leroy
Believable4
Unbelievable16
If this is true its a absolute joke and shows villa have nothin about them!
Agree10
Disagree3
They have added no quotes & names on from whom that is. Villa haven't changed their board since Lerner came in & Ellis's board has nothing to do with the Lerner board. Benteke will be sold for £25m & not in massive add-ons.
Agree8
Disagree2
Ok, let's wait and see then. Levy is an extremely shrewd businessman and he almost always gets his way.
Dont forget that we are still owed from money from Downing´s transfer to Liverpool. so its not like we have never conducted a transfer in this manner previously.
Hope you are a right and I am wrong.
Leroy
Agree5
Disagree6
This is from a guy who says he has two teams because Villa don't win anything? True Villa fan so he must be in the know. well as much as an "ex board member" complete bs
Look at the money we got for Young, Downing & Milner, Randy won't sell unless it suits him
Agree6
Disagree5
Whats with the hostility? Just trying to bring rumours to a rumour site, so that we can discuss them.
I am not sure what goes through some people´s heads on here really.
We have some great regular contributors on here and this is one of the best places (in my opinion) to discuss current topics regarding our club.
I don't think I should cop any rubbish from you when I am merely contributing to this site.
BTW, have never claimed to be in the know and have never once said that I hope we sell to Spurs or that I wish this deal to go through. infact have stated that I hope this information is wide of the mark.
Im one of the few that "signs off" on any post I leave here, I don't hide from my words then sling s*** on others like some.
Leroy
Agree7
Disagree3
Benteke deal appears to be pretty much done. The source is supposedly a former Aston Villa board member, still very much involved and in the loop at the club.
He believes that the sticking point has been what were referred to as ‘the extras’ such as sell on percentages, add-ons for various things. The source is quoting that these ‘extras’ could amount to as much as 25% of the £18m fee. Which means my guy’s info citing £17m wasn’t too shabby the other day. The information ends with a quote from the source:
Just to add Benteke has told Villa It is Spurs he wants to go to and his agent has made this abundantly clear.
The fee now mooted would take the value of the deal – not the upfront fee – over the £20m mark.
Here is the report for the prat spouting rubbish about me making things up off the top of my head.
Leroy
Agree1
Disagree4
Why would an ex board member be briefed about Bentekes transfer situation. Have they heard of the data confidentiality act?
Agree4
Disagree0
Virtually all transfers are paid in instalments.
Agree4
Disagree2
If correct this makes no sense.
At the moment the player is on strike, and as a result we are or will be fining him his weekly wages. This means he has no cost to us at all?
also the fee muted was 30 million which a huge leap to 18 plus add ons and sell on clauses.
Not calling anyone a liar here but how has R Lerner built all the wealth closing deals on this type of basis.
It remains to be seen if the rumour is accurate but I would be very surprised if so.
Agree3
Disagree0
Leeroy this is a poor attempt at a made up rumour, holes in your story mucha-cho
Agree3
Disagree3
Not so sure about the rumour and its make up, but I have to side with Leroy on his other points, he contributes to this site and makes his feelings known without any offence.
I am sure he is without doubt a passionate villa fan.
villadave
Agree7
Disagree1
Data Confidentiality act? new one on me too. Not only have I never heard of that act of parliament but last time I checked Villa were a non governmental body and would not observe these acts even if they existed. having said that, an ex board member is unlikely to be privvy to such information and would be instructed to be discreet.
Agree2
Disagree1
Benteke isn't on strike & will be at Bodymoor Heath tomorrow for training, Kismet has confirmed it.
Agree5
Disagree1
Hussain club anzhi are rumoured to of bid for bentekers
Agree1
Disagree1
There really is no need to be getting personal and slating people that are merely posting rumours on a rumours site. like he said, leroy always leaves his name and says what he thinks without offending anyone so come on guys we all support the same team let's not be arrogant especially to the guys that contribute the most.
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree6
Disagree1
Should it be Data protection? But this is for personal details of a person, not details of proposed business. Whichever fact it makes no differerence to Bentakee, he will walk. His true colours have been shown and they are not claret&blue. Our hopes of a hero are gone and he proves himself to be nothing but a big s.
Agree2
Disagree1
Aston Villa would have to abide by a Data Confidentiality act as any company that handles personal details and bank details has to adhere to this legislation, it is a known fact and also the law. Even if its a private or public company it will apply to both.
Agree2
Disagree1
No such thing as the Data Confidentiality act, as I earlier stated. There is the data protection act, but that does not have any relevance to the internal dealings of a private business. As earlier stated personal details such as his address or bank details should not be divulged by the club, but things such as contract details and transfer information are firmly the business of the club, they are at complete liberty to decided what they want to do. don't quote the law if you haven't got a clue about it, learn it or leave it, it will only get you in trouble.
Agree2
Disagree2
Shout out to Villadave and AVFC 4 LIFE, nice to know that you guys get it that this rumour is not at all my opinion, but passing on what I have found.
I would be disgusted if these were the terms of the transfer as I think we don't have to budge no matter what.
We should be careful though, as the longer time passes, the more Daniel Levy will press for this to go through.
Leroy
Agree2
Disagree1
17 Jul 2013 09:00:25
Villa are expected to sign two strikers with the money from the Benteke's sale, £7m is expected to be spent on Bafetimbi Gomis of Lyon & £5m bid is expected to go in for 19 year old Michy Batshuayi.
Believable9
Unbelievable2
How true are these rumours mate?
cant see gomis due to his age and wage he doesn't really seem like a PL type of player.
Batshuayi on the other hand is a very raw talent with a massive amount of potential.
would love this to happen
Agree6
Disagree2
They would be superb additions if the rumours going around today are true indeed & would leave Lambert with half of the Benteke & Bent money left!
Agree5
Disagree1
I beleive Gomis would be a great addition, although Batshuayi would be PL's preferred route and choice. Expect Byram and Sadio to come to Villa also, in the next few weeks, which should pretty much wrap up the summer spending. Perhaps a few last minute deals before deadline and window closes! VTID AVFC
Agree4
Disagree4
If you threw in Kiyatake with those two, I would be pretty happy with our business this transfer window, despite Benteke forcing his move out.
Leroy
Agree10
Disagree4
16 Jul 2013 20:21:19
According to reports this evening, Russian powerhouse and perennial big spenders, Anzhi, have registered a bid of 23 mil for Christian Benteke.
Second rumour is that Paul Lambert has issued a firm warning to Benteke to start training or risk the consequences.
Leroy
Believable6
Unbelievable3
Reading all this about benteke going and hope his leaves quick but have we shown any real intention of replacing him, have we got anyone in our sights?
Agree2
Disagree2
Of course we have! PL has been looking for months, even before the season ended! He knew this may have been coming, plus the new replacements will be little gems ;)
Agree3
Disagree2
Gomis & Batshuayi it seems for a total of £12m between them!
Agree6
Disagree2
Why do you think we'll sign two
Strikers we already bought helleinus
Agree4
Disagree3
Because we are selling two! Benteke & Bent!
Agree0
Disagree3
If you sell 2 strikers, you usually replace them both i. e replace Bent & Benteke
Agree3
Disagree2
Helenius is bents replacement, unless we are planning to get rid of two and bring in 3? Seems strange when we also have gabby and weimann, one of whom will most like play more central after the arrival of real wingers
Agree4
Disagree1
16 Jul 2013 19:53:33
Anhzi have bid 23 million for Benteke, willing to go higher and will offer 120,000 a week. Spurs were hoping to sell Adebayour to Anhzi to help finance the Benteke deal, now it's all gone wrong!
Believable6
Unbelievable2
Hope its true I still think we should hold out for 25 million, good riddance to him regardless!
Agree7
Disagree2
Lacina Traore coming this way in a deal could work? lol
Agree5
Disagree8
Traore has MASSIVE wages & is totally the opposite of what Lambert is trying to build at Villa! a team of hungry players!
Agree8
Disagree1
He earns about 5 times our wage cap so he DEFINITELY won't be coming
Agree11
Disagree1
16 Jul 2013 10:31:41
Villa have proof of "tapping up" by Spurs, its known Daniel Levy told Eric Kismet to get Benteke to hand in a transfer request to force Villa to lower their demands. Its expected Villa will now refuse to deal with Tottenham Hotspur & file for court proceedings against Levy.
Believable12
Unbelievable3
Just wondering how you came by this info. I wouldn't rule it out it very smells of a tap up. I hope villa never ever do business with spurs again and I hope bale does them over too
Agree8
Disagree0
Benteke wants spurs to make a bid to get him as soon as possible and doesn't want to face the AVFC boys when they get back from touring germany.
How disrespectful can u get?
until this saga he seemed very humble and thankful to all at AVFC.
Bridges burnt get him out NOW and sell him to a club that WONT play him. I hope baker or vlaar snap his damn legs if he faces us this season
Agree7
Disagree2
Maybe true about tapping him but I don't think we have any proof, unless lerner has hired ex news of the world reporters. look we shouldn't blame spurs fan for this if it was us we would the same. he doesn't want to play for us so let's move on.
Agree4
Disagree1
Where has this information come from? Or is it another person chatting waffle
Agree4
Disagree1
We all know anyway that football is controlled by agents. I still think Benteke is a quality player but he should be able to make up his own decisions instead of listening to his agent. That is a reason why I disrespect him. All agents care about is money for themselves and the players listen to them otherwise they won't have an agent.
Agree4
Disagree2
Is it actually possible to take legal proceedings for tapping a player up and how have Villa obtained positive proof of this? {Ed001's Note - Middlesbrough managed to successfully prosecute Liverpool for tapping up Christian Ziege a few year's back. You don't take legal proceedings, you go to the FA and make a formal complaint, who then hold a hearing to hear the evidence etc.}
Agree4
Disagree1
Not arguing the fact benteke been tapped up, but seriously come on, if villa had proof it was levy, it would be public knowledge by now. still not bothered either way he is going and that's it. time to move on no one bigger than our club.
Agree4
Disagree1
As much as we all know they tapped him up I bet he stil goes to spuds
Agree4
Disagree5
Faulkner is on the FA council & they suggest keeping such issues under tight wraps - that's why its not mass- public knowledge!
Agree6
Disagree0
Benteke want's to join spuds so he can stab em in the back and join Arsenal the season after.
Agree8
Disagree1
I don't doubt Spurs have "tapped up" benteke but I think it's only tapping up via media and I don't think there's an rules saying that's not allowed, every journo from every newspaper have known for a month spurs were planning on going for benteke, which tells me spurs leaked that to the media to encourage benteke to force his way out of villa.
Almost impossible to prove direct "tapping up", we'd need Kismet or Levy to admit to it
>Scg87
Agree9
Disagree2
My god you Villa fans will believe anything. Someone says it with no proof and you all jump on it. You just can't face the fact he wants to go to a bigger club and he sees spurs as that team. That's the thing that is bothering you isn't it? The fact you don't see Spurs as a bigger team but everyone else does.
There has been no tapping up, it doesn't take a genius to know spurs are in desperate need of a striker. Add that to Benteke's good season and that's a story. Benteke handed in a transfer request because he wants to leave, same as going on strike to leave Genk to join your lot. You saying Villa tapped him up aswell? Seriously think about how desperate you sound.
Only sensible reply's will be responded to, so let the playground abuse begin!
Agree5
Disagree8
Sensible reply like Bosnichs Basil Fawlty Impression?
Agree7
Disagree2
Personally i'm not bitter about benteke wanting to leave villa to go to spurs, spurs are in a more competitive position and are clearly showing more ambition/intent than we (villa) are.
But to say spurs are a bigger club than villa is laughable, the only thing spurs have over villa is their league position and healthier finances, most people who know anythin about football know that finances and finishing high up the table 2-3 seasons in a row don't define how big a club are.
>Scg87
Agree7
Disagree1
Spurs are basically what villa were 3 years ago, a very good team pushing for champions league and never fully making it, don't worry, it catches up with you, I don't care if benteke goes to spurs because at least then okore can boot the silly git out of the stand, i'm more wound up about the way he went about it, I mean, asking you guys to sign him before thursday because he doesn't want to turn up to training and face the people he's screwed over is pathetic. Either way, he's not going to spurs to play at the top level, he's using you as a stepping stone just like he did us.
Agree6
Disagree0
We'll put. All I hope now is that he leaves quick.
Agree3
Disagree0
2-3 years pushing for Cl? We've come 4th twice and 5th 3 time in recent years so my maths says that's 5 years, could be wrong. The difference is actually making the top 4 which we've done and many people within football see we have the ability to be a major force. We could talk about History aswell and I'm sure spurs have a more prestigious history so on both accounts we are the better side (then and now). Now I'm not claiming Villa are not a big side but do a bit of research and you may understand why spurs are the bigger side. That said though I don't live in the past I live in the here and now and currently we are a better side. No disrespect intended.
Agree1
Disagree8
Finishing 4th makes you a bigger club? When did you last win a cup? Or when did spurs last win the league?
Spurs have a bigger history than villa!? Funny how you never reminded us of spurs EU cup win, ohhhh that's right you havnt won the EU cup have you lol. And 2 more words for you, Founding members
>Scg87
Agree8
Disagree1
Villa are the 4th most successful team in england 20 major honours. spurs 6th with 17, do your own homework. you where in our position a few years back, and we in yours. 2 very similar teams. current form your the better team. pray you don't lose bale tho.
thats 2 teams benteke has s**t on now to get a move and he is only 22. even money he will do it to spurs too when more money or bigger team come knocking and they will because the guy is quality. good luck with the future. villa are coming
Agree6
Disagree2
next he'll be saying they have a bigger stadium. Just remember mate, we were in as good a position as spurs a few years back, only we were a bit more gratious about it. well done you finished a place higher than 5th one year, admitidly something we couldn't achieve, but let's be honest, you stand as much chance of getting champions league as anybody else in the prem because you're forever in arsenals shadows. And unless the two manchester teams or chelsea finish outside the top 4 (about as likely as striking gold down the side of my sofa) you won't play in the champions league, so yes, you are the new villa, and maybe in 3 years when you sell your best players like we did, you'll be in the same position as we are now.
Agree5
Disagree0
I said prestigious not carling cup wins and yes spurs have won the league so a bit of research on your side wouldn't go a miss. First British team to win a European cup (you can't say that) first non-league side to win the FA cup (that year we won the double) That's the sort of history that I care about. But like I said it's the here and now I really concern myself with not 60 years ago before I was born. You hang on to your past and continue to celebrate that in the championship!
Agree1
Disagree5
It wasn't the european cup as in equivilent to champions league, it was the european cup winners cup. that's like saying brazil won the world cup a couple of weeks ago!
Agree4
Disagree1
How does being non-league & doing well in a competition say you are a big club? Wigan won it and were in the EPL, they aren't a big club. That just makes Crawley Town sound bigger than Spurs.
Agree3
Disagree1
Finished in top 4 twice my friend and that consisted of Chelsea missing out on top four so yeah it can happen. No it wasn't a major European cup but it's the history that comes with it. When people ask who the FIRST British side to win it, that's us. When people want to know who was the first non-league side to win the FA cup, that's us again (which IMO is a great achievement). But like I said twice already it's not the history that concerns me.
Yes we could be where you are in three years time. I'm enjoying it whilst it's happening. Saying that I'm far less concerned about the future than I am the past. "Forever in Arsenals shadow" I hear this a lot from you guys and think it makes you look sad using another team to belittle us. Seriously guys think about how bad you make your own team look by using another team to slate us!
Agree1
Disagree5
I only say it because while you may get a sticky keyboard over the fact you are a half decent team, refferring to yourself as a bigger club is down right stupid, you're not the biggest team in london, not even the second, we however are in nobody's shadows and never will be. Anyway with all this said, we have just as much chance at silverware as you do next season so take your 'big club status' and shove it somewhere unpretty. Have benteke, he'll only hand in another transfer request next season when he wants to move to another bigger club like chelsea or arsenal.
Agree4
Disagree0
Lmao Did you really mention spurs winning the cup winners cup compared to villa winning the EU Cup? There's a massive difference pal, you proved my point, spurs are not a bigger club than villa.
Oh an Bale will be gone inside 12 months, so if AVB doesn't bring u back down to the second half of the table, bale leaving will defo do that for ya
>Scg87
Agree4
Disagree1
The Spud that started this tirade of abuse is a typical London club supporter. We all know the sort "my cat is whiter than your cat. " All he wants is to antagonise people but all the while he is hoping that Spuds kep Bale as without him they would certainly have been 6 places down the table. That is the here and now that he quotes. Let us see what happens when Bale has gone and they don't get Bentakee as he realises that he is a big fish in our "little" pond, but in London he becomes just a little fish in the big pond that is London, not WHL.
'Arry made Spuds, not AVB, wonder who will take up the managers job when AVB goes to a BIGGER club?than spuds?
Agree4
Disagree1
No never compared the two, read it again. I said about being the FIRST club to do things is what I find as good history because you tell me for example who won the league in 1933? Nobody cares and that's what history is, things people actually don't care about. My point was (and I'll say it slowly for you to understand) CURRENTLY-WE-ARE-A-BETTER-SIDE-BECAUSE-WE-HAVE-BEEN-FINISHING-ABOVE-YOUR-SIDE-IN-CURRENT-SEASONS. If you still don't understand then I cannot help you. Carry on with your childish comments, I never came on here and was abusive you just are all jealous of us because we are where you want to be. Love you all, bye!
Agree1
Disagree2
So what you're saying is, you have a better team, better squad, better roster of players. You are NOT a bigger club.
Agree4
Disagree2
Yeah, I think that's what he's saying lol
>Scg87
Agree2
Disagree1
16 Jul 2013 10:26:09
Its said that Villa & Spurs are in advanced talks regarding the sale of Christian Benteke for a fee
believed to be £25m & a 10% sell on clause.
Villa are now said to be willing to bring in 2 strikers to replace the outgoing Benteke & Bent.
Mane rumours are increasing & its believed he is seen to be brought in when Stephen Ireland is cleared off the wage bill with his destination likely to be Middlesbrough
Believable5
Unbelievable8
16 Jul 2013 10:15:17
I can tell you now 100% Benteke will not be at Villa come the start of the new season.
I can't reveal my source as current Villa player but his squad No has been offered to said player.
Looks like Spurs will finally pay what we want for Benteke and hopefully Lambert will receive the full funds to reinvest in a replacement and a creative midfielder.
Sorry to any of you still holding out in the hope Benteke will stay another season but it just will not happen.
Believable8
Unbelievable8
If he doesn't want to play for us then he can sod off, I really hope he warms the bench somewhere else
Agree5
Disagree2
There has been a report today in another London based paper -what a surprise-that Benteke wants the move to Tottingham completed by Thursday as he doesn't want to come back to Villa. I'm not surprised as he is probably too embarrassed to face the manager or the players after his pathetic antics. However, to me, this business shows no sign of being resolved any time soon and certainly not by this Thursday so welcome back Benteke. A big dose of humble pie is going to be in order I should say.
Agree4
Disagree2
Typical sell your best player before a ball is kicked yorke? young?downing?platt? bosnich?we'll never break out of mediocrity until players including benteke are told they WILLfulfil signed contracts before moving on elsewhere
Agree7
Disagree0
Villa are and should never berun by a players agent
Agree8
Disagree0
Has it not occured to your 'said player' that the reason for this is Benteke will take the Number 9 shirt vacated by Mr Bent?. Just Asking
Agree9
Disagree2
Cant reveal your source, it does not take a rocket scientist to work out benteke won't be at the club, however squad numbers already been given out, so unless you know a new signing that is coming in and he already been given his number then you are well and truly full of s---e.
Agree4
Disagree7
With player numbers usually changing quite a bit & #9 freed up by DB9. Your reasoning is faulty beyond belief
Agree5
Disagree3
I hope he doesn't take the squad number as otherwise we'll all know who your source is!
Agree5
Disagree1
Wouldn't want him now anyway. Once they slap that request in its never the same. Was hoping benteke would be different and give us another season, but it just shows what footballs all about. Spurs can have him, because when a bigger club comes in he will be off again.
Agree6
Disagree2
You never know - Lambert might get in his ear like the Belgian team & Kismet has & tell him to do some good & admit he's been tapped up!
Agree5
Disagree1
Like I said my source is a current player with Villa and yes No9 is vacated by Bent and I presume No9 will go to Helenius. I presume you don't like the news but to suggest i'm gull of S**T is over the top. Wait and see but unfortunately he will be gone and we can continue to progress under Lambert.
Agree7
Disagree3
15 Jul 2013 16:31:19
just heard Manchester United have entered talks with agent to sign benteke. this must be the strong presence needed that moyes was on about. no wonder he refused to go on tour. get £20 mill and I would be happy.
Believable5
Unbelievable9
Who has told you this utter rubbish - Bentekes agent?
Presumably we are getting Rooney as a makeweight in the deal.
Agree5
Disagree4
Not sure they can enter into talks with the agent from hell.
Surely they must first contact Villa to agree a fee.
Agree5
Disagree1
I hope he does go Manchester United as he will spend most off the time on the bench
as he won't get the nod over rvp or rooney surely villa need to hold out for that £25 mill hope we don't get bullied into less then that
Agree5
Disagree1
I doubt this very much.
Agree3
Disagree1
20mil? why should man u get him cheaper?
Agree6
Disagree2
Just heard form who?
I have 11 sites open on the taskbar and nothing like it mentioned.
villadave
Agree6
Disagree2
Benteke's going to spurs for 25m. He's not going to Chelsea because he wouldn't get enough first team football so why would he go to man u?
Agree6
Disagree1
United have RVP, Welbeck, Rooney & Hernandez, why would they want someone with such a bad attitude! they don't & won't!
Agree6
Disagree1
Was there a roumor the other week regarding danny welbeck being linked with the villa if this was correct and the roumor of bentekke to united surely welbeck + 10 mil would b great buisness
Agree3
Disagree7
MUFC have a habit of stealing our top players so £20m is not enough, £25/30m would be nearer the ball park figure.
They unsettled Yorke, see John Gregorys comments, and it is suggested that Young was approached as it was said that he knew some time before it became open knowledge that he would be playing for MUFC.
Real money this time no make weights or add ons unless they are above the asking price.
Agree7
Disagree3
Easily pleased then I see.
There is no reason why we should lower the price on a player who is contracted to us for three further years.
We are in the drivers seat here. He goes at our valuation or he stays and either makes amends for his actions or will ride the bench.
Spurs made us pay for Jenas even when he was injured, so they can stump up or forget it. Chelsea might be a good place to send him, but they want to offer Ba plus 7-10mil, so not an ideal bit of business as we want straight cash.
Perhaps if Man U paid the full price we may go ahead with a move, but it may arouse interest if they were to offer cash plus Welbeck. he has undoubted ability but is a risk and hasn't been at all consistent.
I am all in favour of doing business for the full cash amount only and allow Lambert to weave his magic once more.
Leroy
Agree6
Disagree2
Said it before and il say it now. welbeck 1 league goal last season compared to almost 20 for benteke?
10mil and welbeck would be awful business for us.
Agree6
Disagree2
God, I am so bored of these posts that are nothing more than mischief making
They are the online equivalent of graffiti but without any artistic merit
Please guys, give it a rest
(I wouldn't mind if they were atleast slightly witty)
Mendax
Agree4
Disagree0
With respect to chelsea offering Ba as part of the deal (and i'm not sayinh they will or that he will come) given that he will probably insist on a low release clause like he did at newcastle (7m), what would his value be in such a deal? can't see chelsea offering ba and 18m.
Agree4
Disagree2
Benteke wants spurs to press up there pursuit of him this week as he does not want to come back to villa! feeling guilty is he?
Agree4
Disagree2
The 25 mill price will not be met because benteke wants out and the last thing villa want is a rouge player. He will join the mighty spurs for 19-23 mill
Agree2
Disagree3
"Spurs made us pay for Jenas when he was injured" gun in the mouth I'm guessing? Lmao, so pathetic!
Agree2
Disagree3
Enough of benteke talk we're all sick of it the most important thing at villa park is that we don't lose the most aggressive and talented teaM buider since ron SAUNDERS PAUL LAMBERT
Agree2
Disagree0
15 Jul 2013 09:21:34
Villa are closing in on a £5m deal for Red Bull Salzburg midfielder Sadio Mane
Believable13
Unbelievable7
16 goals in 24 games, 21 years old, £5 = BARGAIN! In Lambert We Trust!
Agree8
Disagree5
Mane, Castaignos & we should be ready to beat Arsenal!
Agree10
Disagree4
Mane and Finnboagason are must buys if cb is too leave young eager and full of potential, everyone else around us is trying to buy young class so we've been doing something right
Agree9
Disagree3
Just how true are these latest rumours guys? because i'd love to think we will be signing these young guys.
Agree5
Disagree5
I submitted this rumour & I submitted the past Jed Steer ones too. Villa have put in an enquiry into Mane & are preparing a bid for him.
Lambert has a meeting with Faulkner in the coming days to deal with any replacement required for Benteke, Castaignos seems more likely than Finnbogason does.
Agree10
Disagree7
Finnbogasson won't make it in the prem get castaignos
Agree8
Disagree11
Finnbogasson has everything Benteke has. immense signing if we get him at 5-7m and sell Benteke for 25m
Agree5
Disagree11
Playing devils advocate here, have you actually seen Mane play, or have you just looked up his stats? Great stats from a CM of course but from what I remember from the Olympics that guy would struggle to play for our under21s. Not to mention he's playing in a poor to average league so it's hard to judge him as a £5m bargain based on his stats alone.
>Scg87
Agree7
Disagree3
I've seen him before mate & he is more of a Westwood sort of player than anything else.
Agree3
Disagree4
14 Jul 2013 16:56:08
Hi ed is they any truth we have made a bid for -castaignos this would be a great move for the Aston villa {Ed001's Note - I don't know, I do know both yourself and Norwich have been scouting him repeatedly. I really wouldn't be surprised if either moved for him, or both for that matter, but I don't know of any bid right now.}
Believable3
Unbelievable6
There are reports that are linking Villa with a move for either Costaignos or Finnbogason, both rumoured to be in the 6-8mil range.
For me, Finnbogason would be the preferred of the two just because he has a different skill set and would compliment Helenius (who just scored again)
Leroy
Agree13
Disagree6
I have to agree with you Leroy.
Finnbogason has a great touch, and finds the spaces well, he has made up for the loss of Bas Dost when he left Heerenveen.
Must admit have not seen much of him, but what I have seen he could be a good player for us.
Lets hope there is some truth in it, and its not just another false hope.
villadave
Agree10
Disagree5
Or get both! Replace Benteke & Bent?
Agree7
Disagree6
I think with Wiemann, Gabby, Bowery, Helenius, Benteke (?) and Burke, we have a host of guys that can contribute.
The clear focus is and always has been, an attacking player in the middle. And from match reports Leandro Bacuna had a very good match in that role.
He had two or three good shots on goal and was credited with the assist for Helenius' effort.
Bacuna should offer more than Delph and if we sign this amf type I think we can be looking dangerous as they will want to release the Andi Wiemanns and Gabby Agbonlahors of the team to counterattack.
Westwood is excellent so would have great competition in midfield for the first time in a while too.
Now to stop leaking those silly goals like we have this preseason.
Leroy
Agree11
Disagree0
Costaginos is way better young hungry and very fast
Agree9
Disagree3
Tonev, Albrighton, Gardner & Bacuna all looked very hungry & dangerous! I wouldn't be surprised if Lambert played a bit more 4-4-2 this coming season.
Agree6
Disagree2
Really hope delph doesn't lose his place in the startin 11. underrated and undervalued his work ethic is tremendous and good at both attacking and defending. only gona get better. a future captain the way he works so hard.
Agree9
Disagree1
Even if delph does lose his place it will be excellent for us to have players like him on the bench, as apose to the likes of bannan and ireland. There will be fantastic competition for places which will keep all 11 starting players on their toes, the only place there isn't competition is RB but I don't think lowton really needs pushing, and even herd might fight for that place!
Agree9
Disagree1
With so much quality in midfield, Lambert will have his work cut out trying to please every player!
Agree12
Disagree0
Too much yapping over players most of us if we were big enough to admit it sighning a true villa fan like lescott would show what being at avfc really means
Agree2
Disagree0
14 Jul 2013 15:24:25
Swansea bid 2.5 milion for Michy Batshuayi I think he will be one for the future worth a punt.
Believable7
Unbelievable6
What does this have to do with AVFC?
Agree7
Disagree2
It is options for villa to explore that is what it has to do with villa
Agree7
Disagree7
14 Jul 2013 10:43:36
Promising signs coming from Italy that Udinese youngster who spent last season on loan at Watford will be the man to replace Benteke for a 10m fee
Believable1
Unbelievable21
Benteke isn't leaving.
Agree12
Disagree13
This deal happening is as likely as bcfc getting promoted this season. in otherwords its just an utter joke. needless to say it WILL NOT be happening
Agree5
Disagree1
Blues and their non-league players! Pfft - they'll get promoted! once they are in league 2 maybe!
Agree7
Disagree1
14 Jul 2013 10:17:48
Villa have put down a deadline of Wednesday for Benteke to leave Villa Park this summer!
Believable7
Unbelievable6
Benteke will sign a new 4year contract this week 40000 pounds with bonuses for 20 goals and final league position, getting him to what they asked for without changing our wage reforms.
Lambert will request you to not be too harsh on him as he's head was confused on international duty.
Agree9
Disagree10
Benteke has till the start of August to find a new team. Where are you getting this information from or are you guessing he's not welcome at villa anymore
Agree3
Disagree5
I would love this to be true but I think his agent has turned his head
Agree4
Disagree1
Think that ship sailed long time ago
Agree3
Disagree1
Hopefully, can see another relegation battle if we lose him, but if we keep him I can see an easy top half finish on the cards
Agree6
Disagree4
Who are you, Paul Merson.
Agree7
Disagree1
I like the guy that has listed what he thinks Benteke will be offered to stay. This would fall in line with Lerners performance related earnings.
Not sure that it will happen but it is a great post.
Benteke has gone from Big Ben to Benny in Crossroads in a short space of time.
Agree6
Disagree0
Lol merse always thinks the worst of us I noticed that too mate
Agree6
Disagree2
13 Jul 2013 21:39:31
Shay Given has reportedly agreed to a season-long loan move to Championship side Doncaster Rovers.
Believable11
Unbelievable8
13 Jul 2013 18:54:28
Aston Villa are front runners in their quest to sign on loan watford man Matej Vydra
Believable5
Unbelievable13
There is no point loaning. Develop our own players. If we want him, buy him.
Agree11
Disagree3
I think the original poster means that Vydra is on loan at Watford and we are interested in buying
Mendax
Agree5
Disagree2
I presumed that too mendax, but he's not on loan at watford
Agree5
Disagree1
Ohh, OK
Still can't see us loaning him with £25 mill burning a hole in our pocket
Mendax
Agree4
Disagree3
He was on loan at watford, but my point is he isn't now. Anyway since signing for udinese he has played 2 games and spent 2 seasons on loan, can't see them selling him after 2 games so they'll probably be looking to loan again. Either way I don't want him, he's was one of the most overrated players last season who scored a goal every other gamesagainst poor defences in a very attacking team. I think the championship is his level to score goals.
Agree6
Disagree2
Agreed
Mendax
Agree3
Disagree2
13 Jul 2013 18:31:50
Peniel Mlapa is a name starting to go around as a possible target, also Demba Savage was closely looked at previously, a few people seem to think we'll be back in for him also.
Believable5
Unbelievable8
Someone on another thread has suggested Jelle Vossen of Genk. He is a Belgian international and his goalscoring record looks excellent.
Check him out.
Perhaps another striker from Gent with a little more loyalty this time?
Agree6
Disagree0
Gent and genk are different teams
. vossen quality though and still young
Agree4
Disagree1
13 Jul 2013 16:02:03
matej vydra could be on the move to villa park as a replacement for benteke
Believable2
Unbelievable11
Maybe for £4-5m, don't want him & do not rate him.
Agree9
Disagree2
How can hydra be a replacement for benteke?totally different type of players!
Agree13
Disagree0
Would like to see this happen
Agree5
Disagree15
Heard a lot of talk about this guy last year but by the time I got around to seeing him play he didn't overly excite to be honest
Seemed to bear out the maxim that form is temporary but class is permanent.
Also, totally different type of player to Benteke
Mendax
Agree6
Disagree1
I think Tom Ince ince better.
>Scg87
Agree10
Disagree0
Me too. only ince is a winger
Agree5
Disagree0
A few of the games I saw vydra play he started wide, He didn't look a typical centre forward to me.
>Scg87
Agree8
Disagree0
13 Jul 2013 12:10:31
Bent off to Newcastle for £5m. Which gives us more money already to spend on a attacking midfielder. Spurs are going to offer £20m for Benteke. We will hold out for £25m at the least. Chelsea also want him. If we do those benteke there has been rumours that we will go after Demba Ba. Even though I think he is a good player I don't think he fits Lamberts targets. He isn't as young as the players we have signed so far but he is enthusiastic. If we do lose Benteke I think Lambert will sign someone from abroad who has been playing well and is young.
Believable12
Unbelievable0
If trade STRIKTLY NO SPURS OUTCASTS
think about it all the outcasts are old eg
Parker, Huddleston
I would either sell for 25m or trade for lukaku and 10-5m
Also any news on the Japanese player (sorry can't remember his name)
Agree6
Disagree3
I suspect once the Benteke deal goes thru at £23mill minimum then the replacements will be Lacina Traore & Hiroshi Kiyotake and I as well as many other Aston Villa fans would be more than happy, actually quite confident and excited. An CAM is a must
Agree5
Disagree1
The kiyotake deal went dead as his club rejected the offer. But when we get more funds available we may put another bid in for him.
Agree8
Disagree0
We have the funds for an attack mid. We've made bids for Belhanda and Kiyotake so the money's there whether we sell anyone or not
Agree5
Disagree2
We never bid for Belhanda!
Agree3
Disagree7
Benteke has peaked in 3 yrs e'll be a nobody at galatasary
Agree1
Disagree0
13 Jul 2013 08:43:29
Lacina traore has been identified as the perfect replacement for christian benteke by villa boss Paul lambert, the 6"8 foot Ivorian coul cost Upto £17 million, as he's has 3 remaining years on his contract.
Also happening at villa, Darren bents move to Newcastle has been given the green light by Villa, a fee to be around £5million pounds is understood to have been agreed.
Believable9
Unbelievable6
Would love to have him - but can't see Lambert paying £17m for him!
Agree11
Disagree2
I'd love this to happen but can't see it happening simply because of his wages, he plays for Anzhi so is probably on ridiculous amounts, definitely more than the 20k that Benteke was on
Agree7
Disagree1
Lacina Traore? Lmfao. Go find out how much money he makes! Apparently 150k a week.
Never ever ever gunna happen.
>Scg87
Agree12
Disagree2
Anyone who thinks Traore is a realistic target is an person.
We have more chance of signing Rooney.
Agree10
Disagree7
Oh look at that, there's 7 people who think Traore is a realistic target Lol
Agree3
Disagree1
13 Jul 2013 06:12:04
Aston Villa are looking to make a bid for Chelsea target man Demba Ba as a replacement for Christian Benteke
Believable3
Unbelievable12
12 Jul 2013 15:26:34
Reports from Germany coming in that aston villa's benteke will join Tottenham for 25 million and villa will use that cash to buy Japanese target HIroshi kiotake an German 22 year old striker Alexandra esswein in a 18 million pound bid to lure them to Paul lambert a young and hungry team.
Believable6
Unbelievable10
From the coal face said the same thing days ago and was mocked.
come back from the coal face, we need you.
Agree6
Disagree3
Is this meant to be an 18 million pound package deal for the two as they both play for Nuremburg?
Have looked at Essweins record and he doesn't seem to be a particularly prolific scorer.
Agree6
Disagree0
If we sell Benteke, we'll buy an out & out striker, Esswein is not that!
Agree6
Disagree1
Villa's game against Paderborn in Germany tonight has ended 1-1.
Scorer Andi Weimann.
Agree5
Disagree2
Hi from the coal face yes I got mocked for not giving out names but I work alittle to close to give them out not much movement at the moment the big man is going but only if 25 million is met no less and taking players from spurs is not in the bosses plans so no dead wood coming chelsea is our prefered club with Ba coming our way more when I findout so please dis me again for no names
Agree4
Disagree4
Have looked at Essweins record and he doesn't seem to be a particularly prolific scorer - or a even a good player for that matter. Nothing here to see
Some suggestions as to the De Jong brothers in a combined £20m deal. Now those are real footballers!
Agree5
Disagree6
How much money is ba on a week?
And would we pay it?
Agree1
Disagree2
Coal face - you've just read the papers & said, yeah, that's probably about right! i'll say that's what I know! Pffft!
Agree4
Disagree1
If we had siem and luuk de jong playing for villa I would walk around naked for a a week!
Agree5
Disagree0
Adding to that though, how can it being a combined deal if they play for different clubs?
Agree4
Disagree0
Esswein scored 6 goals in 53 appearances for his current club. don't like that at all!
Agree4
Disagree0
He is as good as heskey then. fan bloody tastic!
Agree5
Disagree0
Theres a lot of talk about bringing in these new young players, why not just given drennan and Burke a shot?
Agree7
Disagree0
11 Jul 2013 08:16:18
Villa are ready to sell Benteke to Spuds but are going to have a price war with Levy, Defeo+Dempsey+5m would be ideal or huddlestone aswell
Believable4
Unbelievable34
That deal is worth £20 million at best. We should be looking for north of £25 mil. I'd prefer something like £18mil + Sigurdsson. He could bang in around 10 goals from attacking mid and without Benteke we'll need to start sharing the goals around. Maybe use that £18 mil for Remy and Chadli.
Agree16
Disagree10
We don't want their rejects!
Lerner has said he is happy to make Benteke sit on the bench for the season if his future isn't sorted by the end of the 1st week of August.
Benteke will then have to earn his place back at Villa unless he wants to not go to the World Cup - he has doomed himself now!
Agree22
Disagree2
Hell no, we don't want outcasts from Spurs, made that mistake with Alan 'Im s****' Hutton! Not again. The only player I would consider from Spurs is Sigurdasson, we were linked with him before he went to Reading on loan, and this would have to be ontop of a £20mil minimum offer too!
Agree17
Disagree1
He went on loan to Swansea not Reading mate!
UTVLads83
Agree12
Disagree5
He played for Reading before he moved to Germany though.
Agree11
Disagree1
Started off at Reading though as a young lad. He would be ace to have, Huddlestone would have been good too, but looks like he's at Sunderland now!
Agree8
Disagree4
I would value that deal even lower
5m cash + Defoe (5m) + Dempsey (6m) which would be 16m
Benteke however earns 20k per week. Defoe and Dempsey would be on 100k between them. So 80k extra a week or 4m extra. Not good business. I think that cash only deals with Spuds is the only deal we should consider!
Agree14
Disagree1
I'm happier to keep Benteke - if we use him for 1 more season to propel ourselves up the table next season - then like it or not, i'd then be happy to let him go!
Agree13
Disagree2
Guy's all this stuff about spurs & haggling was in the papers & on line last weekend, clearly they had already set out their agenda via the media, I don't understand some of your angst towards Levy in partucular, I don't think he's that great anyway (not in the same league as Learner). You can rest assured that Uncle Randy will have him in his sights as will Faulkner & PL, Villa have the upper hand in every way in this transfer, the potential looser in this transfer is Benteke. Let's wait and see.
Agree11
Disagree0
I think all fans would have been happy for him to hang around one more year and then move on but he clearly isn't prepared to wait
Agree15
Disagree1
I'd be happy to take 18 mill +sigurdson
Agree7
Disagree7
One teams outcast is another teams star. A player like parker in our team could make all the difference, he's the midfield battler we have needed an I still feel we need next season, £20m + Parker would be good business
>Scg87
Agree15
Disagree8
Levy is a great chairman by far even if he is frustrating with his penny pinching. He won't pay anymore than he thinks is right. Look at the moutiniho deal falling through or Damaio deal for that matter. To see how shrewd he is check out how he screwed United to get Fryers (seriously it's well bad). He is notoriously difficult to deal with and will push any negotiator all the way.
You might even get your wish and he'll stay this year as a deal with spurs prob won't go through because of Levy but I don't think him staying is the best thing for you either.
The reason you don't want him to go spurs is because you want loads of money for him (understandable) so it's Chelsea or city. Do you honestly see either of them actually bidding for him? Yeah if they can get him cheap but they won't pay big for him (they can afford and attract more high profile players) so you won't get the big payout anyway.
So you keep him (Happy days, Bentekkers is staying we are ok now), what makes you think he'll bother playing well at all next year? I mean he's the sort of person to go on strike then he'll happily do whatever it takes to go cheap next year (don't give me the whole World Cup thing, he's young enough to make the next 1 and I think he's more money motivated) so still you don't get the big payout.
Summary, your right you might price him out of a move to spurs but will that benefit Villa?
Agree9
Disagree9
Villa don't want any spurs player that's not good enough for them. We don't need them either. They won't pay 25m because there not that sure about him. The whole deal feels like it's going to collapse through and benteke will be without a club shame because he will be a world class player but he's not bigger then AVFC
Agree6
Disagree3
Its all well and good linking us to these players but hasn't it been mentioned that we did sign a replacement striker a while ago, helenius. I personally feel this beneteke transfer has been know / expected for a while by PL and the board as the move for helenius at the time was strange, another tall striker since we had benteke, weimann, gabby and bent along with many other attacking players. obviously villa wouldn't go public that he's up for sale to get more money but if you look back the hints have been there, money should be used on 2 or 3 SOLID players, not huge names or crap like huddlestone, players who will play for the club and do the job, then see what happens come january with money avalible if needed IMO
Agree6
Disagree1
Well if levy is a great chairman or not, you ain't getting him cheap, just ask Liverpool about the dream pairing of Barry and Gerrard. He reminds me deadly doug, we could of had
keane and Juninho but the great one stalled. You have already reached your peak so it can only go one way for you, I. e. down.
Berbatov, Modric and soon Bale will prove this, even AVB will leave. Football is broken and as a rich shiek buys a club anywhere the players will follow. Our clubs great histories were built on level playing fields. Power corrupts and these players have all the power not us working class fans. Make a stand, rally your troops to petition your board no more mercenaries and we will keep our end of the bargain and let him rot In the reserves.
Agree9
Disagree0
Helenius was always going to be bents replacement not benteke's, so it's almost back to square one if benteke goes.
Agree7
Disagree5
But to spoil the party, Norwich have bid £23mil
Agree2
Disagree9
Helenius isn't like Benteke one bit! He's more agile, yes he is tall but doesn't mean he is a bull in the china shop!
We also could of had Lampard but Deadly Doug decided he wasn't worth the money!
Agree5
Disagree2
Yeah, but Benteke wants a step forward not a step back into the Championship soon enough! All the pundits are putting it on Norwich, Hull & Palace to be relegated!
Agree8
Disagree2
Daily Benteke Gossip update.
Tottenham are to offer Aston Villa the choice of Benoit Assou-Ekotto, 29, Scott Parker, 32, Jake Livermore, 23, or Tom Huddlestone, 26, along with £20m in exchange for their 22-year-old Belgium international striker Christian Benteke.
Is Levy on medication, if not he should be. So Uncle Randy's answer will be. No Thankyou (because he's polite). Fun isn't it.
Agree6
Disagree1
Bent to Wolfsberg? Mj have you & your Skoda got international insurance?
Agree7
Disagree0
Benteke to Norwich? Really? Norwich are a fantastic club, but all that transfer money is leading to a case of delusion of grandeur.
But I am in love with Delia though, you see, she loves football, food & booze, what a woman, why can't she support Villa.
Agree4
Disagree7
Plaese tell me why benteke would rather play for norwich than villa. ?
Agree8
Disagree1
When has Benteke ever been linked with Norwich? That's absolutely hilarious. No disrespect to them but Benteke is worth more than their starting 11 combined.
Agree9
Disagree2
A big thanks to the Tottenham fan for coming on here and explaining to us poor thick brummies who cannot possibly undertsand the machinations of the transfer market, why we should sell Benteke to Spurs on the cheap
I've learned a lot. Cheers for that
Mendax
Agree6
Disagree1
Bentekke scored a hatful just like holt did under lambert for norwich, if he goes i'm sure lambert will unearth another but ederzito of brugge does look like sum player.
Agree5
Disagree3
Latest rumour seems to be that Levy has agreed to pay 25 million in cash without any rubbish added on as a makeweight-- but is there any truth in this? Knowing Levy's reputation for being as tight as a ducks chuff I rather doubt it.
Paul.
Agree4
Disagree2
If no one comes up with our valuation of around £30m then Christian is staying, from a club insider!
Agree3
Disagree3
Express reporting Villa put £30m price tag on Benteke?
Agree3
Disagree3
Might have to invest in international insurance if you're right about DB9 going to Wolfsburg, hopefully pick up Kiyotake from Nuremberg and kill two birds with one stone haha. Anyone have any news on where i'm taking Stephen Ireland yet? Hull or Stoke or somewhere?
Mj
Agree7
Disagree1
Middlesbrough it seems!
Agree2
Disagree1
Sorry mate, no news yet, Obviously Ireland is a very inconsiderate man, you would think, with the number of times you have offered him a lift, he would have taken you up on your kind gesture by now, typical footballer, bloody selfish.
Agree3
Disagree1
Ederzito of brugge is a very good shout! great player, I still think kiyotake has to be pursued and am growing frustrated as I feel the board are more keen on getting rid of the dead weight earners (bent, hutton, ireland) first.
Finch
Agree3
Disagree2
10 Jul 2013 18:53:09
Being reported that Chelsea want Benteke that much that they are willing to offer Lukaku. The figure would be between £5m - £15m. I would say great business if it did happen. Same type of player and I think Lukaku is an all round better player than Benteke. {Ed029's Note - Bizarre if true. Lukaku should be in any top four side next season.
Believable16
Unbelievable8
If true, then you will see the same situation yet again when Lukaku has one good season. he will force a move to a champions league outfit.
Benteke and Lukaku have been friends for a long time and are competitive. No way will Lukaku want to go to the same team that his friend is doing everything in his power to leave.
As long as we don't sell to Spurs though I'm happy.
Leroy
Agree15
Disagree2
Who cares if he wants to leave after 1 year? selling Lukaku would give us even more profit!
Watched the Villa highlights of yesterday & HELENIUS - you are a god! Forgot all about Benteke when thinking of Mr Helenius!
Agree10
Disagree2
Helenius is class, no joking here, i'd go as far to say that with a bit of time and a lot of games he'll be one of the greatest strikers ever to be at villa, and by the looks of things he's another guy with two feet on the ground and a good brain so he won't be in it to use us then screw us over like benteke!
Agree7
Disagree2
I said to a few of my pals that Helenius will score more goals than Benteke this season!
Agree4
Disagree2
Chelsea do not want Benteke, Spurs can't afford Benteke & Benteke will now have to apologize & work hard for Villa or lose out on going to the world cup by sitting on the Villa bench!
Agree10
Disagree2
If we play like we did yesterday in PL this season we will get relegated. that match was so hard to watch. am very worried for us.
Agree4
Disagree8
You didn't see the game so you can't judge - my brother was there as part of the 100 travelling Villa fans - their goal was unstoppable & Okore should of started with concrete Ron!
UTVLads83
Agree7
Disagree2
Lets just hope Benteke learns from his mistakes and decides he is better off at Villa & ED - Eric Kismet DID suggest it the transfer request, they were in Turkey for 5 days together!
UTVLads83 {Ed001's Note - he also told the lad he would be better off staying until the summer, that was his advice to him. What he did was say that it would require a transfer request if he was dead set on leaving. This is not the agent's fault, for once. The player is the one in the wrong, it is his greed that is the issue, just as it was when he went on strike to get a move to you in the first place.}
Agree5
Disagree0
If Benteke stays in the end - Helenius, Weimann & Gabby as well as Bentekkers - top 8 finish surely!
Luna, I was extremely impressed with & Tonev!
Agree8
Disagree1
Spurs won't pay £25m for Benteke, he'll still be a Villa player 1st September.
Agree5
Disagree3
You're an absolute person if you're going to judge our season on any of the 3 games this week, we ended up with 22 players all getting 45 mins of football, there were little tactics, everybody was told to go out there and get some touches of the ball and just have a nice kick around. None of the games in Germany mean anything to anybody they are merely a fitness and morale boosting activity. We cannot judge anything against a german division 5 team so it was mainly about easing the rust and getting some running done.
Agree11
Disagree0
Talksh**te are reporting 'Spurs tell villa to reduce Benteke's price' Yea right! haha laughable.
Agree7
Disagree1
Levy does only want to pay apparently £17-£18m for Benteke & Villa have apparently told him where he can stick his £17m
Agree8
Disagree0
'Spurs tell villa to reduce Benteke's price' hows about spurs go take a running jump. Villa don't want to sell so why would we drop our price. If he wants to go that much then its his agents job to find a team willing to pay the right price. Must be hard, he spends large amounts of the day trash talking to the papers where can he find the time to do his job.
Agree5
Disagree1
Leroy, other Villa fans.
Why is it that you don't want Benteke to go to spurs so badly? I mean your all hating on spurs like they've done something wrong. I'm genuinely interested in the answer, I'm not on a wind up.
Leroy I asked u specifically because you commented before that all other fans are welcome on this site aslong as they kept it decent so interested to know your views!
Many thanks
Agree3
Disagree0
In response to the above.
Dont hate Spurs at all but would rather not sell to them because of a few reasons.
1. Levy has done a great job at Spurs and seems a very shrewd business man. He seems to get players in at far cheaper prices eg Van der Vaart 8 mil.
For this reason alone it doesn't make sense for us.
2. Chelsea would do business immediately, giving us far more time to find a replacement.
3. Despite what many Spurs supporters may think, we Villa fans still believe that Spurs are a team that we should be competing with and should be at their level.
We were in the hunt a few years back but MON walked and then we had some huge problems, where as Spurs continued building very well.
I think we have learnt from selling Young to Man U and Milner and Barry to Man City and Cahill to Chelsea, that you avoid making teams in your own league better.
Sending Benteke overseas is probably the best option if we sell.
4. We are sick of stupid managers taking on Spurs rejects. Again, this has been great business by Spurs and a credit to them, but taking on Hutton and Jenas was completely personic.
We are still hurting about those signings that almost saw us relegated.
I think since Randy has come in, he conducts business fairly yet sternly, which is good. Being overly aggressive in the transfer market repeatedly can give a slightly bad reputation.
5. Spurs are doing the exact same thing with Gareth Bale and have done so previously with Modric etc.
Ie if you don't want to sell a player you don't unless its for "silly money".
Hope this satisfies your questions. T me and I assume most Villa fans, this is why we feel strongly about this. We feel that we are building something exciting here after the abysmal seasons we have had of late.
Benteke still figures in those plans, even if it is just for another season.
Agree7
Disagree2
Didnt sign off on that essay I wrote sorry
Leroy
Agree7
Disagree1
I'd be happy to sell to spurs if they pay the price. I think everybody is getting annoyed because if reports are right, tottenham are just trying to get rid of all their cast-offs and have decided to just give them to us with a little bit of cash for benteke. No thanks. We don't need or want any of the players mentioned in swap deals so take your unwanted players and shove them where the sun don't shine, cough up the right money and you can have him.
Agree3
Disagree0
Fair play leroy, a well put response to my question and it does make sense not to sell to us if you see yourselves on par with us (same reason we wouldn't sell Modric to Chelsea)
I think your right, selling abroad would be your best option. Either way I don't think you'll get any more than 25mill more like 20mill. Problem is a lot of Villa fans are getting wound up by "reports" spurs are going to offer this and that, but this is just paper talk.
I for 1 hope we don't get him as I think you'll get the last laugh as I think he will flop at spurs. let's see what happens though. Best of luck next season Villa your a good Epl side and you should be back in the top 10 next year.
Agree6
Disagree0
Further to Leroy
I agree with all he has said, but what annoys us more is the sly way you try to tap him up using media to price point his value.
When we want a player, you don't here anything until it is done or very close.
Agree5
Disagree0
Thats also a good point, just take the fabian delph incident as an example, our offer was slightly less than that of the other team (cannot for the life of me remember who it was) but leeds released a statement after selling to us saying the reason they agreed to do business with us rather than the other teams interested is because of the manner in which we went about our interest and the level of respect shown to both the club, and the player. This is how all transfer should be done and I can't for the life of me remember villa signing a player from a team in a negative way.
Agree6
Disagree0
Saying that Helenius will be one of Villa's best ever strikers is complete madness. Yes he looked like a good player in Denmark and he played well against a lower league German team but slow down. Let the man have a premier league game first at least.
Agree8
Disagree0
Like I said it's the media winding you guys up. Nobody at spurs has said anything and it's the media quoting all these apparent prices. We have NOT tapped him up. It's not hard for the media to see spurs need a striker and can afford to spend the money. Remember the press will say anything to sell papers DON'T LISTEN TO THEM simple.
Agree2
Disagree0
Levy can stick his £17m in my wallet :)
Agree1
Disagree0
10 Jul 2013 16:28:24
Ed, what are the chances that Benteke will still be on our roster come 1st September?
Might he do a Rooney style U-Turn! {Ed007's Note - Very, very slim I'm afraid. It looks like he wants outof Villa. I'm sure Lambert has someone else lined up to come in and help the team climb back up the league table.}
Believable7
Unbelievable2
Do you think Villa will get £25m for Benteke, Ed?. If yes - do you think all the money will be reinvested? {Ed007's Note - I think the fee will be around £20m and most of it will be reinvested in the squad but not all on one player.}
Agree4
Disagree5
Tottenham are unwilling to meet Aston Villa's £25 million asking price for wantaway striker Christian Benteke.
The Belgian requested a transfer on Monday as he seeks to force through a move away from Villa Park, but the Midlands club are determined not to be held to ransom for their star attraction. Spurs have stepped up their interest in the 22-year-old after missing out on David Villa, who has completed a move to Atletico Madrid, but they are not willing to offer more than £15m to get their man.
Agree1
Disagree6
If they don't offer £25m they will be looking elsewhere. I don't see why Villa should negotiate. He will no doubt be at least as desirable this time next season.
Agree5
Disagree1
Fine. That should basically eliminate Tottenham from the race to sign Benteke
In a market were Man U are being told to stump up £18 million for a 28 year old fullback, Benteke is a steal at £25 mil. We shouldn't even bother to respond to any offer that doesn't start at 30 Mil in my opinion
If we are to lose him, so be it, but have some bloody pride and demand top dollar and mean it Randy
Mendax
Agree10
Disagree1
We should demand 20m plus Gylfi Sigurosson, hope they don't palm us off Huddlestone, Parker or someone like that.
Agree8
Disagree3
Randy Lerner has proven previously that he does not sell good players cheap. Barry £13m, Young £16m both with only 1 year left on contract, Downing £20m, Milner £24m. He isn't going to get bullied by the likes of Daniel Levy. If Spurs don't want to stump up at least £25m (and I think that is cheap in market where West Ham paid £15m for Carroll, and people are talking about £40m+ for Suarez who scored only 4 more goals, and spends most of the time suspended), they can carry on trying to get into the top 4 with Adebayor up front. As the Villa statement said "Benteke was reminded he has 3 years left on his contract". To me that means either a club stumps up the cash or he knuckles down and stays. Those are the tactics Villa used with both Barry and Young, and they ended up staying an extra year before moving on. If he doesn't feel like getting his head down, he can ask some of the reserve team what Doncaster in midweek in January is like! He might be joining them, as Lambert doesn't take prisoners. Just ask Warnock, Hutton, Bent, Ireland etc etc.
Agree9
Disagree0
Randy does sell cheap. Downing £20m, Milner £24m, Barry & Young were made to stay an extra year and he still got £13m and £16m for them
Agree5
Disagree2
Benteke will be given 1 week when all the players are back together to make sure he can still play a part at Villa if a move doesn't occur. If he fails to act positively - Lambert is expected to put him in with the reserves. What a difference 2 weeks can make!
Agree2
Disagree0
10 Jul 2013 16:24:44
Villa are willing to listen to Chelseas offer if it includes Lukaku, and Bertrand+5m. I would drive Benteke to Stanford Bridge for this deal to happen. C'mon Villa!
Believable12
Unbelievable8
Lukaku can be better than Benteke, as he is younger - surely Chelsea aren't that silly to offer that sort of offer to Villa!
Agree8
Disagree4
Why would lukaku go to villa? His wages would be to high for a start.
Agree7
Disagree7
Great shout.
I will come with you and bring my sat nav.
Dave
Agree6
Disagree2
Doesn't sound likely. I do think Benteke is better than Lukaku, but doubt Lukaku is a player Chelsea are looking to offload eitherway.
Perhaps 7m plus Lukaku and we would have to be happy to accept given he wants to leave. I just hope he does not go to Spuds or Liverpool, as he should push for a top European club if he wants to force a move.
I think Spuds would also try to haggle a deal that undervalues him hugely. So perhaps Faulkner should just put the Spuds telephone and fax machines on 'caller block'.
Busi
Agree4
Disagree2
Can we get back to the real world now, Lukaku will not be coming to Villa.
Agree7
Disagree3
I swear villadave is always willing to drive players across the country. If you got a bit of spare time could you drive us to maccy D's. A bit peckish
Agree7
Disagree1
How bout £20m for benteke and Lukaku on loan? I'd defo take that.
>Scg87
Agree10
Disagree8
Kevin De Bruyne in return? likely?
Agree1
Disagree8
Norwich step in with
£22 mil bid now, who said they had no money
Agree2
Disagree12
No way Lukaku would sign for us permanently. But sending him on loan to us, may just swing a deal in Chelsea's favour if there was competition from other clubs
Agree6
Disagree1
Benteke is of to Chelsea like I said the other day and lakuka will be with us for a season on loan with Chelsea paying his wages for the season and have 1st option to buy after loan
so 22mill to villa plus a free player for the season
Agree1
Disagree6
So who am I giving lifts to and where am I going in my Skoda?
Mj
Agree5
Disagree0
Why is £20m for benteke and a loan deal for Lukaku not a good deal?
Agree3
Disagree2
10 Jul 2013 11:56:43
Folks. Check out Mame Diouf of Hanover. Looks like a great player with similar qualities to Benteke. 25yo. In final year of contract. good stats. could be a great buy should benteke be sold!
Believable6
Unbelievable8
The ex Manchester United boy?he was awful here (in england) before however I haven't been checkin his progress ever since so can't say whether he has what it takes or not.
Agree7
Disagree1
Wasnt he at Man United a few years ago? All pace an not much talant was my thoughts on him. Better options surely.
Agree7
Disagree3
Pretty good call. Rotated with Helenius could be good.
Then I think a big marquee signing of a creative goal scoring attacking midfielder (yes, I want him do be ALL of these!) and we could go forward without Benteke.
Agree4
Disagree6
Check douf out
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lBfcz1CIJB8
Agree2
Disagree4
Excuse me Sir, Aren't you Mame Diouf's Agent?
Agree6
Disagree1
My friend's I don't think PL does rotation, I think his mind set is to play the the best players suited to win the game
Agree3
Disagree0
Not being funny, but everyone looks good on YouTube lol they only show the good bits remember.
Check out Bosko Balaban on YouTube, he looks class still LMAO
>Scg87
Agree10
Disagree0
I agree, youtube is about as meaningful as checking a players ratings on Championship Manager. Helenius looks like Pele on youtube clips I have seen, but if he's that good how come we got him for £2m. I remember last year everyone telling us that El Ahmadi looked like a class playmaker based on youtube. My point proven I think!
Agree3
Disagree5
With all this said, youtube does still show flashes of brilliance (such as helenius beating 5 defenders and a keeper and stabbing home) and when you compare that to the youtube video's of barry bannan (all of which are just highlights of his appereance against brazil in a friendly) you can tell a little bit about a player. And also with games like fifa, champ man, fm, you can tell a tiny bit by ratings. Do you think they just assign random stats to random players? No, people watch every player and base the stats around that. HOWEVER saying that, i'm fairly certain that no manager in football signs people based on youtube clips and games, but when we are linked with a player its nice to have a browse at what he is capable of. Its a whole lot quicker than watching the full 90 mins of every game they've ever played too.
Agree1
Disagree4
Thats why clubs have scouts, so they can watch 90mins of every match and judge a player ability or potential.
God I hope they don't watch YouTube!lol.
>Scg87
Agree5
Disagree0
This is what i'm saying, its not our place to suggest targets based on youtube cause they could be awful in real life, but when we've had people look at a player and the clubs showed interest its worth a quick look on youtube just to see what we can expect of them should they sign!
Agree3
Disagree0
Agee there, I watched Helenius on YouTube, an straight away I could see the type of player he is, flamboyant, good finisher, good technique, quick ish. But of course no one can say he will be a success based on 2 or 3 mins of his best bits
>Scg87
Agree4
Disagree0
10 Jul 2013 06:30:35
Word going round is Eric Kismet has spoke to Randy Lerner and said his client will sign a new contract & retract his transfer request if he is offered £60k p/w instead of the £40k p/w offered, Lerner has refused to be pulled into his demands & has said Benteke is valued at £25m but £30m to Spurs due to unpleasantness caused by the Jenas-Journey!
Believable5
Unbelievable6
Yes that's true it will be a higher price if its Spurs due to jenas-gate also they have tapped him. remember Liverpool with Barry? you tap our player you pay the price. Lambert told Benteke he could get treble his wage if signed a new deal but Kismet said no deal. Benteke was at the airport on Monday but refused to travel on bad advise from Kismet.
Agree3
Disagree2
Lambert said he would double not treble his wages matey. £40k for him was a bit of an insult but maybe Kismet just fancies a new car & getting Benteke moves means he gets a nice one with leather seats & possibly blacked out windows?
Agree3
Disagree1
Why are most on here blaming Benteke's agent? Benteke has been talking about joining bigger clubs ie arsenal since December, it was only a few months ago benteke in his own words said if 2 clubs (villa and another) agree a fee then he'd move, so as far as I'm concerned benteke has only saw us as a stepping stone and personally I don't blame him, cus why should he have any loyalty to a club he probably never heard of 12 months ago
>Scg87 {Ed001's Note - his agent actually advised him to stay put until next summer, hence him saying that Benteke was staying. This is Benteke's choice.}
Agree5
Disagree1
Shame Kismet isn't S. Irelands agent.
Agree3
Disagree1
He's progressed really well this season. don't forget he only played 5 time at united wasnt given a good run and blackburn wasnt his best loan either. Since then he's excelled well at hanover scored 18 in 38 and don't forget germany isn't a joke of a league. I've watched him a few times last season scored a cracker against schalke and for say £5-6m may be worth a punt. Yes I could see him and helenius working off each other might bring best out of one another. Striker need to be settled and given chance and if PL gave him one here i'm sure he'd take it. United don't exactly give many young guys a deserved shot. Just a thought. Be he looked in good shape and form last season
Agree1
Disagree1
If benteke does go to spurs, he won't be going because he has ambition, its purely for money. if he had real ambition he'd wanna go to a bigger club, and hold out for that move.
Agree8
Disagree2
Spurs are a bigger club than villa at this moment in time so there is some ambition
Agree4
Disagree5
Unfortunately I have to disagree with anyone who suggests moving to Spurs lacks ambition. A team who will be battling on all fronts next season and pushing for Champions League is a justifiable step up.
He will be mindful of the World Cup and playin at Chelsea he is not guaranteed the game time he will be at Spurs.
TBH I think Spurs are his best option
Agree4
Disagree9
Completely agree spurs are benteke's best option. Guarenteed first team, arsenal, Chelsea won't offer him that.
And competing for top 4 and playing in Europe is a step up.
The way benteke sees it, villa won't be anywhere near competing for top 4 places for 5 years at best. And he isn't seeing us buy proven quality which probably leaves him feeling underwhelmed so doesn't see many reasons if any reason to stay.
>Scg87
Agree7
Disagree7
I think he would be as good as guaranteed to start at Arsenal. Unless they get Rooney, Higuian or Suarez of course
Agree2
Disagree2
How have spurs tapped up Benteke? Not a single person working directly for spurs has mentioned Benteke outside the board room. Levy does his business very quietly hence why us spurs fans only heard of interest for Pauliniho a week or 2 before we officially put a bid in. The journo's do a very good job and pay good money to get information but they also make things up to sell papers surely you don't let this influence your decision?
Agree0
Disagree3
09 Jul 2013 20:53:56
Aston Villa are interested in matej vydra and prepered to pay up to 10m for him
Believable7
Unbelievable11
Best youth player out there, personally I think he is better than Benteke Lukaku Guidetti all youth strikers. His finishing is dank
Agree4
Disagree8
Omg please tell me your jokin bro?!. if not u need some new specs there fella. vydra is awful. comparing him to benteke, please. wake up you blind fool
Agree6
Disagree4
To the Vydra loverrrr. you're havin a laugh mate. nice to have a giggle on this site once in a while though. absolute muppet
Agree8
Disagree0
Lets vote AVFC fans.
Who is a better striker?
Matej Vydra or Christian Benteke?
Send your answers to the deluded fella that ranks vydra no. 1 young striker around.
Agree5
Disagree6
I think i'm a better striker than vydra, if we sign him I might stand outside bodymoor heath kicking a football at the wall and they'll no doubt give me a contract.
Agree6
Disagree3
Well looks like Liverpool are set to join in on the Trail of Benteke Looks like He's done what he set out to do and even clubs in Europe are interested, Question, How the hell do Villa fans think they can keep him, He will be off well before Kick off
Agree6
Disagree1
Me too mate. so me and u upfront next season then lol
Agree5
Disagree0
We want to SELL BENTEKE now!
Why would we want to keep him!
We can get some more cheap gem's & shine them up nicely to be better than Bente££ers.
Agree4
Disagree2
Yeah buy some more gems 2 shine this season so one of the top 4 can buy them this time next year!! pointless!
Agree2
Disagree0
'Gems' are very hard to uncover. We have demonstrated in the past that expensive mining has unearthed a lot of zirconias.
Busi
Agree6
Disagree1
09 Jul 2013 19:26:18
villa to put bids in for mbia and diakite for xp for team
Believable1
Unbelievable13
Nothing but tosh
Agree8
Disagree0
Is that post some sort of coded message? I'm to old for all this!
Agree3
Disagree1
Im assuming it means experience.
Leroy
Agree4
Disagree1
09 Jul 2013 19:07:30
villa to get thorgan hazard on year loan
Believable7
Unbelievable9
Why the F**K would we want him? This is serious stuff, Benteke isn't just someone you can have in exchange for minimal cash and younger brothers of the famous already players! Get a grip! Benteke is innocent in this and his agent has played all these cards for the transfer request and everything. ! Just cannot see Big Chris doing this, specially after everything! Fingers crossed!
Agree5
Disagree4
No he'll just be the new Dawkins or Bowery
Agree5
Disagree3
Just because edens a decent player don't meen his brother is
Agree6
Disagree1
He had a good season in belgum
Agree3
Disagree3
No more belgums please.
Agree4
Disagree3
Please do not sell to the spuds, ok they have Bale but what would they be without him in the team, realistically we can't challenge the likes of the regular top 4, but the spuds, and scousers we can, so why sell 1 of our best players to them, we cant. I only hope this saga does not drag on and we get a quickfire sale, at the valuation we have have placed. then give the money to Lambert to get another few players in. VTID.
Agree2
Disagree1
09 Jul 2013 18:22:40
am I the only one that thinks villa should try get honda {Ed029's Note - I'll believe it when I Civic.
Believable8
Unbelievable4
Nice pun Ed :)
I also think honda would be a great acquisition along with kiyotake too.
Attendances would be up.
The clubs profile would be raised across the world
And finally their both cracking players!
UTV
finch
Agree8
Disagree1
And everyone thought my Red Brown Mayo 'Sauces' gag was bad. Thanks Ed
Agree5
Disagree1
Ed, dear me {Ed001's Note - he has had a severe telling off for that one! If his jokes get any worse I will be relegating him to the Everton site.....}
Agree9
Disagree2
Honda would go to a club that can offer him European football.
Agree0
Disagree1
I like Honda as a player. He's got a great engine.
Agree4
Disagree0
09 Jul 2013 17:20:16
John Guidetti being mentioned now, thought he was still injured though? also some talk of Lambert not being fully convinced with Ron Vlaar, talk of Cheikhou Kouyate coming in, possibly as a replacement though he can play DM too. no doubt we'll pull someone out of obscurity like we did with Sylla. still lots of people hopeful of Hiroshi Kiyotake coming in?
Bent looks set on Newcastle, apparently one of the clubs main objectives is to get Ireland off the books.
Believable8
Unbelievable1
I cannot fathom the rumours so many of you are spitting out about Vlaar leaving. If Lambert has "doubts" about him, why was he made our captain and why did he play so much? If he leaves this season I will eat my hat.
Agree6
Disagree0
He won't leave but we could easily find a better cb out there. only reason he played so much last season is because we had no1 better.
Agree1
Disagree3
Lambert's probably not happy with his injuries since he joined too, Kouyate would be a beast hope he joins up!
Agree1
Disagree0
09 Jul 2013 17:09:43
Hearing Villa are registering enquiries into the situations of Danny Welbeck & John Guidetti!
Believable6
Unbelievable3
I think danny welbeck deserves to be playing week in week out, he's a really promising player who would fit into PLs style an regime. UTV
Agree4
Disagree3
Load of rubbish where did you hear this from?
Agree5
Disagree3
Yeah get welbeck maybe he will score more than the 1 PL goal he notched last season.
Agree8
Disagree1
09 Jul 2013 10:51:54
News coming out of the Villa is Kismet has advised Benteke to put in the transfer request to push Villa to offer him a bigger wage & a release clause in any new contract! Benteke apparently is after £75k p/w & a £35m release clause.
Believable8
Unbelievable8
This is funny, Villa still don't have to budge. He will have two choices -
1. Accept Villa´s updated offer
2. Sit quietly on the bench and when he gets tired and frustrated - agree to play at his current wage.
Your "choice" Christian.
Hold fast Fatty Faulkner!!! lmao
Leroy
Agree12
Disagree1
Why would he be holding out for a £35m release clause? I don't think any club would pay that even if he has another good season next season.
I don't think many players put in a transfer request to get more money, especially in this case.
I just think he wants to leave, simple as that.
Agree9
Disagree4
They did for Carroll & I think you had hit the nail on the head -
Greedy Benteke wants more cash on the table from Villa! disgusting!
Agree7
Disagree3
He is going to Chelsea to form a new front line with Lukaku.
Agree4
Disagree11
He scored more goals than aguero, but aguero is worth more? This kid has got two strong feet and an unbelievable header on him, making him the complete centre forward. He's not worth 35mil he is worth 40!
Agree7
Disagree6
Lets not hang the kid out to dry totally - he has a contract & no bids have been put on the table table & I am hearing no-one has been in contact since. I'm also hearing Spurs have pulled out of any talks due to Benteke's character.
Agree5
Disagree2
Aguero has proven he can score season after season and he is a team player. Benteke has had 1 good season and when he didn't want to work for the ball boy could you tell. If he has another good season and works harder he will be worth more but until then you can dream.
Agree6
Disagree2
Who ever wants him would have to pay at least £25 mill according to tv
Agree6
Disagree0
Well then VillaDave, let's hope your opinion on Helenius is correct, looks like he may get the opportunity after all.
Agree7
Disagree0
I thought at the time he put in his request for a transfer that his attitude towards us may put off other clubs taking a chance on him but such things as a players character don't usually matter to most mercenary clubs like Tottenham and Chelsea. We shall see.
No one is rushing to bid for him yet apparantly.
Agree3
Disagree0
Leroy: "Villa still don't have to budge" The the club have allegedly "accepted" his transfer request, so he won't be sitting anywhere near VP, think of the effect keeping him around could have on the other players.
Agree3
Disagree2
PL really doesn't mess about, he seems to be able to deal with every thing that comes his way. I'm glad Ferguson retired when he did because had it been a season later, his replacement might not have been Moyes. Lambert may well be our best transfer in a decade!
Agree10
Disagree2
He is worth no more than £25 million, possibly £20 million. And that price will drop now that he has put in a transfer request. Villa cannot afford to have a disgruntled player earning thousands a week, not playing, when every month his value drops. Laughable to read naive fans thinking we should put him on the bench.
Agree3
Disagree9
Benteke to Chelsea / Spurs / Arsenal - Who know's?, but let the haggling commence.
Agree6
Disagree0
A few day's ago someone stated that Kismet was "more than an agent, he was a family friend", in future he can be described as a "very wealthy family friend".
Agree3
Disagree2
In response to "Villa don't have to budge" -
“For clarity’s sake, however, he had already been given extra time off until July 18 and was reminded that there are three years remaining on his contract.
"We consider him to be a Villa player and expect that he will be with us for the 2013-14 season.
“Having received his transfer request, we have also informed him that should we receive an offer within an appropriate time-frame during pre-season which meets our valuation, we would act upon it.
"But he will remain a Villa player should this not happen. ”
Now going on what Lambert has said previously, that valuation is 40mil. So unless someone comes in at that price, why would Villa feel compelled to sell to anyone, let alone the rubbish some are spouting about discount fees as he has requested a transfer?
As mentioned before, Villa will have to sort the midfield situation (AMF) asap, because once the selling team knows that Villa have received a significant sum in cash, they will pay a premium.
Hold fast Fatty Faulkner!
Agree3
Disagree0
Theres so much talk of benteke going, but no reports of any1 actually putting a firm bid in for him. I do wish newspaper repoters would go shove thier heads up thier own typewriters, sick of them trying to destabilize teams just to make news on a slow day. rant over.
Agree5
Disagree1
Re: the nonsense above. Benteke wants out, other clubs aren't going to increase fees when they know the player is unsettled.
£25 million is the absolute max Villa can expect and even that will be paid over 3 years.
Don't even try to argue that point. It's how transfer fees are paid.
Agree2
Disagree10
The bad thing for villa is if interested clubs wait until late in the window to make a move. They could be forced to accept a lower fee and doesn't leave much time to bring in a replacement.
Agree0
Disagree6
We don't have to accept ANY fee that is the point. he has 3 contracted years left. if his valuation isn't met he will stay another year. simple {Ed003's Note - It isn't simple though is it? he has now made a move which can create problems in a deal(as in he has upset his employers like he did at his last club) I reckon Villa are well run enough to get a deal done with someone quickly mind.}
Agree2
Disagree0
No, he's right. Villa don't have to do a thing. Why would we sell our most valuable player for less than what he's worth? The club can value him at whatever they want. If no one bids anything close to his valuation then he plays for us next season, that's all there is to it. Unless he does a Tevez and refuses to play, which I doubt he will because it never works. We'll hold onto him like spurs did with Modric before Madrid finally made a bid they thought was suitable.
Agree3
Disagree0
According to Stan Collymore, you would only hand in a transfer request in his situation if you have been tapped up by a club. we shall see what happens hey!
Agree2
Disagree0
As is always the case, any player is valued or is worth what ever the selling team believes him to be worth.
This is only enhanced by the fact that the player we are speaking of, has 3 years remaining on his contract.
If Villa wish value him at 100mil that too is also fine, but clearly there would be ramifications that they would have to deal with in terms of actioning the players demand.
You only have to look at previous transfers for players to understand that 30mil is not at all an unreasonable amount.
Spurs fans will argue "hes only had one good season and he is unproven", well then why do you want to buy him so desperately then?
After the ruthletvess of the Jenas deal (having been made to pay for him despite being injured)why would AVFC do any favours for Spurs, who are not too long ago on level pegging with Villa.
Agree3
Disagree0
Level pegging? where were spurs 4-5 years ago when we were top 6 every season?we were way better than them
Agree1
Disagree0
Touche!
I was trying to be as objective as possible :)
Agree1
Disagree0
Re: Collymore / Benteke-Tapped up. Clearly, Tottenham indicated their initial interest in Benteke through the media, but many teams do nowadays but it doesn't make it right. We all look forward to another FA investigation, (not).
Agree0
Disagree0
09 Jul 2013 09:32:39
Seems Bent could be off to Fenerbahce for £7m rising to £8m in add-ons.
Benteke will apparently start a bidding war with Villa still hopeful they can get £30m for the star striker. As much as I will miss Benteke, its a good chance for Drennan & Burke!
Believable6
Unbelievable5
Very happy if this is true because we will never get anything like that fee from an English club but would he really want to play in Turkey?
Agree2
Disagree1
Spurs are favourites to get him and villa looking at. bobby zamora as a replacement! I hope not!
Agree3
Disagree10
If benteke does go I think we should try steal bony from Swansea
Agree7
Disagree1
Why not turkey mate? top class strikers played there before look at anelka and drogba and villa legend dalian atkinson!
Agree3
Disagree0
Lambert will never go for 31-32 year old zamora. he will go for some1 around bentekes age I would imagine
Agree5
Disagree0
If Benteke goes I say give bent a 2nd chance but by some else as well for e. g. Defoe or Evan a bid for dzeko
Agree5
Disagree2
We don't need to give bent a chance his done nothin wrong in the first place, he hasn't moaned about not playing, lamberts just forcing him out, bent should be on the team sheet week in week out, any one in bentekes position last season would of got as many goals as he did Bent should not be sold he should be in there in the first place
Agree4
Disagree1
Dzeko? Are you dreaming! Personally I think he's an amazing player, i'd even go as far as saying he's man city's best striker, but for him to end up at villa is a bit far fetched.
Agree4
Disagree1
But if we get money for benteke why not dzeko it will only be $15 mill
Agree4
Disagree3
Yeah and he would only demand 100,000 grand a week. get real boys come on
Agree4
Disagree0
Don't mention villa and bobby Zamora in the same sentence again.
Agree1
Disagree0
Even if we could get dzeko he ain't as good as benteke so wouldn't excite me that much anyway.
Agree1
Disagree1
09 Jul 2013 08:04:45
Good morning Villa fans
News from the coal face again, the boys are away in Germany and you will have all seen this mornings papers and web sites we here are all trying our best to try and keep the big man but he will leave I do have some news though with the money we will get from the transfer a big name will be coming in to replace him cannot say as it is awkward but he's coming from the bosses contacts in Germany, possible now bent will be staying as back up. The middfieldervwe have been chasing is almost complete the boss has a few others in his sights also news that next year Mr Learner is going to replace the north stand stand by for designs to be released on the website very impressive.
Bye for now
Believable8
Unbelievable6
I remember you "from the coal face".
You were guy who said we were going to be signing "the midfielder from France we all wanted to see".
What happened there?
Agree6
Disagree6
Is this the guy that said the news came from bodymore rather than bodymoor?
Agree9
Disagree0
I appreciate ALL posts on this site and give each one atleast a consideration, but "coalface", what is the idea of even posting here with the things you have written?
I mean, you only ever posts something that is so ridiculously obscure and generic that anyone could write it.
If everyone wanted to act like they are an ITK like you, we would be forever sifting through these pages looking for something of substance.
Can we make a rule "moderators" that a transfer rumour actually has to include a rumour and maybe even a player name?
Thanks.
Leroy
Agree6
Disagree9
Things change and he went else where for a higher wage as you saw we have a wage cap here and try not to break it and you are correct it is bodymoor computer changed it we have all had it happen to us
Agree6
Disagree3
Amazingly 5 disagrees on Leroy's comment and 5 agrees on coal face. seems like someone is rating their own comments lol
Agree7
Disagree2
I agree 100% with Leroy on this. There's going to be loads of rumours flying around Villa over the next few weeks and probably all summer so it'd be nice if people could include sources or maybe just give some reasoning for what they're saying. And also, it's not a rumour without a name!
James
Agree4
Disagree2
09 Jul 2013 00:55:57
Villa are rumoured to be making a double swoop for Dynamo Kyiv duo Brown Ideye and Lukman Haruna, Ideye may be a Benteke replacement, also hearing Lambert may try to hijack Jozy Altidore's move to Sunderland.
Believable2
Unbelievable7
Altidore has signed so look else were!
Agree7
Disagree2
Lets get khouma babacar. an absolute beast with great potential. only 20 yrs old. bigger, stronger and faster than benteke. spent all season on loan in serie b and not sure fiorentina are lookin to use him in the future either.
Agree7
Disagree1
Babacar has scored fewer goals than the fonz has, and he's been playing in an easier league! As for Brown Ideye he wasn't any good at the confed cup was he
Agree2
Disagree0
08 Jul 2013 22:43:50
Benteke has handed in a transfer request! Sh**
Believable9
Unbelievable1
Absolutely disgusted. We gave him everything and he's thrown it back in our faces. I would have been happy if he'd have given us 1 more season and then moved, but no, he had to go and get greedy! So now, next season he will sit on the bench for some rich ass club and throw away his chances of becoming a world class striker. /rant
Agree9
Disagree2
Their it is now we know. i'm honoured to have had such a high class player at our club even if it was for only 1 season. sell abroad so we don't have to deal with him next season. 30 mill no less.
norn iron lion
Agree10
Disagree3
Sad news hey! Still think he is best off staying at Villa one more season. becoming another bench warmer for one of the big clubs will surely ruin his World Cup chances. Good luck Christian. Now let's cash in big time on this cow!
Agree8
Disagree0
Well, it's been coming
It's really annoying, when you get a super player, they do brilliant for 1 season, why, because every time they will go to a bigger club and not stick with the Fuc*in club who took a chance with him, pulling him out of a sh*te league
Time to repay the favour
Agree5
Disagree2
Gutted. what we gona do now?lets hope helenius steps up to the plate. we won't get another replacement anywhere near as good no matter how much we get for benteke.
Agree3
Disagree4
We all knew it was coming so let's just get rid
Agree6
Disagree0
I haven't been this disappointed, with regard to football matters, since we lost the FA cup final to Chelsea
I can't help but be hugely upset with the boy.
Mendax
Agree7
Disagree0
Hmm anyone else less interested in seeing Bent leave now? It all depends on if Benteke leaves and who we could bring in in terms of a replacement, but he is a goal scorer.
James
Agree4
Disagree0
Guys let's get real we are a selling club like everton so please get your head out the clouds and wake up. we are no longer a. Big club those glory days are gone without the billions going in like city we can just hope gto survive in the epl. lambert dealing in youth great but not selling season tickets is it. villa fan till I die but we wo nt be top midland side this year it pains me to say.
Agree4
Disagree7
Well persanolly after seeing this and then reporting it on here I feel very diss appointed, I for one would of been ok if he had gone next season.
I don't think we will be getting 30+ just for the reason he may flop next season. Remember papis cisse last season there where rumors about people bidding 20+ but what is he worth this season 8+.
I think if we get offered 22 million we will accept and in terms of replacements I expect someone to come in.
Who that is I don't know
No player is bigger than the club, VILLA TILL I DIE
Agree4
Disagree1
Have some confidence in our Villa team
Agree5
Disagree1
He benteke is off to Chelsea for 25 million and we get lakuka for season with Chelsea paying he's wages. good business for villa
Agree3
Disagree7
And now you know what it's like! ie mr Bent. Karma baby.
Agree3
Disagree0
To be fair I'd keep him, if he sulks he doesn't play and because he isn't playing he won't go to the world cup! So he would play well cause he wants to go to brazil. You have him over a barrel!
Agree5
Disagree0
Late bid for Bony anyone!
Benteke - I hope you join Chelsea, £25m & I will shout you bag at you! #greedybentekkers!
Agree3
Disagree0
Gutted. Thanks to Mr Benteke for his year of loyal service. It's sad to say I think that is all we can expect as fans these days. It was always on the cards and with teams after him conducting their transfer negotiations via the media it was only a matter of time.
Truly dissapointed but I'll get over it. Big love to all Villa fans get behind the lads that want to wear the shirt.
Ruprekt
Agree2
Disagree1
Makes a bit of sense shmiggles - if Benteke goes anywhere this might be it.
Agree2
Disagree3
Personally I don't think we need to panic I think PL and PF will have planned for this, and have a replacement lined up
Agree4
Disagree0
There is a lot of clubs wanting Christian, Villa will start a bidding war & with financial heavy weights Man City & Chelsea involved - the amount will rise above £30m + for sure!
Agree2
Disagree0
Maybe this is all just a way of Benteke trying to get a bigger wage at Villa than the £40k he has been offered? Its happened before & I would say this is what it is again!
Agree2
Disagree0
Come on - how naive are you all?
Benteke was always going to leave this summer. The indications were very obvious.
Forget £25 million as well. Now people know he wants to leave, the price will drop.
£20 million might be enough, maybe even less.
Agree3
Disagree5
Wish we could get bony as a replacement but his move to swansea should be confirmed today so too late unfortunately
Agree2
Disagree0
Ok so benteke the money grabbing pr#ck is off we have to look to the future
come on guys who should we try and get to replace him?
Agree1
Disagree0
Bony, honda, wagner love, mertens even danny welbeck all possible replacements lined up.
As for the creative midfielder wev been crying out for I think its imperative we offer kiyotakes club a bumper offer.
Agree2
Disagree1
20mil?
jus because he handed in a request does not mean we have to accept the first derisory offer that comes along.
as said correctly by someone above it will spark a bidding war resulting in the worlds richest clubs fighting it out for his services.
20mil maybe where the bidding begins but it will be the first of many bids to be rejected til we get 30mil maybe more. u r the naive 1 fella.
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree2
Disagree0
Bent got more league goals than welbeck last season who notched jus once in PL
honda and mertens are att mids and vagner love doesn't fit lamberts criteria whatsoever. bony to swansea so you want to try again there mate with guessin the big mans replacement?!
Agree2
Disagree0
After everything Villa have done for Christian Benteke I am more than just angry, I'm disappointed! The biglad has been supported, respected, cherrished and centralised to the whole Aston Villa ethos under PL and now he has well adn truly kicked the fans, the manager and the players he played with in the balls! I have a feeling his agent is behind most of this and therefore Benteke trusts him. ! Trust the Villa Benteke, ffs, have some heart and passion! Decline your request and play for us, but I fear Benteke has well and truly burnt the bridge and ruined the bond between him and the club and fans now! I can only see one outcome! But NOONE is bigger than the club, NOONE! Lambert will bring in a gem to replace you if you go! I liked Benteke, I really did, but sources are telling me there is much more to this story to come. AVFC VTID
Agree3
Disagree0
I'm sure I saw mertens signing for Napoli.
>Scg87
Agree7
Disagree0
You expect loyalty from your players but offer no loyalty back. I've read things such as "I'll personally drive Bent there myself just to get rid of him" think about why players have no loyalty. As soon as they struggle fans want them gone. Trust me there won't be a bidding war, 20mill will be a good piece of business like I said even before he handed in a transfer request!
Agree4
Disagree2
If i'm honest I didn't /don't expect him to stay. But I would just have loved. just for once. for him to have proved the speculation wrong, risen above the media hype and shown some class and integrity by staying for another season on an improved deal before then moving on. As it is he is off to Chelsea where there will be a new formidable front 2 of Benteke/Lukaku. This deal was apparently agreed days ago.
Agree0
Disagree3
Scg87: Re Mertins, you are correct.
Agree2
Disagree0
Hondas a striker who can play in midfield {Ed001's Note - Honda is actually a midfielder, his chosen position is attacking midfield, though his country and clubs have often used him as a striker. For that matter, he has also been used as a left back, left wing back, left midfield, left sided forward, defensive midfielder, box to box midfielder and target man! He has been on record as saying that he feels he is best just behind the striker though. Personally I am disappointed in his lack of versatility, about time he learned how to be a back up keeper!}
Agree5
Disagree0
08 Jul 2013 22:30:36
Hi all.
I don't believe it but have just seen that there "MIGHT" be a 20mil release clause in Bentekes contract.
This is not me saying this I have been reading on one of the transfer sites, sorry I look at so many just can't remember which.
Got to be rubbish!
Dave
Believable3
Unbelievable7
08 Jul 2013 19:41:27
I know bents on his way but 5 million that's been reported can't have that the man scores goals where ever he's played and other clubs are paying way more on strikers who have never played in the premier I know he's wages are probably why he's going on the cheap but hopefully we get a bit more
Believable3
Unbelievable0
Have to agree villamurf.
5 mil is a snip, he needed to do a bit more outside the 18yd box to suit PL.
As you say let's hope we get a bit more than the reported 5 mil.
Possible that some other club is keeping shtum on this and might come in at the last minute!
He will score goals though, let's hope not against us.
Agree4
Disagree1
Surely it will be 5mill plus add ons for appearances and goals scored. a realistic figure would be 7m
Agree1
Disagree0
08 Jul 2013 18:51:43
with spurs loosing out on villa (david villa), they have today enquired into benteke, villa to hold firm he is not for sale, but looks like this could be a on-going sage until the deadline day! would rather have it settled quick, be that he goes or stays so we can prepare either way with little disruption to the team!
Believable3
Unbelievable2
You got your wish, he's going lol.
Agree2
Disagree0
08 Jul 2013 16:18:06
Nathan Delfouneso is said to be deciding between offers from Wigan and Blackpool as offers have been accepted from both by #AVFC
Leroy
Believable7
Unbelievable1
Don't sell the fonz, just loan him out to keep gaining experience and 1st team action.
Agree0
Disagree3
He's been loaned out the past few seasons, he wouldn't be a decent eough scorer of goals in the pl, could be a good signing for a championship team though
Mj
Agree3
Disagree0
Players don't hit there peak till they are 25+ which is still plenty of time to become a first team player, plenty of hard work and I am sure Nathan can become an integral part to our squad this season.
Agree0
Disagree1
Fons is better than bowery
Agree1
Disagree1
07 Jul 2013 21:06:54
It appears Lyons Gue�da Fofana a defensive midfielder has emerged as target for paul lambert. Previously Fofana was linked to Villa under houlliers short reign, he was playing at le harve at the time before switching for Lyon. However the club will command a fee of around £5. 5 to 6.5m for his services making a tidy profit on a player they paid just 1.5m for.
Chris FT
Believable8
Unbelievable4
Aston Villa are ready to sell Darren Bent for £5m, with Newcastle, Hull and Fulham all poised to make a move for the 29-year-old striker.
Agree7
Disagree1
Would love Fofana but it ain't happenin, we simply have far too many midfielders (not all are quality admittedly) so nothing to see here
Agree5
Disagree0
07 Jul 2013 14:37:12
This week will see the departure or at least 2 players.
Given will most likely be loaned out to get him off the wage bill.
Ireland will be sold for a fee of around 1m to Everton or Stoke, again Villa want him off the wage bill.
Villa also looking to get rid of Bent and Bannan before bringing in 2 more signings.
An attacking midfielder and right sided defence cover.
Believable9
Unbelievable3
Where did you hear about Bent / Bannan - +2 more signings.
Agree7
Disagree1
Danny Crowley has joined arsenal shame he looked class. Will be a future England cm
Agree10
Disagree0
Aston Villa outcast Stephen Ireland is wanted by Championship side Middlesbrough. C&P
Agree1
Disagree3
To my mate with the Skoda, sorry to keep messing you about, I know I asked you (well actually you volunteered) to drop Stephen off, firstly it was to Hull, and then Stoke, but it seems that it might now be Middlesborough, will you still be available to assist, (obviously nothing's confirmed yet). And also the gentleman who offered an unbelievable transfer bonus, (you know who you are)? is she still available, she might be required to get him to Middlesborough promptly.
Agree4
Disagree0
I'll happily drop Mr Ireland off in me Skoda whether its Middlesborough, Stoke or the middle of nowhere. If any other Villa fans would kindly donate some petrol money that would be top
Mj
Agree4
Disagree1
Can fit Ireland and bannan in the boot, save fuel and another trip.
Agree3
Disagree0
Take benteke aswell now mate
Agree0
Disagree1
No, let Benteke pay for his own ride.
Agree1
Disagree0
07 Jul 2013 08:43:50
Callum McManaman to AVFC in exchange for Albrighton and 5m, good signing, fits Lamberts philosophy of young and talented, just imagine our attack next year.
Believable8
Unbelievable10
Tottenham will follow up the signing of Paulinho by stepping up their attempts to sign Aston Villa striker Christian Benteke.
After wrapping up a £17million deal for the Brazilian international midfielder, boss Andre Villas-Boas will now turn his attentions to landing a new striker and Benteke is high on his wanted list. The Spurs boss has also targeted Valencia striker Soldado but has been scared off by the £25million price tag and will attempt to land Benteke from Villa instead. Reports claim Tottenham will offer £20million for the Belgium international, who cost Villa just £7million when they signed him last summer, but it still may not be enough. Villa could ask for as much as £30million for a player who bagged 23 goals in a struggling side last season and Spurs will have to haggle the price down if a deal is to happen.
C&P
Agree2
Disagree14
The point is - Villa do NOT want the deal to happen - why would we let them haggle on the price?
I'm hearing they want Remy (£5m) & Soldado (£15m-£20m) now.
Agree8
Disagree1
Why would we negotiate a fee for OUR player whos valued at 40m?. we hold all the cards and don't have to agree to anything as he has 3 years left.
no way they will get him for less than 30mil
Agree10
Disagree1
I think if we do get mcmanaman we should only send albrighton there on loan to build match fitness
Agree6
Disagree4
Both Stoke City and Everton are reported to be battling it out for the signature of Aston Villa midfielder Stephen Ireland.
The Irishman has seen his career nosedive since joining Villa in 2010 as a makeweight in the deal that took James Milner to Manchester City. Gerrard Houllier, Alex McLeish and now Paul Lambert have failed to get the 26-year-old anywhere near his best form and Villa are now looking to cut their losses and ship him out to free up space on their wage bill. He had made just nine appearances in claret and blue last season and many had believed that his only way out would have been to make the early jump to the MLS with New York Red Bulls reportedly interested in taking him off Villa’s hands.
However, despite falling off the radar he is still attracting the interest of top flight English clubs as new Stoke boss is hoping to reunite with him in the Potteries in a bid to replicate the electric form he once showed several years ago.
Agree2
Disagree3
Basically mate, all you have done is quote a load of guff from the London based media
Well done you but it makes dull reading
As someone else said, why would we be haggling on a player we don't want to sell
Mendax
Agree5
Disagree0
Wigan enquired recently about to availability of Gary Gardner on loan, haven't heard anything about Albrighton being enquired about instead though.
Agree4
Disagree1
Gardner will push into the first team this season
Agree7
Disagree0
Mendax,
I like the idea of quoting, or better still C&Ping onto this site, at least with this, some of the rumours may have substance, unlike the made up drivel that continues to appear. It would stop you from having to ask where the rumours came from, wouldn't it! {Ed029's Note - We're not supposed to approve copy and pasted posts from other websites I'm afraid - copyright etc.
Agree4
Disagree0
Mendax, (Why would we be haggling on a player we don't want to sell?) I think you missed the point, all clubs want a player as cheap as they can get thus (haggling required). Until Benteke signs a revised contract these rumours will continue, Spurs (as always) are using the media to unsettle the player. It no longer seems to matter whether the club want's to sell the player or not. If Benteke decides he want's to move do you really think PL / Uncle Randy will stop him, bottom line is receive cira £30m or keep an unhappy player? let's hope he is happy to stay on a new contract for a long time and let's also hope it's concluded soon.
Agree2
Disagree1
Every Club? I would guess Chelsea didn't haggle on £50m for Torres for Villa £24m for Bent. Haggling doesn't always happen!
Agree3
Disagree0
Haggling only take place when you have one person trying to buy something that someone else wants to sell (which is not the case here)
I've not missed the point at all
Mendax
Agree4
Disagree0
Mendax, The professional descriptive term for haggling is negotiating which is why a negotiating team is involved in player transfers.
Agree3
Disagree0
Hi all.
Villa have a player some clubs want to buy.
We (Villa) don't want to sell him.
Therefore we or should I say the press have put a price on his head, and let's be honest we are not really sure what that figure is are we.
I believe Spurs can wait till kingdom come if they so desire, but if this figure is not met he will not be going anywhere.
NOTE; WE DO NOT WANT TO SELL, so how can anyone haggle!
Dave
Agree2
Disagree0
I love it when a rumour/article states that "Tottenham will look to move for Benteke after being put off by the 25mil price tag on Soldado".
We have slapped a 40mil price tag on Benteke, and he's worried about 25mil?
Spurs and Gunners are the last places we should send Benteke. Chelsea or Man City as they pay over the odds fees, if not off to Monaco or Borussia etc.
Last thing we want is for the guy to come back and haunt us after selling to a team who we should be challenging.
Leroy
Agree6
Disagree0
But we are not "negotiating" are we
That takes 2
Mendax
Agree2
Disagree0
Sorry but spurs don't use the media to make thier signings, if you look at players they sign they are players spurs are only linked with by the media a week before the signing is completed (unless they get lucky). The fact the media know spurs have funds available and need a striker is why Benteke to spurs is being quoted by the press (not saying they haven't looked at him because he's a promising player). I think the guys on here who think 20mill won't get your chairman interested are dillusional, that's what a previous fan meant by haggling I. e spurs offer 20mill, Villa come back saying 40mill, spurs say 30mill, Villa agree to deal. That's haggling and believe me if Villa get a offer of 30mill for him they will pack his bags themselves. Do you think spurs will honestly turn down 85mill if Madrid offer it? Do you think Spurs fans are naive not to think the deal will happen if this sum is offered? Now think about how naive you sound saying they won't negotiate with spurs and settle at 30mill!
Agree2
Disagree2
How is it naive that we wouldn't reject a clubs bid for a player of ours when they meet only 75% of our valuation on him? you my friend are missing the point. do you think we were lying when we said 40mil?or are u saying jus because its avfc we MUST accept such a big money offer?
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree2
Disagree0
Yes Villa are clearly lying to boost the price up. Why wouldn't they? Like previously said teams negotiate where transfers are concerned and by saying 40mill they are hoping to scare off any potential suitors so Benteke doesn't ask for a transfer if a low bud comes in. Now Villa can start any negotiation at atleast 20mill. Do you really believe Villa think for a second 30mill isn't adequate? He's not Suarez or cavani etc. if Villa get 25mill you should be happy as that's great business and correct me if I'm wrong but isn't RL a business man?
Agree1
Disagree3
You just don't get it do you?. we won't negotiate with any club on a player we don't want to sell. but your right though he isn't cavani or suarez. he is better than either of them.
Agree1
Disagree1
Look at the end of the day we will hold out for whatever price we want which is 40mil. why do people think clubs shouldn't pay that much for him? look at torres 50mil. come on tell me torres is better than benteke I dare you
Agree3
Disagree0
Jus because we signed him for 7 doesn't necessarily mean 25mil is good business at all. we have unveiled a striker who has every attribute required to be THE best striker in the world in a couple of years so 40mil is certainly NOT an over-valuation whatsoever
Agree2
Disagree1
Aston villa have put a counter offer in for Gareth bale, he is only worth 60mil but we have bid 10mil.
Agree4
Disagree0
Yes I get it perfectly fine. But I think you don't get it. Yes as a Villa fan I'm 100% sure you have the blinkers on as regards to his possible transfer. Trust me if someone seriously wants him then Villa will start negotiating and I'd bet my house you won't get the 40mill quoted. Do you understand now? Look at it through the eyes of a neutral and you'll see things much clearer.
Agree3
Disagree0
Better than Suarez or Cavani after one good season in his whole life now that is naive lmao!
Agree6
Disagree0
You could offer 50mill for Bale and Spurs could accept it and still he wouldn't join Villa.
Agree2
Disagree2
Nice to have a Spurs fan or two here. however, I think a little more empathy should be sent our way.
I mean, it is to be commended the level of leadership and overall grit (balls) that Daniel Levy has shown to keep the best players at Spurs in recent years. Often rejecting crazy money for your players.
What I don't understand is the level of arrogance that one or two Spurs have when #AVFC are merely trying to do the same but with one player.
Fairs fair chaps. he's the best talent to come to us in maybe a decade, we are just trying our best too have him play for us another year, we are practically resigned to the fact that he will leave some day soon, thanks to the ridiculous disparity in WORLD football of today.
Pull your heads in. We have good contributors on the Villa pages, so if you want to have a yarn you will get good comments here, but don't come in here taking the piss with your hypocritical nonsense.
Leroy
Agree4
Disagree0
Leroy, read some of the disrespectful comments some of your fellow Villa fans have said about spurs. There's no way a spurs fan could perceive any of the comments as respectful (not in the slightest) about spurs. If you want to change the attitude of other fans then start at home with your own fans, if not then accept negative comments towards Villa. I tried to be respectful on your other page and got berated. Also check out our page and see how arrogant your fans have been!
Agree0
Disagree0
So the idea is to act just as bad as the ones you are speaking about.
Very mature.
Nothing against Spurs but I am hoping that Benteke goes abroad or goes to Chelsea, as we can fetch far more money there.
Good luck in the new season. Paulinho looks like a good buy.
Agree2
Disagree0
No I wasn't acting like any of your fans I was just pointing out that your fans are no better than ours. Wasn't saying I posted the original posts. I have nothing but respect for your side as I've said before as you are a proper football side who run your club the correct way. That said every team has fans who doesn't quite get football as a whole. For example on our page some muppet believes there is only 3 good teams in our league. Best of luck Villans you'll be just fine without Benteke!
Agree2
Disagree0
07 Jul 2013 07:36:35
IF we sold Milner for £30m, what is the chances we'll sell Benteke for £20m?
I can not sell Lerner selling Benteke unless he gets £35m-£40m. I know that is a huge sum for a striker with 1 year under his belt, YET we can all smell he is like an oil rig - something of which the prices just continue to soar on!
Believable7
Unbelievable0
We didn't sell milner for 30 million it
Was more like 20 million
Agree3
Disagree8
Since when did we sell Milner for £30mil?
Agree4
Disagree6
£24m + £6m Makeweight of Ireland = £30m in total!
Agree9
Disagree1
I think this is BS. I know levy is a tight sod but waiting til the end of the window? Even if we was going to sell waiting to the end of the window would not give us anytime to spend the money to find a replacement.
I personally think benteke will stay an I think we will finish 8-11th I'm the league. As a season ticket holder watching them play towards the end of the season was amazing!
Hoping for the best
AVFC!
Agree4
Disagree0
I really am struggling to understand why papers are linkin benteke with a move to spurs for 20 million. whatever happened to the 40 million we put on him only a fortnight ago?do people think we will actually sell him for 20?derisory to say the least. we said 40 for a reason right?
Agree4
Disagree0
In my experience - unless you NEED to sell, the prices go UP at the end of the transfer market. So why would Benteke be cheaper nearer the end of the market!
Agree7
Disagree0
The whole Benteke situation will be resolved before the end of the transfer window, he is being offered a revised contract, if Benteke accept's it, then clearly he will be staying, if he declines, obviously he want's a move, but as we have seen PL won't mess about, it will be sorted sooner that later.
Agree4
Disagree0
I'm hearing Villa are hopeful of having sorted Benteke's contract situation within the next 7 days.
which sounds all too promising!
Agree3
Disagree0
It was 18m plus 6m Ireland = 24m for Milner BTW
Agree2
Disagree3
Am I the only person who cannot see why Benteke would be remotely interested in joining Spurs in the first place. It's not much of a step up IMO is it? Granted Spurs are currently better than us and have finished in the top 5 over the last 3 or 4 seasons but the top 3 are so far out of reach and now Arsenal have paid for the stadium and should start to spend money again in a 60000 seater stadium, Spurs are never likely to break that top 4 and what if Bale does go, where would that leave them? It is World Cup Year and he is a nailed on starter for a team with a great chance of progressing quite far in the tournament. He moves now to a slightly better team and does not fit in or gets used differently or loses form or gets some boo boys on his back and then loses his World cup starting place? Does that make any sense when if he does have a good World Cup, teams significantly more successful and richer than spurs will be in for him!. I suggest the media think about it a little more rather than treating everyone like an person and getting all the Spurs fans excited over a nothing story. The rumours just smack of arrogance from the London media and a number of spurs fans on these sites and are totally disrespectful to Villa. It's that attitude that if Spurs want Benteke then they shall have him, ignoring that there is another club involved who hold all the aces. They seem to think Lambert and Lerner are stupid, I mean the last day of the transfer window, utter garbage and made up. Easiest job in the world, sit on your fat arse, do no research and just link whoever you like to whoever you would like them to go to with no facts to back it up. Stop treating us as persons.
Agree3
Disagree0
Yeah knocking on the door of champions league or relegation? London or Birmingham? Tough choice. 40mil? Your having a laugh. Only needs him to say he wants to leave.
Agree2
Disagree4
06 Jul 2013 20:14:56
Ed, have you heard anything more on Nacer Chadli? {Ed002's Note - One time looking to a move to Fulham, Chadli is now attracting offers from Swansea, Shaktar and Locomotive Moscow. Spurs, Liverpool, Juventus and Dortmund are also considered potential suitors.}
Believable4
Unbelievable0
07 Jul 2013 00:45:31
callumn mcmanaman is on his way to villa in a deal which will see mark albrighton go to wigan in a cash +deal figure is 4. 5 +albrighton
other rumour I heard is anichabie of everton is a target for lambert
Believable7
Unbelievable3
I know many rate Mc Manaman, but I am not one of them. Intact I would venture to say that if we did actually go through with a deal for him, I would be underwhelmed considering some of the exciting names we have been linked with recently.
I am hoping that we follow through with Reported Chadli interest, as he has the tools to be somewhat of a phenom for us. He's 6'2 and highly skilled, similar to Christiano Ronaldo, in that he is fast and full of trickery on the ball.
He scores flair goals too.
I am thinking that Bacunda will end up playing some defensive mid and be used as a hybrid midfielder, to some degree.
As for Anichibe, I think he is useless and would question what value he would bring to such a young exciting team.
Leroy
Agree7
Disagree3
Its Marc not Mark firstly.
Secondly - this is his make or break season. Player swap deals never happen anymore - pointless rumour as it will never happen!
Agree4
Disagree2
I think he wouldn't be a bad signing but would hope for chadli or kiyotake
Agree6
Disagree0
Agree with you there Leroy. And if i'm totally honest, if albrighton can stay fit he's a much better player than mcmanaman anyway. When he was fully fit he was ripping defences to shreads, in his first season alone he made mugs of Manchester United and chelsea single handedly! Also anichibe is awful and i'm 95% sure lambert can see that!
Agree7
Disagree1
Isnt he injured and out until December
Agree3
Disagree1
Mcmanaman is a class player. Shown last season that he can carry the ball well and is a good crosser just needs to pass it more. Would rather have mcmanaman than albrighon. Would have to disagree about alright on single handily ripping apart opposition defences. It was mainly down to Young and Downing without them he would if been terrible.
Agree4
Disagree6
Disagree, we were getting mullered at home to united, albrighton came on and completely changed the game! i've seen him make top class defenders like ashley cole look like sunday league players. I fully rate the kid and with a full season under his belt he'd be unreal.
Agree3
Disagree1
Personally I think McManaman is quality, Its so good to see an English player with flair and dynamism, he's quick, sharp, agile, direct, brilliant running with the ball, good crosser and I like how he always looks for 1 2s around the box, he was dynamite whenever he played for Wigan, an I'd say without McManaman Wigan would not have beat City in the FA cup final, he was outstanding.
Generally I think McManaman Is technically better and has a more alround game than Albrighton had/has.
I'd agree Albrighton was good for that one season and had real potential to be a very good prem player, but I don't see him fulfilling his potential, injuries are ruining any hope of that
>Scg87
Agree5
Disagree0
Leroy, I'm lost, in what way do you don't rate McManaman, he was one of the best wide players in EPL last season, playing in a poor side in his first full season and he's still a kid. What's a young player got to do to get reasonable recognition? Chances are he won't arrive at VP anyway, Liverpool & Everton are also interested apparently. Let's hope Albrighton gets his opportunity this season and he proves the doubters wrong, his time has come to prove himself.
Agree1
Disagree0
Albrighton knows this is his last chance, but to me him being fit is like a new signing in my eyes! Does nobody else think that we'd have been a few places further up the table with albrighton in the team, playing him and gabby as wingers and benteke and weimann up front? I've put a lot of faith in albrighton during many a conversations in the last few weeks and i'm hoping he will get a good chance and take it properly!
Agree1
Disagree2
I mean to say that I don't rate Mc Manaman ahead of Nacer Chadli or Kiyotake. and like someone else said, perhaps even Marc Albrighton is just as good (when healthy/if he can stay fit).
I don't think that's too outrageous of a thing to suggest really, given the stats of Chadli and Kiyotake, not to mention the flashes of brilliance that Marc showed under Houllier in particular.
Leroy
Agree1
Disagree0
05 Jul 2013 23:17:17
Word out of London, yes I know, London, is that Villa boss Paul Lambert, has short listed several players as a rear guard action should Benteke force through a move to one of a number of clubs being linked with the Belgian star.
Funny thing is, that one of the players on that list is apparently Demba Ba of Chelsea. It is said that Lambert would look to Ba as a loan option should Benteke take off.
This may indeed indicate that Chelsea may make a bid and part of that deal may be sending Ba on loan to Villa.
Again, I repeat, this was from a London ( Chelsea ) publication and we know what to expect from the tabloids. just thought I'd add it here to generate conversation from the masses.
Leroy
Believable3
Unbelievable12
If Chelsea were serious about Benteke he would be there by now, what Roman wants, Roman gets.
Agree7
Disagree1
Now that's an interesting heavyweight battle, Villa's Rich Uncle Randy V Chelsea's Mafia Man Roman, this battle won't be about money, It will be about ego, great fight ahead. The undercard will be just as interesting, The lovable Paul V Hard to Fathom Jose, let the battle's commence.
Agree6
Disagree1
This is true to a certain extent, but what about Cavani or Rooney? Why are there ever any transfer rumors that link Chelsea if Roman just buys players at the snap of a finger like you suggest?
There have been many reports tha Chelsea have "stepped up" their efforts to sign Benteke. Where there's smoke.
I don't think it's as easy as what you have said, even with Abramavich and his money
Agree4
Disagree0
If Chelsea want Benteke then we can expect some ridiculous offer that cannot be ignored. Lambert & Lerner should be looking for another player or two plus whatever the offer. However I want to believe that he will stay at VP to repay the faith all of us have in him.
Agree5
Disagree0
Look let's be honest, Benteke is an exceptional player, of course we all want him to stay but the likelihood is he will not be a VP for the full period of his contract. He is obviously a very ambitious individual & if these media reports are correct he want's to play for a top 4 team. 30+ years ago Andy Gray did the same as did Alan Mc Inally. Hopefully he will stay for at least 1 more season just so we can all see what sort of team PL has assembled, if he goes anywhere in the EPL, I hope it's Chelski only for the reason they will pay the most, he will then realise how supportive the Manager, club & supporters at Villa have been, because it will be different at Chelsea, where the Manager is inconsistent and the owner is never happy with his lot, it might even suit Benteke but I doubt it, as stated many times, no player is bigger than the club, buy here's hoping!
Agree6
Disagree1
"If Chelsea want Benteke" response: I thought that. We already missed out on Cornelius, Altidore about to sign for Sunderland, but then someone posted that we already had Benteke's replacement (if one's to be required) in Helenius, the guy said he had seen Helenius play many times and that he thought he was that good, I didn't ask the poster's name but I hope it wasn't Helenius.
Agree3
Disagree0
Hi all.
Yes that guy was me, and you are correct.
I have seen a lot of Helenius, I have seen him probably a dozen times or more and he is very mobile guy for his height, the lad has got it all, and I really believe after a period of him coming to terms with the prem he will be better than Cornelius.
He is not reliant on guys around him he can create his own goals and finishes very well
Dave
Agree8
Disagree2
Hi All,
Some good points made here. I don't honestly believe that Benteke will leave this summer. I truly believe it. Maybe its slightly naive, but I think Benteke is (still) humble enough to understand the faith that Lambert has put in him.
With the world cup coming up, he just needs to have another season like last and he will be THE hottest commodity perhaps in world football.
If and or when the time comes that he will move on, I think we should only be selling to the Man Cities of the world.
I honestly believe we should be aiming to challenge Spurs and Arsenal, so we should not be allowing them to get ahold of our best players.
Leroy
Agree9
Disagree2
Well said Leroy.
You are not naïve at all.
You have thought about it and see it as YOU see it, I agree and also think he will stay,!!
Your other points are also well made.
Dave
Agree6
Disagree1
Maybe we should benteke, with a proviso that we get him straight back on a season long loan. best of both, any1 agree
Agree2
Disagree6
Benteke will be at Villa Park this coming season - I strongly believe that. Villa do not plan to sell him nor do they want to. Up the villa lads!
Agree4
Disagree0
I don't think Benteke would do as well at any other club and would more than likely flop especially if he goes to a club made up of stand out players.
Agree1
Disagree1
Thanks VillaDave and others.
Whilst I firmly believe that Benteke will stay, I am slightly alarmed (yet again) with the lack of communication from AVFC in this regard.
It has been a flaw in past seasons, the lack of connection with the fans that is. I think most of us could accept just about any decision made by the club, if they acted confidently and swiftly, but made sure us fans were kept abreast of matters.
This has been an issue since Randy has come in I must say.
Regardless, I feel pretty confident that we will be a fun team to watch this year and that's even without this potential attacking player that we seem to be trying to add.
I think that we may look further into Chadli and that would be just fine with me as I rate him highly.
Leroy
Agree2
Disagree2
I agree to a point Leroy, I think the only problem with keeping fans in the know about potential targets is that it would alert others (teams that is) of our intentions therefore inflating the price.
I think it would be great however if AVFC would post on their website what positions they intend to strengthen ie RSM or LB etc, and also at what stage negotiations are with current playing staff (Benteke) I think we would all like to know that one.
I also think we will have a good season top 10, and maybe GOAL OF THE SEASON. we now have potential to score from anywhere on the park
Lets hear your thoughts
Dave
Agree2
Disagree0
Ninth to thirteenth is my bet. Maybe a cup run but much easier for us than last season. If we play like we did from March onwards we should look a good team.
Agree0
Disagree0
I think you may have misunderstood what I was trying to say VillaDave.
I was referring to Benteke and this ongoing situation. Would be great to hear something about whether he is staying or not.
There was also the situation with Bent just being left off the team without word or reason. The whole MON situation was kept a secret also.
I have liked the overall manner in which we have operated this transfer window. I mean, getting in early and signing some exciting young talent of whom seem highly motivated to play for the badge.
Leroy
Agree0
Disagree1
My money will be on a RVP goal of the season as always!
Top 10 finish easily as Benteke will be playing at Villa Park next season - no debate on that one!
Agree1
Disagree0
05 Jul 2013 11:29:29
Apparently Kiyotake's agent has told #AVFC, the player has a release clause and Villa have made a second bid that had to be accepted.
Believable3
Unbelievable8
Like you said mate "apparently". where have u heard this or ya jus make it up?
Agree8
Disagree1
It has been reported today that we are no longer interested in the player so how can we have had a new bid accepted?
This sounds like utter rubbish to me.
Agree5
Disagree0
I have some fairly good reassurances that this deal Is NOT HAPPEING, sort of smoke screen to sign another attack midfielder from Germany
Agree4
Disagree1
I agree that Villa are most probably after someone else at this stage, but I don't buy into the whole "smoke screen" stuff.
I mean essentially what this implies is that Villa are dilly-dallying about with Kiyotake falsely to mask the fact that they really have their eyes set on another target.
Seems rather ridiculous to me.
As I mentioned above though, I do believe we will sign someone in the AMF role and this alone brings excitement. the targets we have been linked with have been terrific this year, no one can deny that
Agree4
Disagree0
Its great to bring in a new Attacking midfielder but we do not want to block the path of Gary Gardner & deny him the playing time he'll require this season!
Agree2
Disagree0
Well said re: Gary Gardner, I'm a bit fed up with all the speculation about transfers, obviously new blood is needed, but we do have some exceptional young talent already at VP, let's not forget them and give them a chance this season.
Agree0
Disagree0
04 Jul 2013 22:10:35
Villa have had a 8.5 million bid accepted for kiyotake, would be a great signing, has flair and a creative spark. Danny Guthrie has also been mentioned to stabilize the midfield
Believable3
Unbelievable10
Where does it say villa have had this figure accepted!
I have checked all sites for any info on this rumour and found nout.
Sorry mate just a guess.
Its seems that an increased offer will be made so you are just stating the obvious, Right
Agree10
Disagree0
Danny Guthrie, no chance!
Agree10
Disagree0
Danny Who?
Agree6
Disagree1
Only thing I can say about this "rumour" is it is a poor guess
Agree5
Disagree0
Dear Villa Dave, I'm so surprised at your retort, not your usual calm & considered response, is the inaccuracy in some of these post's starting to grate, come and join the rest of us for a beer, it doesn't stop the exaggeration, but honestly, I worry about it less afterwards.
Agree3
Disagree0
Actually that would be handy if he is the singer/songwriter, perhaps he could compose some uplifting ditty's for us to sing next season and if they were really good we could enter them in the eurovision song competition and win another european trophy That would be cool! (Nigel Kennedy could be our musical director as well) blimey!
Agree2
Disagree1
Hi all.
Thanks for your comment, It is not meant to be anything else than calm, I am just keeping it short and sweet to make a point that most of us villa fans already know.
A beer sounds good.
Just a mention let's hear a few names of people who are posting
it helps with replies
Dave
Agree3
Disagree2
04 Jul 2013 11:59:28
Lerner has jetted into Birmingham reportedly to talk to Paul Faulkner & Paul Lambert over the Kiyotake situation. Lerner is expected to make significant funds available to make a deal possible, Kiyotake is apparently optimistic of a move to Aston Villa & see's Villa as a new challenge for himself to overcome.
Believable6
Unbelievable9
If rich Uncle Randy has indeed flown in, I would imagine it would be to add his influence to the Benteke situation.
Agree8
Disagree0
Seems to be some weight to this rumour and and while it has been speculated they have rejected a 7.5m offer from us (other reports denying any bid made) sources suggest a figure closer to 8.5m may be acceptable. I suggest we .
Agree5
Disagree3
And how do you know this
Agree4
Disagree0
Has Uncle Randy brought his book on motivational speaking with him?
Agree5
Disagree0
No book on motivation, just been confirmed, Uncle Randy has indeed brought his cheque book along with him this time (top man).
Agree7
Disagree3
Dont slate me for this just stating what birmingham mail says. no offer has been made for kiyotake as yet and a deal looks unlikely but obviously they rarely get anything right.
probably bcfc fans. scum
Agree8
Disagree1
Aston Villa are set to sign Danny Guthrie from Reading for an undisclosed fee.
(c&p from another page) so?
Agree4
Disagree10
Randy Lerner has not flown in so far
Agree5
Disagree2
Rich Uncle Randy has probably bought his cheque book & chains to keep the Beast of Benteke at Villa!
Villa haven't bid for Kiyotake just enquired, but I think if we do make an offer - it'll really be upto the player as he might really feel he wants to make the jump (or not?)
Agree4
Disagree0
We'v got to get this guy! not had the creative magician since merse played for us.
Even from a marketing point of view he would boost attendances, product sales and fanbase from across the globe.
Agree3
Disagree0
Danny Guthrie? dear god I hope not! call me crazy but I think i'd rather barry bannan!
Agree7
Disagree2
Not the biggest fan of Guthrie over but he did have a decent spell on loan at Bolton a few years back.
Unlike a previous comment, I would have him over Bannan all day long (and KEA for that matter) who is an awful footballer.
I would suggest if we did sign Guthrie then it is to strengthen the squad because I can't see him gettting a game ahead of Westwood, Deplh, Sylla and Bacuna.
Agree4
Disagree2
Alright then your crazy, no disrespect to Barry though.
Agree2
Disagree0
I'm feeling inferior here, I don't even know who Danny Guthrie is, I thought he was a singer/songwriter.
Agree3
Disagree3
Actually that would be handy if he is the singer/songwriter, perhaps he could compose some uplifting ditty's for us to sing next season and if they were really good we could enter them in the eurovision song competition and win another european trophy That would be cool! (Nigel Kennedy could be our musical director as well) blimey!
Agree3
Disagree2
We'll I wouldn't call him a footballer either! But still better than little orange bannan.
Agree3
Disagree1
Okay maybe I was going a little far, disagree with the el ahmadi comment though, he's a good player the prem is just way too fast for him! Maybe he'll get used to it.
Agree4
Disagree0
Kindest inoffensive insult ever on this site, Barry Bannan will now be known as "We orange man". Mate your a genius.
Agree0
Disagree0
03 Jul 2013 17:50:07
Chelsea now in the frame for benteke, if true then the greedy git will be off like a wippet.
Believable8
Unbelievable12
Sell him to chelski for 20 million + lukaku
Agree11
Disagree7
Jozy Altidore is still available.
Agree5
Disagree10
They have Torres, Lukaku, New German signing, Ba if he stays?
Agree7
Disagree3
Why would they want Lukaku & Benteke? hint: they don't!
Agree11
Disagree1
How many times has this garbage got to be dismissed?lukaku being given 1st team football at chelsea this season so why would they be in for him?get real.
Agree8
Disagree3
They want Cavan as well bit much if you ask me
Agree6
Disagree1
With the World Cup approaching, Benteke would be a fool to go to a club where he won't play every game. Surely this is the deciding factor?
Agree4
Disagree1
If Mourinho is giving Lukaku first team football this season then why is he trying to force a move £50m + for Cavani? Not to mention sniffing around Rooney
Agree2
Disagree0
Sounds sensible to me, but don't forget he is a footballer?
Agree1
Disagree0
03 Jul 2013 09:10:42
Linked with Villa is another young Bulgarian Georgi Milanov, who plays for Litex. He is a midfielder and through the recent signing of Tonev and Petrov's interest in homebased players, we may see this one escalate and materialise sooner rather than later. Would be a bargain at 800k also.
Believable5
Unbelievable8
Gone to CSKA i'm afraid, would have been good.
Agree8
Disagree1
Yeah this is now the case, shame, good player, and great vision/contacts from the original poster. Moving on to others now, PL we trust
Agree4
Disagree0
If he's just signed for CSKA, how can we linked to him?
Agree4
Disagree0
This may be a contentious post but It has been a month since reports started, but I fail to understand why our beloved AVFC have failed to comment on the Benteke situation. I think like the Belhanda no news may be bad news, hopefully I'm completely wrong. With Wiemann it seemed there was almost a commentary, with Benteke it appears to be different, not even a comment from his agent, so I'm starting to have doubting thoughts, any one else feeling the same way?
Agree6
Disagree2
Why do people put this rubbish on here without true facts
i would be happy signing Joey Barton think he would organise the Midfield and make him Captain we need a leader
Agree3
Disagree10
"Barton" I think you have posted on the wrong team page, this one is for Aston Villa. Good luck with Barton whoever you support. Just recount all the violent incidents he has been involved in, probably why very few Managers would want him, such a waste of talent though.
Agree7
Disagree1
Before Weimann signed his new contract, Norwich were apparently close to signing him & every club under the sun.
Agree5
Disagree0
Joey Barton? you can't be serious, the guy's been to prison! If you want someone like that at Villa then I think you need to be tested.
Agree9
Disagree3
Bad retort. Mandela has been to prison. As well, what does he need to be 'tested' for?
I don't want Barton either though, as good as he can be the risk he carries on top of the wages and the insipid personting - sorry twitting, twittering, whatever!
Agree3
Disagree3
Tested for some kind of horrific mental illness for even suggesting we should bring Barton in. No sane person would want him at their football club.
Agree1
Disagree0
It seems there is nothing better than a player that would put a cigar out in the eye of one of our promising youth players along with spending a season in jail and missing 10 games through suspension. The mans a good for nothing waste of space. He should stay in france where the way of life as a whole is more peaceful and calm.
Agree2
Disagree0
Joey Barton only plays for person teams. Expect Birmingham city to approach him
Agree1
Disagree1
I have it on very good authority that Chelsea will poach Benteke away for £26 mil, and He will be off before the end of the month
Agree0
Disagree3
Interesting post on Benteke, but to be believed by us cynics your "very good authority" is not good enough anymore, they now have to be at least "very very good authority" before we believe them, please verify the standard.
Agree1
Disagree0
03 Jul 2013 09:08:48
Georginio Wijnaldum is high on PL list of transfer targets, as he is seen as the complete midfielder, the 'Dutch Lampard'. Nothing solid as yet, but watch this one very closely.
Believable3
Unbelievable7
Cant see it. he's still only 21 so will cost 10mil plus and been touted as 1 of europes top prospects for a while now. would be chuffed to bits if we do pull it off though. very quick and creative with an eye for goal.
Agree7
Disagree2
He needs to leave that league he's been too good for it for 2-3 years now. He may stagnate as a player if he stays there much longer.
Agree5
Disagree1
There's no comparison between Wijnaldum an Lampard lol completely different types of players
Agree5
Disagree1
After watching him, any club that get's him for £10m will probably think they got a bargain.
Agree3
Disagree2
03 Jul 2013 09:07:04
Villa plan a second bid for Kiyotake, Nuremburg FC. The inital bid that all the papers are talking about was bid several weeks ago and rejected. They are currently in talks with a new bid and player agreements. Expect this one to be confirmed and sealed when we shift Ireland and Bent. Touted price for the young Japenese AM, £7mil. VTID
Believable4
Unbelievable4
Its believed they'd accept £9m for him after they rejected our £7.5m first bid.
Agree6
Disagree1
He got 12-13 assists last year and scored a few himself in an average team surely at us he would be an animal. Would try 5m and Ireland or bannan or whatever useless player we want to get rid of
Agree7
Disagree0
The reported accepted fee for Kiyo is 7mil Euro. His agent had informed Villa after the rejected initial bid, that he had a get out clause so Villa have gone ahead and activated it. Also, we have accepted a £6-8mil bid for Bent in the past 10 minutes! Great news!
Agree4
Disagree3
Who is the Bent bid from and where have you heard this /Nothing on Sky yet that I can see and they are usually first with such news.
Agree4
Disagree1
Shame we got bent when we did, if we had got him when mon was around could ogf got in to a champions leauge space
freidel
young collins dunne warnock
young milner barry downing
agbonlahor bent
?
Agree6
Disagree1
Where's Bent going?
Agree3
Disagree0
Apprently he's not for sale
Agree0
Disagree7
Did Young, Milner, Barry and downing ever play in the same midfield together? Where's Petrov?
Agree1
Disagree0
Not for sale, he been training away from the first team??
Agree2
Disagree0
They did play together but not for long because Downing signed for us with a serious long term injury, so they only played about 6 or 7 matches as a 4.
Agree1
Disagree0
I think the not for sale comment wasn't about bent as it was posted on the other thread about kiyotake. But either way its wrong
Agree1
Disagree2
I agree with the old starting 11 but swap the cb's for mellberg and laursen ;)
Agree2
Disagree1
02 Jul 2013 19:10:18
Gareth barry in talks with villa a fee has been agreed with city and personal terms to be nagotiated.
Believable5
Unbelievable17
Hes going to tottenham so utter lies mate
Agree5
Disagree6
I don't see villa paying his wages
Agree11
Disagree2
Villa already said there not resigning Barry or downing
Agree10
Disagree2
Barry set for stoke mate, he ain't coming anywhere near our beloved villa!. he way too fat now!
Agree7
Disagree4
You are living in the past (as usual) its Lamberts Villa now, please explain why he would want to sign an over paid has been?
Agree6
Disagree6
So disrespectful to an ex-player/ captain. He didn't hurt your family did he? What's the matter with you people.
Agree8
Disagree4
Wrong age and wages.
Agree7
Disagree4
Barry was a hero at VP. Villa are bigger than other clubs, we don't ridicule or denegrate our ex players.
Agree5
Disagree4
Why are villa fans slating Barry?one of the best players we've had at villa park in last 20 year's. anyone who thinks different hasn't got a clue about football!
Agree5
Disagree4
Barry is awful don't care what any of u think. stop brown nosing him jus because he used to play for us. move on please. yaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwwwwn
Agree4
Disagree7
Barry was awful at villa?stop browsing him?are you 12 years old or just a sad bluenose!
Agree2
Disagree1
"Barry is awful" quote: anyone that ends a discussion with yaaaaaaaaaaaaaawwwwwn can't be taken seriously as a fully developed adult anyway.
Agree4
Disagree0
02 Jul 2013 14:41:45
Younes Belhanda has a change of heart and no longer want too be to Kiev! He only agreed a pre-contract but its understood shalke who can offer champs league have made an 11th hour approach!
Believable6
Unbelievable8
Don't want him, clearly has an attitude problem. we were never in for him. his agent and his club just used villa to try and flush out other so called bigger clubs.
Agree7
Disagree6
He denied those rumours so he's staying at kiev
Agree6
Disagree1
02 Jul 2013 00:59:32
£22m + player for Benteke bid from Arsenal! What ********! Praying he signs a new contact soon.
Believable6
Unbelievable14
Where has THIS latest rumour come from?
Can't imagine Wenger paying that much for ANYONE.
He never has in the past. He usually spends money as if it's coming out of his own pocket.
Agree12
Disagree1
If that's true we have lost him, lerner won't lose that kind of deal
Agree7
Disagree8
What hapnd 2 his 40mil price tag then? we accept this offer il be massively upset. I know AVFC means a million times more than any single player but losing benteke will really hurt I absolutely love the fella. PLEASE STAY
Agree12
Disagree3
Lerner knows Benteke's worth will soar after the world cup when Belgium steam roller the competition. Lerner knows of profits & when to sell up - to sell Benteke now would be madness & he knows it. Pointless rumour!
Agree10
Disagree3
Dont think this one is true as arsenal unveiled yaya sanogo today who is a young french striker with great potential in the same mould as benteke not only that higuain is still very much top of wengers shopping list. not read this anywhere at all this morning have looked about a bit too. hmmm?
AVFC 4 LIFE
Agree10
Disagree2
Which player?Giroux, Walcott, ox-chamberlain, carzorla?. Absolute rubbish!
Agree8
Disagree4
Swansea have bid for chadli.
Agree7
Disagree1
Reports in France say Belhanda hasn't signed a contract with Kiev and "won't play for Kiev".
You heard anythin on this ed's?
>Scg87
Agree7
Disagree1
If we keep hold of him and he has a good season + World Cup he's gunna be worth 40 so I'd keep him
Agree4
Disagree0
01 Jul 2013 19:54:24
Aston Villa now after the signature of FC Twente's forward, Nacer Chadli
Believable11
Unbelievable3
So are west brom, fulham, liverpool and tottenham
Agree3
Disagree0
And Swansea
Agree3
Disagree0
Well then, looking at this list of other potential suitors, we must be favorites!
Agree1
Disagree0
01 Jul 2013 19:30:57
Apparently, Darren Bent might not join Newcastle due to the uncertainty concerning Alan Pardew.
Believable9
Unbelievable2
Meh, information from a red top is almost always a lie!
Agree5
Disagree2
01 Jul 2013 18:58:33
bannan delfouneso and stevens all transfer listed today as part of the overhaul. hopefully we get them out soon as possible so we can crack on and grab a couple more players ourselves.
Believable9
Unbelievable0
The problem is that transfer listing them and getting someone to take them away is a world of difference.
Wouldn't it be a better idea to just pay up their contracts and let them go?
They can't be earning that much a week.
Agree1
Disagree5
They're earning a lot more than what their contribution to the team is worth.
Agree8
Disagree0
All three of them had an enquiries made about them & a bids have come in for Bannan & Fonz if what I am getting from some sources is correct.
Agree1
Disagree4
I really hope these 3 players don't read these posts, because quite frankly, they are disrespectful to them. As we know Fonz & Bannan came through the youth & academy system and have made international appearances and Stevens was bought cheaply and played U21 for Ireland. They have been good squad players, just because PL has decided let them go doesn't mean there bad players. 2 years ago we were all singing there praises "the future of youth" remember that? I'm sure all 3 will have fantastic careers as footballers, I for one wish them luck and thank them.
Agree7
Disagree3
Fonz is awful and on nearly 20k a week. Good riddance!
Agree2
Disagree0
Around 6k a week actually, that's typical slate the player & get the facts wrong.
Agree2
Disagree2
01 Jul 2013 12:05:08
The Belhanda saga is over and his not at Villa FC. N:B PL never claimed an interest!
Sources seems to imply that Villa's missing piece is the coveted No10 role ala our own Mata/Silva.
It will be one from these three BUT WHO! only PL could answer that question as the rest would just be speculation 1) Nacer Chadli 2) Victor Wanyama 3) Hiroshi Kiyotake.
In order of Preference. Kiyotake, Chadli, Wanyama
Believable7
Unbelievable7
Wanayama is a def mid fielder
Agree11
Disagree4
I think wanyama would be my preferred choice but that's only if benteke is still a villa player by then otherwise I'd choose a player with more creative flair.
Agree7
Disagree1
Wanyama isn't a number 10 haha
Agree12
Disagree0
Wanayama I a defensive midfeilder
Agree8
Disagree2
Supposed Villa target Ba could allegedly be bought from Porto for a little as £2.5m.
If this is the case could the same AVFC negotiation team, last seen on a plane from France, jump on another plane, this time to Portugal and earn their money this time, if this price is correct, the lad's an absolute bargain. Please hurry as offer won't last for long.
Agree5
Disagree1
Any news on Steer signing today?
Agree2
Disagree0
Aston Villa and Premier League rivals Stoke have been linked with a £2.5million move for Senegal defender Abdoulaye Ba, 22, who plays for Portuguese giants Porto.
Aston Villa could face competition from top-flight compatriots Swansea to land £8.5million-rated Twente forward Nacer Chadli, after the Swans dropped their interest in Wilfried Bony.
Agree5
Disagree0
The 2 players being looked are ba and chadli either would be excellent but for 2.5mil ba would be a steal but he is being linked with both Milan clubs and galatasary so it's not looking promising
Agree5
Disagree2